比较半定量胸部CT评分系统评估新型冠状病毒肺炎(COVID-19)严重程度
研究纳入108例COVID-19患者,两名放射科医师独立采用三种半定量CT评分系统(TSS、CCTS、CTSS)评估胸部CT,并与入院临床严重程度及U-net模型计算的定量密集区比率(QDAR)对照。三种系统观察者间一致性均优(ICC 0.952-0.970),鉴别入院临床严重程度的AUC为0.836-0.855;TSS与CCTS阅片时间显著短于CTSS,CCTS与QDAR相关性最高,作者认为CCTS似乎最适合临床实践。
要点
- 三种半定量CT评分系统鉴别入院临床严重程度的AUC为0.836-0.855,观察者间一致性优(ICC 0.952-0.970)。
- TSS和CCTS阅片时间显著短于CTSS(TSS 25.7-41.7秒、CCTS 27.7-39.5秒 vs CTSS 48.9-80.0秒,p<0.001)。
- CCTS与QDAR相关性最高(ρ=0.443-0.448),其次TSS(ρ=0.435-0.437),CTSS最低(ρ=0.415-0.426)。
核心结论
- 三种半定量评分系统对入院临床严重程度均有较好诊断效能且观察者间一致性优;TSS和CCTS阅片时间更短,CTSS与QDAR相关性最低,CCTS似乎是临床实践中最合适的CT评分系统。
研究设计与样本
- 研究论文;108例患者,两名放射科医师独立阅片,比较三种半定量胸部CT评分系统(TSS、CCTS、CTSS,其中CTSS做了轻微修改),以入院临床严重程度(重型n=14、轻型n=94)及U-net模型计算的QDAR为参照。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 鉴别入院临床严重程度的AUC:TSS 0.855-0.842、CCTS 0.853-0.850、CTSS 0.853-0.836;预测发展为危重症的AUC为0.786-0.802;CCTS在评分时采用5%阈值以更好区分轻微与轻度肺受累。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 作者认为CCTS似乎是最适合临床实践的CT评分系统;TSS和CCTS因阅片时间更短、临床实用性更佳,CTSS与QDAR相关性最低。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVES: To compare the clinical usefulness among three different semiquantitative computed tomography (CT) severity scoring systems for coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) pneumonia.
METHODS: Two radiologists independently reviewed chest CT images in 108 patients to rate three CT scoring systems (total CT score [TSS], chest CT score [CCTS], and CT severity score [CTSS]). We made a minor modification to CTSS. Quantitative dense area ratio (QDAR: the ratio of lung involvement to lung parenchyma) was calculated using the U-net model. Clinical severity at admission was classified as severe (n = 14) or mild (n = 94). Interobserver agreement, interpretation time, and degree of correlation with clinical severity as well as QDAR were evaluated.
RESULTS: Interobserver agreement was excellent (intraclass correlation coefficient: 0.952-0.970, p < 0.001). Mean interpretation time was significantly longer in CTSS (48.9-80.0 s) than in TSS (25.7-41.7 s, p < 0.001) and CCTS (27.7-39.5 s, p < 0.001). Area under the curve for differentiating clinical severity at admission was 0.855-0.842 in TSS, 0.853-0.850 in CCTS, and 0.853-0.836 in CTSS. All scoring systems correlated with QDAR in the order of CCTS (ρ = 0.443-0.448), TSS (ρ = 0.435-0.437), and CTSS (ρ = 0.415-0.426).
CONCLUSIONS: All semiquantitative scoring systems demonstrated substantial diagnostic performance for clinical severity at admission with excellent interobserver agreement. Interpretation time was significantly shorter in TSS and CCTS than in CTSS. The correlation between the scoring system and QDAR was highest in CCTS, followed by TSS and CTSS. CCTS appeared to be the most appropriate CT scoring system for clinical practice.
KEY POINTS: • Three semiquantitative scoring systems demonstrate substantial accuracy (area under the curve: 0.836-0.855) for diagnosing clinical severity at admission and (area under the curve: 0.786-0.802) for risk of developing critical illness. • Total CT score (TSS) and chest CT score (CCTS) were considered to be more appropriate in terms of clinical usefulness as compared with CT severity score (CTSS), given the shorter interpretation time in TSS and CCTS, and the lowest correlation with quantitative dense area ratio in CTSS. • CCTS is assumed to distinguish subtle from mild lung involvement better than TSS by adopting a 5% threshold in scoring the degree of severity.
引用
- Inoue, Takahashi, Ibe, et al. Comparison of semiquantitative chest CT scoring systems to estimate severity in coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) pneumonia. Eur Radiol. 2022. PMID: 35020014. doi:10.1007/s00330-021-08435-2
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。