在学术性腹部放射学实践中实施同行学习项目并与传统同行评议系统进行比较
该回顾性研究将基于评分的传统同行评议(2016年4月至2020年9月,16次会话共172例)与教育导向的同行学习项目(2020年10月至2021年10月,7次会话共52例)进行比较,发现同行学习项目全部52例均构成学习机会(每年48次),而同行评议仅16例(每年3.6次)为学习机会,结论认为教育导向的同行学习项目提供了持续质量改进平台并产生更多学习机会。
要点
- 同行评议中仅3例(1.8%)为显著差异,13例(7.6%)为次要差异。
- 同行学习提交病例中29例(56%)为值得进一步讨论的有趣或挑战性病例,18例(35%)为差异病例,5例(10%)为优秀判读。
核心结论
- 教育导向的同行学习项目提供了持续质量改进平台,与基于评分的同行评议相比产生了显著更多的学习机会。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性研究,比较2020年9月前基于评分的同行评议模型与2020年10月起实施并仅使用的同行学习模型;同行评议在2016年4月至2020年9月间16次会话共回顾172例,同行学习在2020年10月至2021年10月间7次会话共提交64例、回顾52例。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 同行评议中,将共识判读与原始报告比较以分类每例并计算显著与次要差异率,仅差异病例视为学习机会,172例中显著差异3例(1.8%)、次要差异13例(7.6%),共16个学习机会(每年3.6次)。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 同行学习由协调员在隐藏提交者和判读放射科医师身份的情况下向小组展示每例,并在各阶段邀请讨论;同行学习全部52例展示病例均构成学习机会(每年48次)。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVE: The purpose of this study was to transition from a traditional score-based peer-review system to an education-oriented peer-learning program in our academic abdominal radiology practice.
MATERIAL AND METHODS: This retrospective study compared our experience with a score-based peer-review model used prior to September 2020 and a peer-learning model implemented and used exclusively beginning in October of 2020. In peer review, a web-based peer-review tool randomly generated a list of cases, which were blindly reviewed in consensus. Comparison of the consensus interpretation with the original report was used to categorize each reviewed case and to calculate the rates of significant and minor discrepancies. Only cases with a discrepancy were considered to represent a learning opportunity. In peer learning, faculty prospectively identified and submitted cases for review in several categories, including case interpretations with a discrepancy from subsequent opinion or result, interpretations considered to represent a great call, and interesting or challenging cases meriting further discussion. The peer-learning coordinator showed each case to the group in a manner which blinded the group to both submitting and interpreting radiologist and invited discussion during various stages of the case.
RESULTS: During peer review, a total of 172 cases were reviewed over 16 sessions occurring between April 2016 and September 2020. Only 3 cases (1.8%) yielded significant discrepancies whereas 13 (7.6%) yielded minor discrepancies, representing a total of 16 learning opportunities (3.6 per year). In peer learning, 64 cases were submitted and 52 reviewed over 7 sessions occurring between October 2020 and October 2021. 29 (56%) were submitted as an interesting or challenging case meriting further discussion, 18 (35%) were submitted for a discrepancy, and 5 (10%) were submitted for a great call. All 52 presented cases represented learning opportunities (48 per year).
CONCLUSION: An education-focused peer-learning program provided a platform for continuous quality improvement and yielded substantially more learning opportunities compared to score-based peer review.
引用
- Ludwig, Strnad, Bierhals, et al. Implementation of a peer-learning program in an academic abdominal radiology practice and comparison with a traditional peer-review system. Abdom Radiol (NY). 2022. PMID: 35482105. doi:10.1007/s00261-022-03523-3
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。