临床孤立综合征中视神经2D-STIR与脑3D-FLAIR对视神经病变的对照研究
该回顾性研究纳入51例伦敦大学学院前瞻性队列中的临床孤立综合征患者,全部接受视神经2D-STIR、脑3D-FLAIR、OCT及视觉功能评估,以临床视神经炎诊断为参考标准。两种序列敏感性均为100%,2D-STIR与3D-FLAIR的特异度分别为85.5%和88.7%,准确度分别为91.2%和93.1%。研究提示常规脑3D-FLAIR可作为无法获得视神经专用序列时的实用替代方案。
要点
- 视神经2D-STIR与脑3D-FLAIR对视神经病变检出的一致性近于完美,Cohen's Kappa = 0.961,p < 0.001
- 3D-FLAIR特异度88.7%、准确度93.1%,略高于2D-STIR的85.5%和91.2%
- 2D-STIR阳性眼视觉功能和视网膜层厚度明显差于阴性眼,视神经病变具有结构和功能意义
核心结论
- 脑3D-FLAIR与视神经2D-STIR在检出视神经病变中一致性高,诊断性能相当
- 3D-FLAIR可作为常规脑MRI中评估视神经的实用替代方案,尤其在无法获得视神经专用序列时
- 视神经病变与更差的视觉功能和视网膜层变薄相关
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性研究,纳入伦敦大学学院前瞻性队列中51例临床孤立综合征患者
- 所有患者均接受视神经2D-STIR、脑3D-FLAIR、光学相干断层扫描及视觉功能评估
- 参考标准为临床视神经炎诊断
关键影像表现/征象
- 2D-STIR与3D-FLAIR均可检出视神经病变,两者病变长度测量高度一致,ICC = 0.886
- 病变检出一致性近于完美,Cohen's Kappa = 0.961,p < 0.001
- 2D-STIR阳性眼视觉功能和视网膜层厚度明显差于阴性眼
诊断标准与关键数值
- 诊断标准:以临床视神经炎诊断作为参考标准
- 2D-STIR诊断指标:敏感性100%,特异性85.5%,准确度91.2%
- 3D-FLAIR诊断指标:敏感性100%,特异性88.7%,准确度93.1%
- 病变检出一致性:Cohen's Kappa = 0.961,p < 0.001;病变长度测量一致性:ICC = 0.886
临床应用与阅片要点
- 当视神经专用2D-STIR序列不可得时,常规脑3D-FLAIR可用于评估视神经病变
- 3D-FLAIR在无症状眼中检出病变为11.3%,2D-STIR为14.5%,专用序列仍有微弱的额外检出优势
- 报告发现视神经病变时应结合视觉功能及OCT视网膜层厚度信息综合判断
局限性
- 本研究为回顾性设计
- 单中心研究,样本量为51例
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVES: The 2024 McDonald criteria for multiple sclerosis include the optic nerve as the fifth location for dissemination in space. While optic nerve 2D-STIR is the recommended diagnostic approach, brain 3D-FLAIR is more routinely acquired during initial assessments of clinically isolated syndrome (CIS). This study compares optic nerve lesion detection between the two imaging techniques in CIS and evaluates the structural and functional significance of the lesions.
MATERIALS AND METHODS: This retrospective study included 51 CIS patients from a prospective cohort at University College London. All underwent optic nerve 2D-STIR, brain 3D-FLAIR, and optical coherence tomography (OCT), as well as visual function assessments. Optic nerve lesions were identified, and lesion lengths were recorded using both imaging techniques. Diagnostic performance was evaluated using clinical optic neuritis diagnosis as the reference standard. Visual function and OCT (pRNFL, GCIPL, and GCL) were compared between 2D-STIR-positive and negative eyes.
RESULTS: 2D-STIR and 3D-FLAIR both showed 100% sensitivity. Specificity and accuracy were 85.5% and 91.2% for 2D-STIR, and 88.7% and 93.1% for 3D-FLAIR, respectively. Lesion detection agreement was near-perfect (Cohen's Kappa = 0.961, p < 0.001), and lesion length measurements were highly concordant (ICC = 0.886). In non-symptomatic eyes, 2D-STIR detected slightly more lesions (14.5% vs 11.3%). 2D-STIR-positive eyes showed significantly worse visual function and thinner retinal layers.
CONCLUSION: Brain 3D-FLAIR and optic nerve 2D-STIR show high agreement in detecting optic nerve lesions, with comparable diagnostic performance. 3D-FLAIR is a practical alternative for assessing the optic nerves in routine brain imaging, especially when dedicated optic nerve acquisitions are unavailable.
KEY POINTS: Question Compare brain 3D-FLAIR with dedicated optic nerve 2D-STIR for detecting optic nerve lesions in CIS and determine their association with early clinical measures. Findings 2D-STIR and 3D-FLAIR showed excellent agreement and performance in detecting optic nerve lesions. Optic nerve lesions were associated with worse vision and retinal layer thinning. Clinical relevance 3D-FLAIR offers a feasible alternative for evaluating the optic nerves on routine brain MRI, particularly when dedicated optic nerve acquisitions are unavailable.
引用
- Larassati, Foster, Prados, et al. Optic nerve lesions on optic nerve 2D-STIR vs brain 3D-FLAIR in clinically isolated syndromes. Eur Radiol. 2026. PMID: 42763330. doi:10.1007/s00330-026-12873-1
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。