文献速递儿科影像骨肌神经CTDR

儿童虐待性头部创伤:在有多平面CT三维重建时,颅骨X线片不提供额外信息用于诊断颅骨骨折

Abusive head trauma in children: radiographs of the skull do not provide additional information in the diagnosis of skull fracture when multiplanar computed tomography with three-dimensional reconstructions is available.
PubMed 文献 · Pediatr Radiol · 2022-01-19

本研究纳入2010至2019年因疑似身体虐待行颅骨X线片及同期多平面CT三维重建的106名儿童(53例骨折、53例无骨折对照),由两名儿科放射科医师和一名经验较少的受训者独立判读。单独CT与CT联合颅骨X线片诊断颅骨骨折的不一致率为0.009(低于预设的0.03劣效界值),单独CT敏感度98%、特异度96-98%,单独X线片敏感度81%、特异度96%;观察者间一致性kappa 0.86-0.95。结论认为单独多平面CT三维重建不劣于且临床等效于CT联合颅骨X线片,提示可将颅骨X线片从疑似身体虐待影像检查指南中移除。

要点

  • 单独多平面CT三维重建诊断颅骨骨折不劣于CT联合颅骨X线片,不一致率仅0.009(界值0.03)。
  • 单独CT敏感度98%、特异度96-98%;单独X线片敏感度81%、特异度96%。
  • 全部检查方式观察者间一致性很高(kappa 0.86-0.95)。

核心结论

  • 在疑似身体虐待影像检查中,单独多平面CT三维重建诊断颅骨骨折不劣于(且临床等效于)CT联合颅骨X线片,经验较少的受训者判读时同样准确,提示可将颅骨X线片从疑似身体虐待影像检查指南中移除。

研究设计与样本

  • 研究纳入2010至2019年间因疑似身体虐待行颅骨X线片及同期多平面CT三维重建、且正式报告中有骨折诊断的儿童,纳入全部骨折病例及等量随机选取的无骨折对照,共106名儿童(53例骨折、53例无骨折);匿名的数据集由两名儿科放射科医师和一名经验较少的受训者分别以单独X线片、单独CT或CT联合颅骨X线片独立判读。

诊断标准与关键数值

  • 主要结局为单独CT与CT联合颅骨X线片诊断颅骨骨折的不一致率,结果>0.03判定为单独CT劣效;实际仅1例不一致,不一致率0.009,符合非劣效;单独CT敏感度98%、特异度96-98%,CT联合颅骨X线片敏感度98%、特异度96-98%,单独X线片敏感度81%、特异度96%;所有检查方式观察者间一致性kappa 0.86-0.95。

临床应用与阅片要点

  • 对于疑似身体虐待的儿童,在已有多平面CT三维重建时,单独CT即可用于诊断颅骨骨折,且由经验较少的受训者判读时同样准确;作者据此提出可将颅骨X线片从疑似身体虐待影像检查指南中移除。

局限性

  • 原文结论提出可将颅骨X线片从疑似身体虐待影像检查指南中移除,该建议基于本研究结果,原文未报告其他局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开

BACKGROUND: Some data suggest that CT is more accurate than skull radiographs in diagnosing skull fractures in abusive head trauma.

OBJECTIVES: We investigated whether multiplanar CT with three-dimensional (3-D) reconstructions alone is non-inferior to combination CT/skull radiography for the diagnosis of skull fracture in suspected physical abuse.

MATERIALS AND METHODS: We identified children who had skull radiographs and concurrent multiplanar CT with 3-D reconstructions obtained during suspected physical abuse imaging between 2010 and 2019, and a fracture diagnosis in the formal report. We included all fracture cases and an equal number of randomly selected non-fracture controls in an anonymised dataset. This dataset was independently reviewed for skull fracture by two paediatric radiologists and one less-experienced trainee using either radiography alone, CT alone or CT/skull radiography. The primary outcome was discordance in diagnosis of skull fracture between CT alone and CT/skull radiography, with a result > 0.03 deemed to indicate inferiority of CT alone. The Fleiss kappa was used to assess interobserver agreement.

RESULTS: We included 106 children, 53 with and 53 without skull fracture. A single case was discordant between CT alone and CT/skull radiography, resulting in discordance of 0.009, consistent with non-inferiority of CT alone. The sensitivity and specificity of CT alone and CT/skull radiography were 98% and 96-98%, respectively, whereas radiography alone was more inaccurate (81% sensitivity and 96% specificity). Interobserver agreement for all modalities was very high (kappa 0.86-0.95).

CONCLUSION: Multiplanar CT with 3-D reconstructions alone is not inferior (and clinically equivalent) to CT/skull radiography for diagnosing skull fracture in suspected physical abuse imaging and was as accurate when reported by a less-experienced trainee. This suggests that skull radiography can be removed from suspected physical abuse imaging guidelines.

来源:Pediatr Radiol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Cosgrave, Bowie, Walker, et al. Abusive head trauma in children: radiographs of the skull do not provide additional information in the diagnosis of skull fracture when multiplanar computed tomography with three-dimensional reconstructions is available. Pediatr Radiol. 2022. PMID: 35043263. doi:10.1007/s00247-021-05256-9

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。