使用欧洲指南制定常见放射学检查的儿科诊断参考水平
研究从4个国家31家医院收集7类检查共2978例儿科患者数据,按体重和年龄分别推导区域诊断参考水平,发现基于体重与基于年龄分组所得参考水平差异明显,且推导值低于或等于欧洲及近期发表的国家诊断参考水平。作者认为可基于体重分组并在获取患儿实际体重的前提下制定儿科诊断参考水平,年龄与体重分组不可互换。
要点
- 儿科诊断参考水平可按体重和年龄分组推导,但两种分组所得数值差异明显,不可互换使用。
- 推导值低于或等于欧洲及近期发表的国家诊断参考水平。
- 作者认为应使用体重分组并获取患儿实际体重来制定儿科诊断参考水平。
核心结论
- 推导区域诊断参考水平是可行的,但数据收集前需对临床指征和方法学进行彻底审查。
- 本研究不支持使用年龄分组与体重分组推导的诊断参考水平可以互换的观点。
- 儿科诊断参考水平应使用体重分组并获取患儿实际体重来制定,体重法与年龄法所得诊断参考水平差异显著,仍需统一方法以制定可靠的儿科放射检查诊断参考水平。
研究设计与样本
- 研究类型为利用欧洲指南探索区域诊断参考水平的可行性研究,数据来自4个国家31家医院。
- 纳入7类检查共2978例儿科患者,分别按体重分组和年龄分组推导区域诊断参考水平。
- 每组患者总数超过15例时才推导该组区域诊断参考水平。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 按体重分组和年龄分组分别推导区域诊断参考水平,每组患者总数需超过15例。
- 基于体重分组与基于年龄分组推导的区域诊断参考水平差异明显。
- 推导的区域诊断参考水平低于或等于欧洲及近期发表的国家诊断参考水平。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 作者认为儿科诊断参考水平应使用体重分组并获取患儿实际体重来制定。
- 作者认为基于年龄分组与基于体重分组推导的诊断参考水平不可互换。
- 作者认为数据收集前需对临床指征和方法学进行彻底审查。
局限性
- 并非所有按体重和年龄分组的7类检查均能推导出区域诊断参考水平。
- 基于体重和基于年龄分组的结果差异明显,本研究不支持两者可互换。
- 仍需统一方法以制定可靠的儿科放射检查诊断参考水平。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVE: The purpose of this study was to explore the feasibility to determine regional diagnostic reference levels (RDRLs) for paediatric conventional and CT examinations using the European guidelines and to compare RDRLs derived from weight and age groups, respectively.
METHODS: Data were collected from 31 hospitals in 4 countries, for 7 examination types for a total of 2978 patients. RDRLs were derived for each weight and age group, respectively, when the total number of patients exceeded 15.
RESULTS: It was possible to derive RDRLs for most, but not all, weight-based and age-based groups for the seven examinations. The result using weight-based and age-based groups differed substantially. The RDRLs were lower than or equal to the European and recently published national DRLs.
CONCLUSION: It is feasible to derive RDRLs. However, a thorough review of the clinical indications and methodologies has to be performed previous to data collection. This study does not support the notion that DRLs derived using age and weight groups are exchangeable.
ADVANCES IN KNOWLEDGE: Paediatric DRLs should be derived using weight-based groups with access to the actual weight of the patients. DRLs developed using weight differ markedly from those developed with the use of age. There is still a need to harmonize the method to derive solid DRLs for paediatric radiological examinations.
引用
- Almén, Guðjónsdóttir, Heimland, et al. Paediatric diagnostic reference levels for common radiological examinations using the European guidelines. Br J Radiol. 2021. PMID: 34898256. doi:10.1259/bjr.20210700
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。