无对比剂全心冠状动脉MRA:以冠状动脉造影为参考的前瞻性个体内比较1.5-T SSFP与3-T Dixon水脂分离GRE方法
前瞻性纳入44例中高冠心病风险患者,在冠状动脉造影前均行1.5-T SSFP与3-T Dixon GRE无对比剂全心冠状动脉MRA。3-T Dixon GRE的图像质量、可见节段比例及诊断敏感度和特异度均高于1.5-T SSFP,尤其在远段及分支节段。
要点
- 3-T Dixon GRE整体图像质量评分4.0±1.1高于1.5-T SSFP的3.0±1.2。
- 3-T Dixon GRE分支节段可见比例93.1%高于1.5-T SSFP的77.2%。
- 3-T Dixon GRE远段及分支节段敏感度89.7%高于1.5-T SSFP的75.9%。
核心结论
- 无对比剂冠状动脉MRA中,3-T Dixon GRE的图像质量和诊断效能均优于1.5-T SSFP,尤其在远段及分支节段;作者认为该技术可能优于当前临床标准的1.5-T SSFP技术。
研究设计与样本
- 前瞻性个体内比较研究,纳入44例(27男17女,平均年龄59±8岁)中高冠心病风险患者,均在冠状动脉造影前接受1.5-T SSFP与3-T Dixon GRE无对比剂全心冠状动脉MRA,以冠状动脉造影为参考标准。
关键影像表现/征象
- 3-T Dixon GRE整体图像质量评分4.0±1.1高于1.5-T SSFP的3.0±1.2。
- 3-T Dixon GRE全节段可见比例96.7%高于1.5-T SSFP的88.9%,远段96.9%高于90.1%,分支节段93.1%高于77.2%。
- 3-T Dixon GRE整体表观CNR 93.2±29.2高于1.5-T SSFP的80.8±27.9。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 图像质量采用1-5分主观评分,5分为最高图像质量。
- 以冠状动脉造影为参考,3-T Dixon GRE vs 1.5-T SSFP的敏感度与特异度:按血管分析87.9% vs 77.3%与83.3% vs 60.6%。
- 按节段分析敏感度与特异度:3-T Dixon GRE 84.6% vs 1.5-T SSFP 74.8%与90.9% vs 79.6%。
- 远段及分支节段分析敏感度与特异度:3-T Dixon GRE 89.7% vs 1.5-T SSFP 75.9%与89.7% vs 73.7%。
- 观察者间一致性:图像质量kappa 0.85,节段可见性kappa 0.85,狭窄kappa 0.83,表观CNR组内相关系数0.92。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 作者认为3-T Dixon GRE技术可能优于当前临床标准的1.5-T SSFP技术用于无对比剂冠状动脉MRA。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
BACKGROUND. Coronary MRA is commonly performed at 1.5 T using SSFP acquisitions. Coronary MRA performed at 3 T using SSFP is limited due to impaired fat suppression and has been typically investigated using contrast-enhanced techniques. A Dixon fat-water separation gradient-recalled echo (GRE) method may enable high-quality unenhanced 3-T coronary MRA. OBJECTIVE. The purpose of this study was to compare 1.5-T SSFP and 3-T Dixon water-fat separation GRE methods for unenhanced whole-heart coronary MRA in patients with suspected coronary artery disease (CAD). METHODS. This prospective study included 44 patients (27 men and 17 women; mean age, 59 ± 8 [SD] years) with an intermediate to high risk of CAD who underwent both 1.5-T SSFP and 3-T Dixon GRE coronary MRA examinations before undergoing coronary angiography (CAG). Two radiologists independently assessed coronary arteries in terms of subjective image quality (on a scale of 1-5, with 5 denoting the highest image quality), number of visible segments, apparent contrast-to-noise ratio (CNR; vs myocardium), and presence of significant stenoses. Methods were compared using the mean of the readers' values for apparent CNR and using consensus interpretations for other measures. CAG served as the reference standard for detecting the presence of stenoses. RESULTS. Expressed as a kappa coefficient, interobserver agreement was 0.85 for image quality, 0.85 for segment visibility, and 0.83 for stenosis, and expressed as an intraclass correlation coefficient, interobserver agreement was 0.92 for apparent CNR. The mean overall image quality score was 4.0 ± 1.1 for 3-T Dixon GRE versus 3.0 ± 1.2 for 1.5-T SSFP. The percentage of visible segments for 3-T Dixon GRE versus 1.5-T SSFP was 96.7% versus 88.9% for all segments, 96.9% versus 90.1% for distal segments, and 93.1% versus 77.2% for branch segments. The mean overall apparent CNR was 93.2 ± 29.2 for 3-T Dixon GRE versus 80.8 ± 27.9 for 1.5-T SSFP. The 3-T Dixon GRE method, compared with the 1.5-T SSFP method, showed higher sensitivity and specificity in per-vessel analysis (87.9% vs 77.3% and 83.3% vs 60.6%, respectively), per-segment analysis (84.6% vs 74.8% and 90.9% vs 79.6%, respectively), and per-segment analysis of distal and branch segments (89.7% vs 75.9% and 89.7% vs 73.7%, respectively). CONCLUSION. For unenhanced coronary MRA, 3-T unenhanced Dixon GRE had better image quality and diagnostic performance than 1.5-T SSFP, particularly for distal and branch segments. CLINICAL IMPACT. The 3-T Dixon GRE technique may be preferred to the current clinical standard of the 1.5-T SSFP technique for unenhanced coronary MRA.
引用
- Tian, Zhao, Wang, et al. Unenhanced Whole-Heart Coronary MRA: Prospective Intraindividual Comparison of 1.5-T SSFP and 3-T Dixon Water-Fat Separation GRE Methods Using Coronary Angiography as Reference. AJR Am J Roentgenol. 2022. PMID: 35293232. doi:10.2214/AJR.21.27292
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。