文献速递乳腺乳腺X线

乳腺X线阅片时段内乳腺癌检出率的变化:经验是否有影响

Variations in breast cancer detection rates during mammogram-reading sessions: does experience have an impact?
PubMed 文献 · Br J Radiol · 2021-11-04

研究让10名放射科医生无休息连续阅读60例乳腺X线测试集,按每年阅片量≥2000例与<2000例分为经验较多与较少两组,每20例为一序列共三序列。结果发现经验与序列顺序对敏感度和病灶敏感度存在显著线性交互:第一序列两组均值相近,至第三序列经验较多者敏感度与病灶敏感度改善、经验较少者下降,特异度与ROC曲线下面积不受经验或序列顺序显著影响。作者建议年轻放射科医生意识到连续阅片可能出现的敏感度与病灶敏感度下降,并据此安排适合自身的休息。

要点

  • 连续阅片至第三序列时,经验较少者敏感度与病灶敏感度下降,经验较多者改善。
  • 特异度与ROC曲线下面积未受经验和序列顺序显著影响。
  • 作者建议年轻放射科医生根据自身情况在连续阅片中安排休息。

核心结论

  • 放射科医生的阅片表现可能在一次阅片时段内明显变化,且似乎与经验有关:经验较少者敏感度和病灶敏感度下降,经验较多者反而改善;特异度与ROC曲线下面积不受显著影响。

研究设计与样本

  • 采用方差分析2×3析因设计,10名放射科医生无休息连续阅读60例乳腺X线测试集,按每年阅片量≥2000例(经验较多)与<2000例(经验较少)分组,每20例为一序列共三序列,各序列难度相当且顺序固定,每序列约需30分钟、全程共90分钟。

诊断标准与关键数值

  • 计算每个序列的敏感度、特异度、病灶敏感度和ROC曲线下面积;经验与固定序列对敏感度存在显著线性交互(F[1]=5.762,p=.04,偏η2=.41),对病灶敏感度亦存在显著线性交互(F[1]=6.993,p=.03,偏η2=.46)。

临床应用与阅片要点

  • 作者建议让年轻放射科医生意识到连续阅片过程中敏感度和病灶敏感度可能随时间下降,以便根据自身情况在连续阅片时段中安排休息,而不是试图效仿经验更多的同事。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开

OBJECTIVES: To examine whether radiologists' performances are consistent throughout a reading session and whether any changes in performance over the reading task differ depending on experience of the reader.

METHODS: The performance of ten radiologists reading a test set of 60 mammographic cases without breaks was assessed using an ANOVA, 2 × 3 factorial design. Participants were categorized as more (≥2,000 mammogram readings per year) or less (<2,000 readings per year) experienced. Three series of 20 cases were chosen to ensure comparable difficulty and presented in the same sequence to all readers. It usually takes around 30 min for a radiologist to complete each of the 20-case series, resulting in a total of 90 min for the 60 mammographic cases. The sensitivity, specificity, lesion sensitivity, and area under the ROC curve were calculated for each series. We hypothesized that the order in which a series was read (i.e. fixed-series sequence) would have a significant main effect on the participants' performance. We also determined if significant interactions exist between the fixed-series sequence and radiologist experience.

RESULTS: Significant linear interactions were found between experience and the fixed sequence of the series for sensitivity (F[1] =5.762, p = .04, partial η2 = .41) and lesion sensitivity. (F[1] =6.993, p = .03, partial η2 = .46). The two groups' mean scores were similar for the first series but progressively diverged. By the end of the third series, significant differences in sensitivity and lesion sensitivity were evident, with the more experienced individuals demonstrating improving and the less experienced declining performance. Neither experience nor series sequence significantly affected the specificity or the area under the ROC curve.

CONCLUSIONS: Radiologists' performance may change considerably during a reading session, apparently as a function of experience, with less experienced radiologists declining in sensitivity and lesion sensitivity while more experienced radiologists actually improve. With the increasing demands on radiologists to undertake high-volume reporting, we suggest that junior radiologists be made aware of possible sensitivity and lesion sensitivity deterioration over time so they can schedule breaks during continuous reading sessions that are appropriate to them, rather than try to emulate their more experienced colleagues.

ADVANCES IN KNOWLEDGE: Less-experienced radiologists demonstrated a reduction in mammographic diagnostic accuracy in later stages of the reporting sessions. This may suggest that extending the duration of reporting sessions to compensate for increasing workloads may not represent the optimal solution for less-experienced radiologists.

来源:Br J Radiol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Alshabibi, Suleiman, Albeshan, et al. Variations in breast cancer detection rates during mammogram-reading sessions: does experience have an impact? Br J Radiol. 2021. PMID: 34735290. doi:10.1259/bjr.20210895

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。