肺移植术后原发性移植物功能障碍评估的观察者间变异性:放射学培训的影响及不一致病例分析
回顾性纳入164例双肺移植患者,3名放射科医师独立评估术后胸片是否提示原发性移植物功能障碍(PGD),其中2名接受专项培训。共评估473张胸片,两名受训医师间一致性很高(K=0.90,ICC=0.90),与其他配对一致性较差(K=0.34–0.35,ICC=0.40)。不一致主要原因为过度判断支气管周围增厚及单侧病变评估错误。
要点
- 受训医师间PGD胸片判读一致性很高(K=0.90,ICC=0.90),未受训者一致性差(K=0.34–0.35)。
- 不一致病例中52.4%源于无明确双肺磨玻璃影时过度判断支气管周围增厚或单侧改变误判。
- 作者建议放射科医师接受专项培训以准确识别PGD。
核心结论
- 专项培训可提高放射科医师对肺移植术后PGD胸片判读的一致性;不一致主要源于对支气管周围增厚的过度判断和单侧病变的错误评估。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性研究,纳入2013年2月至2019年12月在本机构接受双肺移植的164例患者,3名放射科医师独立评估术后胸片,其中2名在研究开始前接受专项培训;参考标准为胸片是否提示PGD。
关键影像表现/征象
- 胸片评估PGD的主要征象包括双肺磨玻璃影和支气管周围增厚。
- 不一致病例中52.4%为无明确双肺磨玻璃影时过度判断支气管周围增厚,或单侧改变评估错误。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 受训医师1与2之间一致性K=0.90、ICC=0.90。
- 医师1与3之间一致性K=0.34、ICC=0.40。
- 医师2与3之间一致性K=0.35、ICC=0.40。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 作者建议放射科医师接受专项培训以准确识别PGD。
- 判读时需注意避免在无明确双肺磨玻璃影时过度判断支气管周围增厚,并正确评估单侧改变。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
PURPOSE: Radiologic criteria for the diagnosis of primary graft dysfunction (PGD) after lung transplantation are nonspecific and can lead to misinterpretation. The primary aim of our study was to assess the interobserver agreement in the evaluation of chest X-rays (CXRs) for PGD diagnosis and to establish whether a specific training could have an impact on concordance rates. Secondary aim was to analyze causes of interobserver discordances.
MATERIAL AND METHODS: We retrospectively enrolled 164 patients who received bilateral lung transplantation at our institution, between February 2013 and December 2019. Three radiologists independently reviewed postoperative CXRs and classified them as suggestive or not for PGD. Two of the Raters performed a specific training before the beginning of the study. A senior thoracic radiologist subsequently analyzed all discordant cases among the Raters with the best agreement. Statistical analysis to calculate interobserver variability was percent agreement, Cohen's kappa and intraclass correlation coefficient.
RESULTS: A total of 473 CXRs were evaluated. A very high concordance among the two trained Raters, 1 and 2, was found (K = 0.90, ICC = 0.90), while a poorer agreement was found in the other two pairings (Raters 1 and 3: K = 0.34, ICC = 0.40; Raters 2 and 3: K = 0.35, ICC = 0.40). The main cause of disagreement (52.4% of discordant cases) between Raters 1 and 2 was the overestimation of peribronchial thickening in the absence of unequivocal bilateral lung opacities or the incorrect assessment of unilateral alterations.
CONCLUSION: To properly identify PGD, it is recommended for radiologists to receive an adequate specific training.
引用
- Andrisani, Vespro, Fusco, et al. Interobserver variability in the evaluation of primary graft dysfunction after lung transplantation: impact of radiological training and analysis of discordant cases. Radiol Med. 2021. PMID: 34905128. doi:10.1007/s11547-021-01438-5
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。