儿童骨骼调查中附加侧位X线对疑似虐待的价值
结果显示多数骨折(14/16)正位即可见,仅2例骨折仅侧位发现,附加侧位未导致过度诊断,且能提升正常病例的报告信心(p=0.001-0.003)。
要点
- 儿童骨骼调查中附加侧位对骨折检出增益有限,多数骨折正位即可见。
- 附加侧位可提升正常骨骼调查的报告信心,但不改变骨折病例的信心。
- 附加侧位未导致正常病例的过度诊断。
关键影像表现/征象
- 16处附肢骨折在两种投照中成像(6处腕、5处膝、5处踝)。
- 14/16处骨折在正位视图上即可见,仅2处骨折(1处桡骨远端、1处胫骨远端)在盲法阅片时仅侧位发现。
- 1处骨折(胫骨远端)仅正位可见(侧位不可见)。
- 附加侧位未导致剩余正常研究的骨折过度诊断。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 附加侧位后,正常研究的报告信心评分改善(p=0.001-0.003),但发现骨折时信心无显著改善(p>0.05)。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 在儿童骨骼调查中,正位投影对骨折检出已足够,附加侧位主要价值在于提升正常病例的报告信心。
- 阅片时应注意仅侧位可见的骨折(如桡骨远端、胫骨远端)和仅正位可见的骨折(如胫骨远端),避免漏诊。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
AIM: To determine the added value of lateral limb radiographs in suspected physical abuse (SPA), particularly with regard to fracture detection and reporter confidence.
METHODS AND MATERIALS: A 3-year (October 2017 to November 2020) retrospective study was conducted. Two blinded paediatric radiologists independently reviewed the appendicular radiographs for the presence of fractures, first by reviewing just the frontal projections, then both frontal and lateral radiographs. The additional yield of fractures and changes in reporting confidence scores were recorded.
RESULTS: One hundred and thirty-eight skeletal surveys (29 live, 109 deceased children) were assessed, consisting of 16 appendicular fractures imaged in two projections (six wrist, five knee, five ankle). In the majority of cases (14/16) the fractures were already visible on the frontal view with only two fractures (one distal radius, one distal tibial) identified only by lateral projection on the blinded review. One fracture (distal tibia) was visible only on the frontal radiograph (not lateral view). The addition of lateral projection did not lead to overcalling of fractures in the remaining normal studies. Radiologist confidence scores showed an improvement with the addition of a lateral projection when a study was thought to be normal (p=0.001-0.003), but not when a fracture was identified (p>0.05).
CONCLUSION: The addition of lateral radiographs improves reporting confidence in normal skeletal surveys, but only rarely helped to detect additional fractures given that most were visible on frontal projections. Larger multicentre studies of clinical practice are required to confirm these findings.
引用
- Meshaka, Garbera, Arthurs, et al. Value of additional lateral radiographs in paediatric skeletal surveys for suspected physical abuse. Clin Radiol. 2021. PMID: 34742547. doi:10.1016/j.crad.2021.09.019
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。