MRI上前列腺体积预测:工具、准确性与变异性
本研究由7名独立放射科医生在3T 3D T2加权MRI上,对40例未经治疗的前列腺癌患者分别采用传统椭球公式、双近似椭球公式和手动平面测量法估计前列腺体积及PSA密度。手动平面测量法重复性最高、变异性最低;传统椭球公式与手动平面测量法一致性高但轻度高估体积;双近似椭球公式解剖标志更精确但读者间变异性更高。
要点
- 手动平面测量法读者间重复性最高(ICC=0.999),是前列腺体积评估及PSA密度计算的稳健方法。
- 传统椭球公式与手动平面测量法一致性高,但显著高估前列腺体积(+1.91 cm3,P=0.03)。
- 读者间体积变异可导致按PSAd>0.15 ng/mL标准分类不一致,手动平面测量法2例(5%)、传统椭球公式7例(17.5%)、双近似椭球公式9例(22.5%)。
核心结论
- 椭球公式与手动平面测量法测量前列腺体积均高度可重复;手动平面测量法变异性最低,是前列腺体积评估和PSAd计算的稳健方法;传统椭球公式与手动平面测量法高度一致但轻度高估体积;双近似椭球公式解剖标志更精确、体积估计更准确,但读者间变异性更高。
研究设计与样本
- 多读者研究,从本地数据库选取40例未经治疗的行前列腺MRI患者,由7名独立放射科医生在3T 3D T2加权MRI上分别用传统椭球公式、双近似椭球公式和手动平面测量法(作为参考标准)估计前列腺体积及对应PSA密度,采用混合模型基内相关系数计算读者内和读者间变异性。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 传统椭球公式、双近似椭球公式和手动平面测量法的平均体积分别为67.00±36.61 cm3、66.07±35.03 cm3和64.77±38.27 cm3;传统椭球公式和双近似椭球公式均高估体积,前者差异显著(+1.91 cm3,IQ=[-0.33 cm3, 5.07 cm3],P=0.03);读者内和读者间ICC均>0.90,手动平面测量法读者间ICC=0.999;读者间体积变异导致按PSAd>0.15 ng/mL分类不一致的例数分别为手动平面测量法2例(5%)、传统椭球公式7例(17.5%)、双近似椭球公式9例(22.5%)。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 手动平面测量法读者间变异性最低,适合用于前列腺体积评估和PSAd计算;椭球公式准确且可重复,但读者间变异性更高;传统椭球公式倾向于高估前列腺体积;双近似椭球公式采用更精确的解剖标志,体积估计更准确,但变异性更高。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVE: A reliable estimation of prostate volume (PV) is essential to prostate cancer management. The objective of our multi-rater study was to compare intra- and inter-rater variability of PV from manual planimetry and ellipsoid formulas.
METHODS: Forty treatment-naive patients who underwent prostate MRI were selected from a local database. PV and corresponding PSA density (PSAd) were estimated on 3D T2-weighted MRI (3 T) by 7 independent radiologists using the traditional ellipsoid formula (TEF), the newer biproximate ellipsoid formula (BPEF), and the manual planimetry method (MPM) used as ground truth. Intra- and inter-rater variability was calculated using the mixed model-based intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC).
RESULTS: Mean volumes were 67.00 (± 36.61), 66.07 (± 35.03), and 64.77 (± 38.27) cm3 with the TEF, BPEF, and MPM methods, respectively. Both TEF and BPEF overestimated PV relative to MPM, with the former presenting significant differences (+ 1.91 cm3, IQ = [- 0.33 cm3, 5.07 cm3], p val = 0.03). Both intra- (ICC > 0.90) and inter-rater (ICC > 0.90) reproducibility were excellent. MPM had the highest inter-rater reproducibility (ICC = 0.999). Inter-rater PV variation led to discrepancies in classification according to the clinical criterion of PSAd > 0.15 ng/mL for 2 patients (5%), 7 patients (17.5%), and 9 patients (22.5%) when using MPM, TEF, and BPEF, respectively.
CONCLUSION: PV measurements using ellipsoid formulas and MPM are highly reproducible. MPM is a robust method for PV assessment and PSAd calculation, with the lowest variability. TEF showed a high degree of concordance with MPM but a slight overestimation of PV. Precise anatomic landmarks as defined with the BPEF led to a more accurate PV estimation, but also to a higher variability.
KEY POINTS: • Manual planimetry used for prostate volume estimation is robust and reproducible, with the lowest variability between readers. • Ellipsoid formulas are accurate and reproducible but with higher variability between readers. • The traditional ellipsoid formula tends to overestimate prostate volume.
引用
- Hamzaoui, Montagne, Granger, et al. Prostate volume prediction on MRI: tools, accuracy and variability. Eur Radiol. 2022. PMID: 35169895. doi:10.1007/s00330-022-08554-4
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。