卵巢间质超声测量方法的可靠性与一致性:方法学的影响
本研究由5名评估者在两种成像条件下(实时自由选择与离线固定帧)对30个卵巢动态图像采用3种方法测量间质面积(SA)和间质/卵巢面积比(S/A),并以3级主观量表评分间质回声(SEcho)。结果显示SA和S/A的评估者间可靠性为中至差,SEcho评估亦不可靠;方法1(卵巢面积减去卵泡面积)的SA可靠性相对最优。
要点
- 卵巢间质面积(SA)评估者间可靠性总体为中至差,方法1相对最优。
- 间质/卵巢面积比(S/A)各方法评估者间可靠性均为中至差。
- 间质回声(SEcho)3级主观评分评估者间一致性不可靠(κ<0.500)。
核心结论
- 卵巢间质的超声评估可靠性为中至差;间接估算间质的方法(方法1)或可优化为可重复的评估方式,从而明确间质的临床意义。
研究设计与样本
- 由5名评估者在实时(自由选择)与离线(固定帧)两种成像条件下,对30个卵巢动态图像采用3种方法测量SA和S/A、1种方法评估SEcho。
诊断标准与关键数值
- SA方法1(卵巢面积减去卵泡面积)在自由选择条件下ICC=0.558,固定帧条件下ICC=0.705。
- SA方法2(勾画间质外周)在自由选择条件下ICC=0.522,固定帧条件下ICC=0.230。
- SA方法3(勾画间质后减去中央卵泡的混合法)在自由选择条件下ICC=0.429,固定帧条件下ICC=0.305。
- SEcho采用主观3级量表评分,评估者间Fleiss kappa κ<0.500。
局限性
- 卵巢间质超声评估的重复性为中至差,限制了其临床实用性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVES: Increased ovarian stromal area (SA), stromal-to-ovarian area ratio (S/A), and echogenicity (SEcho) on ultrasonography have been proposed as diagnostic markers for polycystic ovary syndrome. Although several methods to evaluate the stroma exist, their reproducibility has not been defined which limits clinical utility. This study aimed to determine the interrater reliability and agreement of methods to evaluate SA, S/A, and SEcho.
METHODS: Five raters tested 3 methods to obtain SA and S/A, and one to obtain SEcho on 30 ovarian cineloops under two imaging conditions, simulating real-time (free-choice) or offline (fixed-frame) imaging. For SA, Method 1 subtracted follicular area from the ovarian area, Method 2 involved outlining the periphery of the stroma, and Method 3 represented a hybrid approach in which central follicles were subtracted from the outlined stroma. SEcho was scored on a subjective 3-tiered scale. Intraclass correlation coefficients (ICCs) and the coefficient of variation were determined for SA and S/A, and Fleiss' kappa agreement statistics (κ) were determined for SEcho.
RESULTS: Interrater reliability of SA was superior using Method 1 (ICC = 0.558 and ICC = 0.705) versus Method 2 (ICC = 0.522 and ICC = 0.230) or Method 3 (ICC = 0.429 and ICC = 0.305) under free-choice and fixed-frame imaging conditions, respectively. Interrater reliability of S/A was also moderate to poor across methods. SEcho was also not reliably assessed across raters (κ = <0.500).
CONCLUSIONS: Ultrasonographic assessments of the ovarian stroma were associated with moderate to poor reproducibility. Indirect estimates of the ovarian stroma (Method 1) could be optimized to yield a reproducible approach, clarifying the clinical relevance of the stroma.
引用
- Vanden Brink, Nosrati, Ortiz-Flores, et al. Reliability and Agreement of Ultrasonographic Measures of the Ovarian Stroma: Impact of Methodology. J Ultrasound Med. 2021. PMID: 34913507. doi:10.1002/jum.15917
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。