文献速递神经儿科影像MR

视觉可访问伦勃朗图像特征在儿童脑肿瘤中的评分者间信度

Features of Visually AcceSAble Rembrandt Images: Interrater Reliability in Pediatric Brain Tumors.
PubMed 文献 · AJNR Am J Neuroradiol · 2022-01-20

本研究由3名神经放射科医师独立回顾50例连续儿童颅内肿瘤切除前脑MR检查,评估视觉可访问伦勃朗图像(VASARI)术前特征的评分者间信度,并以30例胶质瘤行亚组分析。结果显示肿瘤位置(F1)和强化肿瘤比例(F5)等9个特征在儿童脑肿瘤中具有可接受的评分者间一致性,胶质瘤亚组有11个特征一致性可接受。

要点

  • 肿瘤位置(F1)和强化肿瘤比例(F5)在儿童脑肿瘤中评分者间一致性几乎完美(α > .8)。
  • 肿瘤侧别(F2)、语言功能区受累(F3)、强化质量(F4)、非对比强化肿瘤比例(F6)和深部白质侵犯(F21)达高度一致(α = .61-.80)。
  • 轴位测量值组内相关系数极佳(主组0.984和0.982,胶质瘤亚组0.973和0.973)。

核心结论

  • 视觉可访问伦勃朗图像有9个特征在儿童脑肿瘤中评分者间一致性可接受,胶质瘤亚组有11个特征一致性可接受,其余特征可重复性低,需要使用针对儿童年龄组定制的特征。

研究设计与样本

  • 50例连续儿童颅内肿瘤切除前脑MR检查由3名神经放射科医师独立回顾,采用组内相关系数评估连续变量、Krippendorf alpha评估评分者间一致性,并对30例胶质瘤行亚组分析。

关键影像表现/征象

  • 肿瘤位置(F1)和强化肿瘤比例(F5)的Krippendorf alpha > .8,一致性几乎完美。
  • 肿瘤侧别(F2)、语言功能区受累(F3)、强化质量(F4)、非对比强化肿瘤比例(F6)和深部白质侵犯(F21)的Krippendorf alpha = .61-.80,一致性高度。
  • 其余参数中11个为中等一致(α = .41-.60)、5个为一般一致(α = .21-.40)、1个为轻微一致(α = 0-.20)。
  • 30例胶质瘤亚组中肿瘤位置(F1)、语言功能区受累(F3)和强化肿瘤比例(F5)一致性几乎完美,肿瘤侧别(F2)、强化质量(F4)、非对比强化肿瘤比例(F6)、囊肿(F8)、强化边缘厚度(F11)和深部白质侵犯(F21)一致性高度。
  • 轴位测量值组内相关系数在主组为0.984(F29)和0.982(F30),在胶质瘤亚组为0.973(F29)和0.973(F30),均极佳。

诊断标准与关键数值

  • Krippendorf alpha > .8为几乎完美一致,α = .61-.80为高度一致,α = .41-.60为中等一致,α = .21-.40为一般一致,α = 0-.20为轻微一致。
  • 视觉可访问伦勃朗图像9个特征在儿童脑肿瘤中评分者间一致性可接受,11个特征在儿童胶质瘤亚组中一致性可接受。

临床应用与阅片要点

  • 儿童脑肿瘤影像报告可优先采用评分者间一致性可接受的视觉可访问伦勃朗图像特征,如肿瘤位置(F1)和强化肿瘤比例(F5)。
  • 其余特征可重复性低,原文认为需要使用针对儿童年龄组定制的特征。

局限性

  • 原文指出其余特征可重复性低,需要使用针对儿童年龄组定制的特征,并认为这可能与儿童脑肿瘤影像形态更异质有关。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE: At present, no evidence-based lexicon exists for pediatric intracranial tumors. The Visually AcceSAble Rembrandt Images terminology describes reproducible MR imaging features of adult gliomas for prediction of tumor grade, molecular markers, and survival. Our aim was to assess the interrater reliability of the pre-resection features of Visually AcceSAble Rembrandt Images in pediatric brain tumors.

MATERIALS AND METHODS: Fifty consecutive pre-resection brain MR imaging examinations of pediatric intracranial neoplasms were independently reviewed by 3 neuroradiologists. The intraclass correlation coefficient for continuous variables and the Krippendorf alpha were used to evaluate the interrater agreement. Subgroup analysis was performed for 30 gliomas.

RESULTS: Parameters with almost perfect agreement (α > .8) included tumor location (F1) and proportion of enhancing tumor (F5). Parameters with substantial agreement (α = .61-.80) were side of tumor epicenter (F2), involvement of eloquent brain (F3), enhancement quality (F4), proportion of non-contrast-enhancing tumor (F6), and deep white matter invasion (F21). The other parameters showed either moderate (α = .41-.60; n = 11), fair (α = .21-.40; n = 5), or slight agreement (α = 0-.20; n = 1). Subgroup analysis of 30 gliomas showed almost perfect agreement for tumor location (F1), involvement of eloquent brain (F3), and proportion of enhancing tumor (F5); and substantial agreement for side of tumor epicenter (F2), enhancement quality (F4), proportion of noncontrast enhancing tumor (F6), cysts (F8), thickness of enhancing margin (F11), and deep white matter invasion (F21). The intraclass correlation coefficient for measurements in the axial plane was excellent in both the main group (0.984 [F29] and 0.982 [F30]) and the glioma subgroup (0.973 [F29] and 0.973 [F30]).

CONCLUSIONS: Nine features of Visually AcceSAble Rembrandt Images have an acceptable interrater agreement in pediatric brain tumors. For the subgroup of pediatric gliomas, 11 features of Visually AcceSAble Rembrandt Images have an acceptable interrater agreement. The low degree of reproducibility of the remainder of the features necessitates the use of features tailored to the pediatric age group and is likely related to the more heterogeneous imaging morphology of pediatric brain tumors.

来源:AJNR Am J Neuroradiol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Biswas, Amirabadi, Wagner, et al. Features of Visually AcceSAble Rembrandt Images: Interrater Reliability in Pediatric Brain Tumors. AJNR Am J Neuroradiol. 2022. PMID: 35058297. doi:10.3174/ajnr.A7399

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。