腰椎间盘退变Pfirrmann分级的影像与骨科阅片一致性
回顾性分析60例腰椎MRI,4名放射科医生与4名骨科医生独立对5个椎间盘分别使用5级和8级Pfirrmann系统分级,并在2个月后重复评估。结果显示不同评估者组间一致性存在差异,骨科顾问医生一致性最高,提示需要标准化分级并考虑定量MRI生物标志物。
要点
- 骨科顾问医生在5级与8级Pfirrmann系统的评估者间一致性最高。
- 放射科顾问医生5级系统重复评估的评估者内一致性最高,为76%。
- 报告椎间盘退变分级时需注意不同专业和年资评估者间存在系统差异。
核心结论
- 在腰椎退变性椎间盘病的Pfirrmann分级中,放射科医生与骨科医生之间存在评估者间变异性。
- 骨科顾问医生的评估者间一致性最高,8级系统kappa达0.97。
- 研究提示需要标准化分级方案,并探索定量MRI生物标志物以提高可靠性。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性研究,纳入60例腰椎MRI扫描。
- 4名放射科医生和4名骨科医生参与评估,每组各含2名顾问医生和2名专科注册医生。
- 每名评估者对每例扫描的5个椎间盘独立进行5级和8级Pfirrmann分级。
- 2个月后重复分级以评估评估者内一致性。
关键影像表现/征象
- 骨科顾问医生5级系统二次加权kappa为0.89,8级系统为0.97。
- 全部评估者5级系统的Krippendorff's alpha为0.67,Gwet's AC2为0.67。
- 全部评估者Fleiss's kappa仅为0.37,属于一般一致性水平。
- 放射科顾问医生在5级系统重复评估中达到最高的76%评估者内一致率。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 骨科顾问医生5级Pfirrmann系统二次加权kappa为0.89(95%CI:0.86-0.92)。
- 骨科顾问医生8级Pfirrmann系统二次加权kappa为0.97(95%CI:0.96-0.98)。
- 全部评估者5级系统Krippendorff's alpha为0.67(95%CI:0.63-0.72)。
- 全部评估者5级系统Gwet's AC2为0.67(95%CI:0.64-0.71)。
- 全部评估者Fleiss's kappa为0.37(95%CI:0.27-0.47)。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 阅片时应注意Pfirrmann分级的评估者间差异,尤其是跨专业会诊场景。
- 报告腰椎间盘退变分级时建议注明分级系统和评估者背景。
- 对于临界级别椎间盘,应结合矢状位T2信号与椎间盘高度综合判断。
局限性
- 回顾性研究设计本身存在选择偏倚风险。
- 研究仅纳入60例腰椎MRI,样本量相对有限。
- 原文作者指出需要标准化分级和定量MRI生物标志物以改善可靠性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
INTRODUCTION: The Pfirrmann grading system is widely used for assessing degenerative disc disease (DDD) on T2-weighted MRI but is criticised for its subjectivity. This study evaluates inter-rater reliability between radiologists and orthopaedic surgeons using this system.
METHODS: A retrospective review of 60 lumbar spine MRI scans. Four radiologists and four orthopaedic surgeons (two consultants, two specialist registrars per group) independently graded five intervertebral discs per scan using both the 5-level and 8-level Pfirrmann grading systems. Grading was repeated after two months to assess intra-rater reliability.
RESULTS: The highest inter-rater agreement was observed among orthopaedic consultants, with quadratic weighted kappa values of 0.89 (95 % CI: 0.86-0.92) and 0.97 (95 % CI: 0.96-0.98) for the 5- and 8-level grading systems, respectively. Overall agreement across all assessors using the 5-level system was good according to Krippendorff's alpha (ordinal) of 0.67 (95 % CI: 0.63-0.72) and Gwet's AC2 (quadratic) of 0.67 (95 % CI: 0.64-0.71).In contrast, Fleiss's kappa indicated only fair agreement overall, with a coefficient of 0.37 (95 % CI: 0.27-0.47). Radiology consultants achieved the highest intra-rater agreement (76 %) on reassessment when using the 5-level grading system, although they also demonstrated notable grading discrepancies.
CONCLUSION: This study found that variability exists across assessor groups when comparing inter-rater reliability between radiologists and orthopaedic surgeons using the Pfirrmann grading system for lumbar DDD. This highlights the need for standardised grading and the potential role of quantitative MRI biomarkers to improve reliability.
引用
- Marland, McDonnell, Pan, et al. Inter-rater reliability between radiologists and orthopaedic surgeons when assessing lumbar degenerative disc disease using the Pfirrmann grading system. Eur J Radiol. 2026. PMID: 42710426. doi:10.1016/j.ejrad.2026.113212
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。