放射学不是任务:人工智能与放射学认知体系
本文为观点性论述,将放射学定义为一种认知体系,即影像观察转化为可验证、可执行、可修正且可归责的临床知识的组织化基础设施。作者认为当前AI缺乏认知自主性,其输出依赖制度性标准与责任授权;即使未来多模态或智能体系统扩展信息整合,仍不自动获得裁决冲突、修正标准或承担责任的能力。
要点
- AI可替代任务、重组角色,但不会自动获得临床知识的权威与可归责性
- 多模态或智能体AI整合更多信息不等于获得裁决冲突或修正标准的权力
- 责任分布在放射科医生、临床团队、厂商与监管者之间,必须保持可归因
核心结论
- 放射学作为认知体系,其知识权威依赖制度维持的标准、修正流程和可归责授权,AI目前不具备认知自主性
研究设计与样本
- 观点性论文,未报告具体样本量或研究设计
- 未涉及具体设备、序列或参考标准
临床应用与阅片要点
- 阅片报告中对AI输出的采用应将其定位为辅助信息,最终诊断意见须由具备制度授权者确认
- 临床中需警惕将AI的功能表现等同于认知替代,避免把算法输出直接视为可归责的临床知识
- 当AI与其他信息冲突时,裁决权应留给有制度责任的临床角色,而非默认算法正确
局限性
- 本文为观点性论述,缺乏实证数据支持
- 未报告系统性检索或定量分析
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
Artificial intelligence (AI) in radiology is often introduced as a tool but discussed as a replacement, conflating functional performance with epistemic substitution. This Perspective defines radiology as an epistemic system: the organized clinical infrastructure through which imaging observations become warranted, actionable, revisable, and accountable knowledge. Existing validation and governance frameworks explain how AI should be assessed and managed. The epistemic-system framing reorganizes these elements around a distinct question: how do algorithmic outputs acquire the authority and answerability required of clinical knowledge? Current AI lacks epistemic autonomy because its outputs remain dependent on institutionally maintained standards, corrective processes, and accountable authorization. Foreseeable multimodal and agentic systems may integrate electronic health records, prior examinations, pathology, outcomes, and workflow tools, thereby expanding their epistemic participation. Informational integration, however, does not itself confer authority to adjudicate conflict, revise standards, or assume responsibility. Accountability is distributed across radiologists, clinical teams, health systems, manufacturers, and regulators, but it must remain attributable. AI may replace tasks and reorganize roles; replacing radiology requires transfer of the epistemic functions and institutional authority through which outputs become trustworthy clinical knowledge.
引用
- Erturk. Radiology Is not a Task: AI and the Epistemic System of Radiology. Acad Radiol. 2026. PMID: 42728185. doi:10.1016/j.acra.2026.08.107
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。