经阴道超声与CT在急诊非妊娠绝经前女性中的比较:两次检查均进行时第二次检查的临床影响
纳入200例因急性盆腔或下腹部症状就诊于急诊的非妊娠绝经前女性,均行经阴道超声(TVUS)和腹盆腔CT。先TVUS后CT组中,CT在26%(28/107)提供了关键的新诊断或替代诊断;先CT后TVUS组中,TVUS仅1/93例(1%)提供相关新诊断或替代诊断(p < 0.001)。TVUS后CT常发现非妇科病因,而CT后TVUS的主要获益是更自信地排除卵巢扭转。
要点
- TVUS阴性后行CT,26%(28/107)可提供关键新诊断或替代诊断,多为非妇科病因。
- CT后行TVUS,仅1/93例(1%)提供相关新诊断或替代诊断。
- CT不确定时,TVUS在32例(34%)进一步排除卵巢扭转或附件病变。
核心结论
- TVUS阴性后行CT常发现非妇科急性病因;CT后TVUS的主要获益是更自信地排除卵巢扭转。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性分析200例连续非妊娠绝经前女性(平均31.8岁,范围18-49岁),12个月内均行急诊TVUS和腹盆腔CT;107例先TVUS后CT,93例先CT;由两名腹部放射科医生评估第二次检查的额外临床影响。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 先TVUS后CT组:CT在26%(28/107)提供关键新诊断或替代诊断。
- 先CT后TVUS组:TVUS在1/93例(1%)提供相关新诊断或替代诊断(p < 0.001)。
- TVUS初始正常或仅提及偶然发现者占69%(74/107),后续CT在25例(34%)确立非妇科胃肠或泌尿生殖病因。
- CT判为正常者占37%(34/93),TVUS未增加新信息。
- CT不确定或模棱两可时,TVUS在32例(34%)进一步排除卵巢扭转或附件病变。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVE: To determine the clinical impact of the second examination when both CT and TVUS are obtained in the same ED visit for acute pelvic/lower abdominal symptoms in non-pregnant premenopausal women.
METHODS: 200 consecutive non-pregnant premenopausal women (mean age, 31.8 years; range, 18-49 years) who underwent both ED-based TVUS and abdominopelvic CT evaluation for acute symptoms over a 12 month period were included; 107 women had TVUS first, followed by CT; 93 women had CT first. All relevant clinical, radiologic, and pathologic findings were reviewed to establish a final diagnosis. Any additional clinical impact provided by the second imaging test was assessed by two experienced abdominal radiologists.
RESULTS: Initial TVUS was interpreted as normal (n = 63) or mentioned incidental findings (n = 11) in 69% (74/107); subsequent CT established a non-gynecologic GI/GU etiology in 25 (34%). For 37% (34/93) of CT exams interpreted as normal, TVUS added no new information. In 32 cases (34%), TVUS further excluded ovarian torsion/adnexal pathology when initial CT was indeterminate/equivocal. Overall, CT following TVUS provided a key new or alternative diagnosis in 26% (28/107), whereas TVUS after CT provided a relevant new/alternative diagnosis in only 1/93 cases (p < 0.001). In nine cases (8%), CT confirmed a positive US diagnosis but detected relevant additional diagnostic information.
CONCLUSION: CT following negative TVUS frequently identified a non-gynecologic cause of acute pelvic or lower abdominal symptoms in non-pregnant premenopausal women, whereas the main benefit of TVUS after CT was more confident exclusion of ovarian torsion.
引用
- Viers, Lubner, Pickhardt, et al. Transvaginal US vs. CT in non-pregnant premenopausal women presenting to the ED: clinical impact of the second examination when both are performed. Abdom Radiol (NY). 2022. PMID: 35394154. doi:10.1007/s00261-022-03504-6
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。