脑影像研究中偶然发现对年轻成年参与者的影响:一项访谈研究
该研究通过11次半结构化访谈(10名参与者),调查年轻成年研究参与者对脑MRI研究偶然发现(IF)披露的经历与偏好,以及披露的长期影响;分析得出初始震惊、不确定期、随访检查结果、长期影响和生物医学背景五个主题,披露未带来健康获益且有暂时有限的负面影响,提示需审慎考虑IF披露并开展系统大规模随访研究。
要点
- IF披露后参与者主要受不确定期影响,披露未带来健康获益。
- 部分参与者有暂时且有限的负面心理影响。
- 作者建议审慎考虑健康年轻参与者中的IF披露。
核心结论
- 研究提示在年轻健康参与者群体中审慎考虑IF披露很重要,并强调需系统大规模随访研究监测该人群IF披露的风险与获益。
研究设计与样本
- 在荷兰Donders认知神经影像中心(DCCN)对参与脑MRI研究后被披露IF的10名研究参与者进行11次半结构化访谈,采用持续比较法分析访谈转录。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 作者认为本研究见解可为改进影像研究IF管理与披露的现有研究程序或框架提供附加价值。
- 作者强调需系统大规模随访研究监测该人群IF披露的风险与获益。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVES: The current study aims to investigate young adult research participants' experiences with and preferences regarding the disclosure of MRI incidental findings (IFs) in brain imaging research, and to elucidate the impact and long-term effects of IF disclosure on these participants.
METHODS: We conducted 11 semi-structured interviews with 10 research participants to whom an IF was disclosed after they participated in brain MRI research at the Donders Institute, Centre for Cognitive Neuroimaging (DCCN) in the Netherlands. Interview transcripts were analyzed using the constant comparative method.
RESULTS: The analysis yielded five themes regarding the impact of IF disclosure: the initial shock of disclosure, a period of uncertainty, results of the follow-up examination, long-term impact, and participants' biomedical background. Participants were primarily impacted by the uncertainty in the period immediately following IF disclosure. For our participants, disclosure has had no health benefits and some, albeit mostly temporary and limited, negative impact.
CONCLUSIONS: Our study suggests that it is important to carefully consider IF disclosure in a population of young healthy participants and emphasizes the relevance of systematic, large-scale follow-up studies to monitor risks and benefits of IF disclosure in this population. The insights from this study can be of added value to improve current research procedures or frameworks for the management and disclosure of IFs in imaging studies.
KEY POINTS: • Participants were primarily impacted by the uncertainty in the period immediately following IF disclosure. • Our study suggests that it is important to carefully consider IF disclosure in a population of healthy young adult participants. • Our study emphasizes the relevance of systematic, large-scale follow-up studies to monitor the risks and benefits of IF disclosure in this population.
引用
- Oerlemans, Barendregt, Kooijman, et al. Impact of incidental findings on young adult participants in brain imaging research: an interview study. Eur Radiol. 2022. PMID: 35020011. doi:10.1007/s00330-021-08474-9
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。