儿童疑似中肠扭转的一线超声应用国际实践调查
对儿科放射学会与欧洲儿科放射学会成员进行自愿线上调查,覆盖38国179家医院共227份应答。结果显示欧洲医院78.2%使用一线超声,北美为28.9%,其他地区为61.1%。受访者最常认为正式指南发布可促进推广应用。
要点
- 中肠扭转疑诊时一线是否选超声,各区域差异大,北美明显低于欧洲。
- 多数机构无正式临床路径、无标准化报告模板,检查中不常规给口服或鼻胃管液体。
- 北美最常见障碍为超声技师培训与能力,欧洲为放射科医生接受度。
核心结论
- 儿童疑似中肠扭转的一线超声使用率存在显著地区差异,欧洲最高、北美最低。
- 阻碍推广的因素反映地区人员配置与培训模式差异,正式发布指南被视为促进推广的常见因素。
研究设计与样本
- 研究类型为国际多中心横断面调查,由儿科放射学会与欧洲儿科放射学会联合开展。
- 调查时间为2025年8月至9月,向两会成员发放自愿线上问卷。
- 共分析227份应答,代表38个国家179家医院,按地理区域进行应答分析。
- 调查内容包括一线超声使用、经验年限、操作人员、方案细节与影响推广的因素。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 欧洲医院中一线超声使用率为78.2%,北美医院为28.9%,其他地区医院为61.1%。
- 所有区域多数机构报告无正式临床路径。
- 所有区域多数机构报告无标准化报告模板。
- 所有区域多数机构报告检查期间不常规给予口服或鼻胃管液体。
- 欧洲最常见推广障碍为放射科医生接受度,北美最常见为超声技师培训与能力。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 阅片时需注意多数机构缺乏标准化报告模板,中肠扭转超声描述一致性可能不足。
- 检查流程在不同机构差异较大,转诊或会诊时应确认对方是否常规使用一线超声。
- 北美超声技师培训不足是主要障碍,提示当地开展时需重视技术人员胜任力。
- 正式指南发布被多数受访者视为促进普及的因素,可关注后续共识或指南更新。
局限性
- 调查为自愿作答,存在应答偏倚,可能高估或低估部分地区实践情况。
- 研究基于机构或个体自报实践,未与实际医疗记录或影像结果核实。
- 不同地区应答数量不均衡,区域间比较可能受样本构成影响。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
BACKGROUND: Midgut volvulus is a surgical emergency that requires rapid diagnosis to prevent bowel ischemia. Although fluoroscopic upper gastrointestinal examinations have traditionally been used in some countries, ultrasound is gaining acceptance as a potential first-line imaging modality.
OBJECTIVE: To evaluate international practice patterns of first-line ultrasound use for suspected midgut volvulus in children and identify factors influencing adoption.
MATERIALS AND METHODS: A voluntary online survey was distributed to members of the Society for Pediatric Radiology and the European Society of Paediatric Radiology between August and September 2025. Survey items addressed institutional use of first-line ultrasound for suspected midgut volvulus, duration of experience, personnel performing examinations, protocol details, and factors influencing adoption. Responses were analyzed by geographic region.
RESULTS: Overall, 227 responses representing 179 hospitals across 38 countries were analyzed. First-line ultrasound was used by 78.2% of European hospitals, 28.9% of North American hospitals, and 61.1% of hospitals in other regions. In Europe, the most frequently reported barrier to adoption was radiologist acceptance, whereas in North America the most common barrier was sonographer training and competence. Across all regions, most institutions reported no formal clinical pathway, no standardized reporting template, and no routine administration of oral or nasogastric fluid during the examination. Publication of formal guidelines was the most commonly reported factor that respondents believed would facilitate adoption.
CONCLUSION: Use of ultrasound as first-line imaging for suspected midgut volvulus varies widely across regions. Barriers to adoption reflect local staffing and training models, and formal published guidelines were frequently identified as a potential facilitator of broader implementation.
引用
- Tutman, Perucca, Chan, et al. International practice patterns in the use of ultrasound as first-line imaging for suspected midgut volvulus in children: a joint society for pediatric radiology-European society of paediatric radiology survey. Pediatr Radiol. 2026. PMID: 42776228. doi:10.1007/s00247-026-06792-y
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。