人工智能提升平片骨折识别效能与效率
本回顾性多阅片者多病例诊断研究基于外部多中心480例检查,评估AI辅助对医师平片骨折诊断的影响。AI辅助使每患者敏感度提高10.4%(95%CI 6.9,13.9;P<.001),特异度非劣于无AI(差值+5.0%,95%CI +2.0,+8.0;P=.001),平均阅片时间缩短6.3秒(95%CI -12.5,-0.1;P=.046)。
要点
- AI辅助使每患者骨折检出敏感度从64.8%升至75.2%,提高10.4%。
- AI辅助特异度95.6%非劣于无AI的90.6%,差值+5.0%。
- AI辅助平均每例阅片时间缩短6.3秒。
核心结论
- AI辅助可提高放射科医师和非放射科医师的骨折检出敏感度,甚至可能提高特异度,且不延长阅片时间。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性诊断研究,采用多阅片者多病例方法,基于外部多中心数据集的480例检查,每个身体区域至少60例,骨折患病率设为50%。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 以两位肌骨放射科医师判定为参考标准,分歧由第三位解决。
- 主要分析需证明AI辅助下每患者敏感度优效且特异度在-3%界值非劣效。
- AI辅助每患者敏感度75.2%(4331/5760次判读),无AI为64.8%(3732/5760次判读),提高10.4%(95%CI 6.9,13.9;P<.001)。
- AI辅助每患者特异度95.6%(5504/5760次判读),无AI为90.6%(5217/5760次判读),差值+5.0%(95%CI +2.0,+8.0;P=.001)。
- 各区域每患者敏感度提升+8.0%至+16.2%(P<.05),但肩锁关节和脊柱分别为+4.2%和+2.6%(P=.12和.52)。
临床应用与阅片要点
- AI辅助可使每患者骨折检出敏感度提高10.4%,特异度差值+5.0%,阅片时间缩短6.3秒。
- 肩锁关节和脊柱区域敏感度提升未达统计学显著(+4.2%和+2.6%;P=.12和.52)。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
Background Missed fractures are a common cause of diagnostic discrepancy between initial radiographic interpretation and the final read by board-certified radiologists. Purpose To assess the effect of assistance by artificial intelligence (AI) on diagnostic performances of physicians for fractures on radiographs. Materials and Methods This retrospective diagnostic study used the multi-reader, multi-case methodology based on an external multicenter data set of 480 examinations with at least 60 examinations per body region (foot and ankle, knee and leg, hip and pelvis, hand and wrist, elbow and arm, shoulder and clavicle, rib cage, and thoracolumbar spine) between July 2020 and January 2021. Fracture prevalence was set at 50%. The ground truth was determined by two musculoskeletal radiologists, with discrepancies solved by a third. Twenty-four readers (radiologists, orthopedists, emergency physicians, physician assistants, rheumatologists, family physicians) were presented the whole validation data set (n = 480), with and without AI assistance, with a 1-month minimum washout period. The primary analysis had to demonstrate superiority of sensitivity per patient and the noninferiority of specificity per patient at -3% margin with AI aid. Stand-alone AI performance was also assessed using receiver operating characteristic curves. Results A total of 480 patients were included (mean age, 59 years ± 16 [standard deviation]; 327 women). The sensitivity per patient was 10.4% higher (95% CI: 6.9, 13.9; P < .001 for superiority) with AI aid (4331 of 5760 readings, 75.2%) than without AI (3732 of 5760 readings, 64.8%). The specificity per patient with AI aid (5504 of 5760 readings, 95.6%) was noninferior to that without AI aid (5217 of 5760 readings, 90.6%), with a difference of +5.0% (95% CI: +2.0, +8.0; P = .001 for noninferiority). AI shortened the average reading time by 6.3 seconds per examination (95% CI: -12.5, -0.1; P = .046). The sensitivity by patient gain was significant in all regions (+8.0% to +16.2%; P < .05) but shoulder and clavicle and spine (+4.2% and +2.6%; P = .12 and .52). Conclusion AI assistance improved the sensitivity and may even improve the specificity of fracture detection by radiologists and nonradiologists, without lengthening reading time. Published under a CC BY 4.0 license. Online supplemental material is available for this article. See also the editorial by Link and Pedoia in this issue.
引用
- Guermazi, Tannoury, Kompel, et al. Improving Radiographic Fracture Recognition Performance and Efficiency Using Artificial Intelligence. Radiology. 2021. PMID: 34931859. doi:10.1148/radiol.210937
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。