基于磁共振成像的新前喙突盂线对应临界肩盂骨缺损
研究在50例肩盂解剖正常的患者中,由两名骨科医生用T1加权矢状位MRI和喙突盂线技术测量垂直线前方骨性肩盂百分比,两名肌骨放射科医生用圆法测量同一批肩盂。喙突盂线组平均21.69%±3.12%,圆法组平均20.86%±2.29%,两种测量呈线性相关(r=0.704),喙突盂线法组间信度0.83(优秀)。
要点
- 喙突盂线(平行肩盂长轴、过喙突与肩盂拐点的垂直线)前方骨性肩盂平均约21%,可作为约20%肩盂骨缺损的 demarcation 参考。
- 喙突盂线法组间信度0.83(优秀),圆法组间信度0.553(一般),喙突盂线法可能更便于日常使用。
- 喙突盂线与圆法测量值呈中高度线性相关(r=0.704),支持其作为圆法替代参考。
核心结论
- 喙突盂线似乎代表喙突盂线前方约21%肩盂骨质的 demarcation 线,该技术可靠、有效且准确。
研究设计与样本
- 从一名骨科医生数据库中随机选取50例肩盂解剖正常的患者,两名骨科医生用T1加权矢状位MRI和喙突盂线技术测量,两名肌骨放射科医生用圆法测量同一批50例肩盂;采用配对t检验比较差异,组内相关系数和Kappa比较信度,Pearson相关系数比较效度。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 喙突盂线法测量垂直线前方肩盂平均表面积为21.69%±3.12%;圆法测量肩盂平均表面积为20.86%±2.29%;圆法组间信度0.553(一般),垂直线法组间信度0.83(优秀);圆法与垂直线测量呈线性关系,r=0.704(中高度相关)。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVE: Glenoid bone loss is estimated using a best-fit circle method and requires software tools that may not be available. Our hypothesis is that a vertical reference line drawn parallel to the long axis of the glenoid and passing through the inflection point of the coracoid and glenoid will represent a demarcation line of approximately 20% of the glenoid. Our aim is to establish a more efficient method to estimate a surgical threshold for glenoid insufficiency.
METHODS: Fifty patients with normal glenoid anatomy were randomly chosen from an orthopedic surgeon's database. Two orthopedic surgeons utilized T1-weighted sagittal MRIs and the coracoglenoid line technique to determine the percentage of bony glenoid anterior to vertical line. Two musculoskeletal radiologists measured the same 50 glenoids using the circle technique. Differences were determined using dependent t test. Reliability was compared using interclass correlation coefficient and Kappa. Validity was compared using Pearson correlation coefficient.
RESULTS: Mean surface area of the glenoid anterior to the vertical line was on average 21.69% ± 3.12%. Surface area of the glenoid using the circle method was on average 20.86% ± 2.29%. Inter-rater reliability of the circle method was 0.553 (fair). Inter-rater reliability of the vertical line technique was 0.83 (excellent). There was a linear relationship between circle and vertical line measurements, r = 0.704 (moderate to high).
CONCLUSION: The coracoglenoid line appears to represent a line of demarcation of approximately 21% of glenoid bone anterior to the coracoglenoid line. Our technique was found to be reliable, valid, and accurate.
引用
- Olmscheid, Crawford, Dickinson, et al. Novel anterior coracoglenoid line utilizing magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) corresponds with critical glenoid bone loss. Skeletal Radiol. 2022. PMID: 34988628. doi:10.1007/s00256-021-03981-8
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。