双能CT碘浓度与衰减测量定量准确性的多厂商体模比较研究
该体模研究比较了来自3个厂商的7台双能CT扫描仪共12种配置(含不同管电压、辐射剂量10/20/30 mGy及多种重建算法)对碘浓度和衰减测量的定量准确性;结果显示碘浓度平均绝对百分比误差为4.62%–28.55%,衰减为10.21%–26.33%,第三代快速切换和双源扫描仪准确性高于各自前代及所评估的单台双层探测器扫描仪,采用深度学习图像重建的第三代快速切换扫描仪准确性最高。
要点
- 不同厂商、平台和代际的双能CT配置间定量准确性存在差异,阅片时应予认识。
- 第三代快速切换和双源扫描仪的碘浓度与衰减测量准确性高于各自前代及所评估的双层探测器扫描仪。
- 采用深度学习图像重建的第三代快速切换扫描仪碘浓度MAPEiodine为4.62%±3.87%、衰减MAPEHU为10.21%±11.43%,为所有配置中最高准确性。
核心结论
- 双能CT定量准确性因厂商、平台、代际及采集和重建参数而异,深度学习图像重建可能改善定量准确性。
研究设计与样本
- 体模研究,使用含7个不同碘浓度插入物及软组织、脂肪插入物的双能CT质控体模,在7台来自3个厂商的双能CT扫描仪上以12种配置扫描,技术包括快速切换、双源和双层探测器,辐射剂量为10、20、30 mGy,重建算法包括滤波反投影、中等和高强度迭代重建及深度学习图像重建。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 碘浓度平均绝对百分比误差(MAPEiodine,测量误差绝对值与标称值之比的平均,越低准确性越好)范围为4.62%–28.55%。
- 虚拟单能图像衰减平均绝对百分比误差(MAPEHU,40、70、100、140 keV)范围为10.21%–26.33%。
- 采用深度学习图像重建的第三代快速切换扫描仪MAPEiodine为4.62%±3.87%、MAPEHU为10.21%±11.43%。
- 总体MAPEiodine受扫描仪配置(F=450.0,p<.001)和碘浓度(F=211.0,p<.001)显著影响。
- 总体MAPEHU受扫描仪配置(F=233.5,p<.001)、辐射剂量(F=14.9,p<.001)、VMI能级(F=1959.4,p<.001)和材料密度(F=411.5,p<.001)显著影响;12种配置中有5种辐射剂量与MAPEHU显著相关。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 临床实践中进行双能CT定量评估时,应认识到不同扫描仪间测量差异。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
BACKGROUND. Studies comparing accuracy of quantification by dual-energy CT (DECT) scanners have been limited by small numbers of scanners evaluated and narrow ranges of scanning conditions. OBJECTIVE. The purpose of this study was to compare DECT scanners of varying vendors, technologies, and generations in terms of the accuracy of iodine concentration and attenuation measurements. METHODS. A DECT quality-control phantom was designed to contain seven inserts of varying iodine concentrations as well as soft-tissue and fat inserts. The phantom underwent DECT using 12 different scanner configurations based on seven different DECT scanners from three vendors, with additional variation in tube voltage settings. Technologies included rapid-switching, dual-source, and dual-layer detector DECT. Scans also used three radiation dose levels (10, 20, and 30 mGy) and multiple reconstruction algorithms (filtered back projection, medium and high iterative reconstruction, and deep learning image reconstruction [DLIR]). The mean absolute percentage error (MAPE, representing the absolute ratio of measured error to nominal values on average; lower values indicate better accuracy) was calculated for iodine concentration on iodine maps (MAPEiodine) and attenuation on virtual monochromatic images (VMIs) using 40, 70, 100, and 140 keV (MAPEHU). Linear mixed models were used to explore factors affecting quantification accuracy. RESULTS. MAPEiodine and MAPEHU ranged 4.62-28.55% and 10.21-26.33%, respectively, across scanner configurations. Accuracies of iodine concentration and attenuation measurements were higher for third-generation rapid-switching and dual-source scanners in comparison with respective earlier-generation scanners and the single evaluated dual-layer detector scanner. Among all configurations, the third-generation rapid-switching scanner using DLIR had the highest quantification accuracy for iodine concentration (MAPEiodine, 4.62% ± 3.87%) and attenuation (MAPEHU, 10.21% ± 11.43%). Overall, MAPEiodine was significantly affected by scanner configuration (F = 450.0, p < .001) and iodine concentration (F = 211.0, p < .001). Overall, MAPEHU was significantly affected by scanner configuration (F = 233.5, p < .001), radiation dose (F = 14.9, p < .001), VMI energy level (F = 1959.4, p < .001), and material density (F = 411.5, p < .001); radiation dose was significantly associated with MAPEHU for five of 12 individual configurations. CONCLUSION. Quantification accuracy varied among DECT configurations of varying vendors, platforms, and generations and was affected by acquisition and reconstruction parameters. DLIR may improve quantification accuracy. CLINICAL IMPACT. The interscanner differences in DECT-based measurements should be recognized when quantitative evaluation is performed by DECT in clinical practice.
引用
- Chen, Zhong, Wang, et al. Multivendor Comparison of Quantification Accuracy of Iodine Concentration and Attenuation Measurements by Dual-Energy CT: A Phantom Study. AJR Am J Roentgenol. 2022. PMID: 35674353. doi:10.2214/AJR.22.27753
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。