前交叉韧带足板解剖:三维与二维MRI评估及部分患者关节镜对照
回顾性纳入101例膝关节MRI(男43例、女66例,年龄39.5±11.9岁),比较2D与3D MRI测量胫骨-前交叉韧带(T-ACL)及半月板间韧带-前交叉韧带(IM-ACL)距离,并在18例关节镜患者中与术中测量对照;2D与3D测量差值小,关节镜下IML-ACL均值更接近3D MRI,T-ACL均值更接近2D MRI。
要点
- 2D与3D MRI测量T-ACL及IM-ACL的组间平均差值均小于1.2 mm,可重复性良好。
- 关节镜下IML-ACL均值更接近3D MRI测量,T-ACL均值更接近2D MRI测量。
- 2D与3D MRI均可用于勾勒前交叉韧带足板解剖,辅助术前规划。
核心结论
- 2D与3D MRI测量胫骨或半月板间韧带边缘至ACL的距离均显示良好的阅片者间信度,且两种方法间平均差值小。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性连续纳入101例同时行2D和3D MRI的膝关节MRI(男43例、女66例,年龄39.5±11.9岁),并在18例接受膝关节镜的患者中由骨科医生用标准标尺测定T-ACL和IML-ACL距离进行对照。
诊断标准与关键数值
- T-ACL:阅片者1的2D与3D测量平均差值为1.17 mm,阅片者2为1.03 mm。
- IM-ACL:阅片者1和阅片者2的2D与3D测量平均差值均为0.65 mm。
- 2D测量T-ACL和IM-ACL在两位阅片者中均大于3D测量。
- 阅片者间信度:2D为0.81-0.96(优秀),3D为0.59-0.90(一般至优秀)。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVES: ACL reconstruction tunnel location is an important predictor for outcomes after surgery. The aim was to establish 3D and 2D MRI radiological measurements for native ACL tibial footprint that can provide information to facilitate pre-operative planning for anatomical graft placement. The measurements were also correlated in a subset of patients on arthroscopy.
METHODS: Retrospective evaluation of a consecutive series of knee MRIs with both 2D and 3D MR imaging was performed in 101 patients with 43 men and 66 women and ages 39.5 ± 11.9 years. Two measurements were obtained, tibial to ACL and intermeniscal ligament to ACL (T-ACL) and (IM-ACL), respectively. In a cohort of 18 patients who underwent knee arthroscopy, the T-ACL and IML-ACL distances were also determined by an orthopedic surgeon using a standard scale. ICC, Pearson correlation, and Bland-Altman plot were generated.
RESULTS: For readers 1 and 2, the mean differences between 2D and 3D measurements of T-ACL and IM-ACL were 1.17 and 1.03 mm and 0.65 and 0.65 mm, respectively. The 2D measurements of T-ACL and IM-ACL were larger than the 3D measurements for both readers. The inter-reader reliability was excellent on 2D (0.81-0.96) and fair to excellent on 3D MRI (0.59-0.90). The mean arthroscopic IML-ACL was closer to that of 3D MRI compared to 2D MRI. The mean arthroscopic T-ACL was closer to 2D MRI than 3D MRI.
CONCLUSIONS: Both 2D and 3D MRI show inter-reader reliability with small inter-modality mean differences in the measurements from the tibial or inter-meniscal ligament margins.
KEY POINTS: • The mean differences between 2D and 3D measurements of tibia-ACL and intermeniscal ligament-ACL are small (< 1.2 mm). • As compared to arthroscopy, the mean T-ACL and IML-ACL were closer to measurements from 2D and 3D MRI, respectively. • Both 2D and 3D MRI can be reliably used to delineate ACL foot plate anatomy.
引用
- Nguyen, Haider, Tietze, et al. Anterior cruciate ligament foot plate anatomy: 3-dimensional and 2-dimensional MRI evaluation with arthroscopy assessment in a subset of patients. Eur Radiol. 2022. PMID: 35713663. doi:10.1007/s00330-022-08920-2
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。