双参数MRI与多参数MRI基于VI-RADS评分诊断膀胱癌及评估肌层浸润的准确性与有效性比较:对比剂在检测肌层浸润中是否真的必要
本研究对128例初诊膀胱癌患者的术前膀胱多参数MRI进行回顾性分析,由两名不同经验读者独立评估双参数MRI(T2WI+DWI)和多参数MRI两套图像,以VI-RADS≥4分为肌层浸润 cutoff。双参数MRI与多参数MRI的诊断效能无显著差异(p=0.238和0.318),读者间一致性极好;双参数MRI诊断准确性可与多参数MRI媲美,读者经验似乎不影响基于VI-RADS的诊断效能。
要点
- 双参数MRI(T2WI+DWI)基于VI-RADS评分检测肌层浸润的准确性可与多参数MRI媲美。
- 以VI-RADS≥4分为肌层浸润 cutoff,双参数MRI敏感度90.3-93.5%、特异度96.6-99.1%。
- 两种MRI协议下读者间VI-RADS评分一致性极好,读者经验似乎不影响诊断效能。
核心结论
- 双参数MRI协议基于VI-RADS标准检测肌层浸润性膀胱癌的诊断准确性可与多参数MRI协议相媲美;在两种MRI协议下,使用VI-RADS标准时读者经验似乎不显著影响诊断效能。
研究设计与样本
- 对128例初诊膀胱癌患者行术前膀胱多参数MRI,由两名读者独立评估双参数MRI(T2WI+DWI)和多参数MRI两套图像;以VI-RADS≥4分为肌层浸润 cutoff,计算每名读者和每套图像的敏感度、特异度、准确性和AUC,并用Cohen kappa系数评估读者间一致性。
关键影像表现/征象
- 双参数MRI与多参数MRI的VI-RADS评分读者间一致性极好。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 以VI-RADS≥4分为肌层浸润 cutoff:双参数MRI读者1敏感度90.3%、特异度96.6%、准确性96%、AUC 0.947;读者2敏感度93.5%、特异度99.1%、准确性97.3%、AUC 0.951。
- 以VI-RADS≥4分为肌层浸润 cutoff:多参数MRI读者1敏感度87.1%、特异度91.6%、准确性91.3%、AUC 0.919;读者2敏感度90.3%、特异度96.6%、准确性94.6%、AUC 0.921。
- 两种协议诊断效能无显著差异(读者1 p=0.238,读者2 p=0.318)。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 双参数MRI(T2WI+DWI)可作为多参数MRI的替代方案用于膀胱癌肌层浸润评估,基于VI-RADS评分。
- 使用VI-RADS标准时,读者经验似乎不显著影响诊断效能。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
PURPOSE: (1) To evaluate the accuracy and validity of the biparametric MRI (bp-MRI), including T2-weigthed image (WI) and DWI sequences, and the availability of an alternative to the multiparametric MRI (mp-MRI), for the muscle-invasiveness assessment of bladder cancer (BC). (2) To evaluate the diagnostic performance and agreement of readers with different experiences in the abdominal imaging of using both protocols.
METHODS: Preoperative bladder mp-MRI was performed on 128 patients with a initial diagnosis of BC. Two sets of images, set 1 (bp-MRI) and set 2 (mp-MRI), were independently evaluated by both readers. Descriptive statistics, including sensitivity, specificity, accuracy, and area under the curve (AUC), for VI-RADS scores were calculated using ≥ 4 as the cutoff for muscle invasion for each reader and image sets. Inter-reader agreement was evaluated using the Cohen's kappa coefficient.
RESULTS: The sensitivity ranged between 90.3-93.5% and 87.1-90.3%, specificity ranged between 96.6-99.1% and 91.6-96.6%, accuracy ranged between 96-97.3% and 91.3-94.6%, and AUC ranged between 0.947-0.951 and 0.919-0.921, for bp-MRI and mp-MRI, and reader 1 and reader 2, respectively. No significant differences were shown in diagnostic performance for either reader between both the protocols (p = 0.238 and 0.318). There was excellent agreement among the readers in the VI-RADS scores, using both protocols.
CONCLUSION: A bp-MRI protocol has a diagnostic accuracy comparable to an mp-MRI protocol for the detection of muscle-invasive BC using the VI-RADS criteria. Also, in both MRI protocols, the reader's experience does not appear to significantly affect diagnostic performance when using the VI-RADS criteria.
引用
- Aslan, Cakir, Oguz, et al. Comparison of the diagnostic accuracy and validity of biparametric MRI and multiparametric MRI-based VI-RADS scoring in bladder cancer; is contrast material really necessary in detecting muscle invasion? Abdom Radiol (NY). 2021. PMID: 34919161. doi:10.1007/s00261-021-03383-3
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。