文献速递神经MRCT

神经放射二诊意见改变约五分之一病例的管理:差异与错误类型回顾性队列研究

A formal neuroradiology second opinion service changes management in one in five cases: a retrospective cohort study of discrepancies and types of errors.
PubMed 文献 · Clin Radiol · 2026-08-25

本研究回顾性分析英国某三级神经中心12个月内580例正式神经放射二诊报告,比较原报告与亚专科二诊报告的一致性。结果显示总体差异率42.2%,重大差异占21.4%,其中血管研究最常见;错误类型以推理错误为主。二诊意见在约五分之一病例中改变管理,提示认知性误读是质量改进重点。

要点

  • 约五分之一病例因二诊意见改变临床管理,血管病变是重大差异最常见来源。
  • 错误类型以推理错误为主,其次为自满、漏读及搜索满足,提示需加强认知训练。
  • 重大差异几乎均导致诊断改变(99.2%),治疗改变率亦高达93.5%。

核心结论

  • 亚专科神经放射二诊报告在42.2%的病例中与原报告存在差异,其中21.4%为重大差异,约五分之一病例因二诊意见改变管理。
  • 重大差异中99.2%改变诊断,93.5%改变治疗,68.5%改变进一步检查计划。
  • 推理错误是最常见的错误类型(占全部差异的44.5%),其次为自满(22.0%)、漏读(15.1%)和搜索满足(11.4%)。

研究设计与样本

  • 回顾性队列研究,纳入英国某三级神经中心2024年4月至2025年3月连续580例正式神经放射二诊报告。
  • 影像构成:MRI占84%(487/580),CT占16%(93/580)。
  • 差异分类:重大差异、轻微差异、完全一致,并按Kim-Mansfield改良Renfrew错误分类法进行错误分型。

关键影像表现/征象

  • 影像表现:原文未提供具体征象描述。
  • 血管研究是重大差异最常见的来源,占所有重大差异的49.2%。
  • 错误类型分布:推理错误109例(44.5%),自满54例(22.0%),漏读37例(15.1%),搜索满足28例(11.4%)。

诊断标准与关键数值

  • 总体差异率42.2%(245/580),其中重大差异21.4%(124/580),轻微差异20.9%(121/580)。
  • 重大差异中:推理错误占42.7%(53/124),自满占27.4%(34/124),漏读占21%(26/124)。
  • 重大差异的临床影响:诊断改变123/124(99.2%),治疗改变116/124(93.5%),检查计划改变85/124(68.5%)。

临床应用与阅片要点

  • 阅片时警惕血管病变,因其在二诊重大差异中占比最高。
  • 注意避免推理错误、自满和漏读,特别是复杂病例建议主动寻求二诊。
  • 重大差异常导致诊断和治疗改变,报告时应强调关键阳性发现。

局限性

  • 单中心回顾性研究,可能受转诊偏倚影响。
  • 二诊报告本身作为参考标准,可能存在一定主观性。
  • 未报告不同亚专科或检查类型的具体差异率。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开

AIM: To quantify discrepancy rates between referring reports and subspecialist neuroradiology second-opinion reports in a UK tertiary neuro centre, describe the clinical impact of the service, and classify discrepancies using the Kim-Mansfield modification of the Renfrew error taxonomy.

MATERIAL AND METHODS: Retrospective review of consecutive formal neuroradiology second opinion reports over 12 months (April 2024 to March 2025) at a tertiary neuro centre. Agreement between referring reports and second-opinion reports was classified into: major discrepancy, minor discrepancy, or complete agreement. Discrepancies were further categorised by error type using the Kim-Mansfield classification.

RESULTS: A total of 580 studies were reviewed (magnetic resonance imaging [MRI]: 487/580, 84%; computed tomography [CT]: 93/580, 16%). The overall discrepancy rate was 42.2% (245/580), including 21.4% major discrepancies (124/580) and 20.9% minor discrepancies (121/580). Vascular studies were the commonest major discrepancies (61/124, 49.2%). Error typing across all discrepancies demonstrated predominantly cognitive/interpretive categories: faulty reasoning was the most frequent (109/245, 44.5%), followed by complacency (54/245, 22.0%), underreading (37/245, 15.1%), and satisfaction of search (28/245, 11.4%). In major discrepancies, faulty reasoning remained the most common (53/124, 42.7%), followed by complacency (34/124, 27.4%) and underreading (26/124, 21%). Major discrepancies were associated with high clinical impact, including a change in diagnosis (123/124, 99.2%), a change in treatment (116/124, 93.5%), and a change in investigation change (85/124, 68.5%).

CONCLUSION: Subspecialist neuroradiology second-opinion reporting identified discrepancies in over two-fifths of cases, including management-altering discrepancies in approximately one in five. Faulty reasoning was the dominant error type, supporting targeted quality improvement interventions focused on interpretive/cognitive pitfalls.

来源:Clin Radiol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Abdelsalam, Radon, Mills, et al. A formal neuroradiology second opinion service changes management in one in five cases: a retrospective cohort study of discrepancies and types of errors. Clin Radiol. 2026. PMID: 42759332. doi:10.1016/j.crad.2026.107462

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。