CASSEAL胎儿心血管系统3×3结构化评估的多中心验证
前瞻性多中心观察研究纳入1494例18-22+6周胎儿,由7个中心15名操作者使用CASSEAL 3×3序列采集9个轴位切面。完整显示率由78%升至84%,平均检查时间由8.0分钟降至5.8分钟。结论认为该框架可行性高、学习曲线短、多中心可重复性好。
要点
- 9个轴位切面按心下、心内、心上3个区域顺序采集
- 前壁脊柱位和母体高BMI增加切面显示不全风险
- 任一轴位切面异常可作为筛查心血管异常的线索
核心结论
- CASSEAL算法在胎儿心血管系统扩展评估中显示高可行性、短学习曲线和稳健的多中心可重复性
- 3×3序列框架便于在常规多中心筛查中标准化显示心上、心内和心下区域
研究设计与样本
- 前瞻性多中心观察性研究,7个中心15名操作者,共1494例胎儿检查
- 纳入18至22+6周非选择的单胎和双胎妊娠
- 标准化培训后先完成30例实施阶段检查,随后完成至少50例验证阶段检查
关键影像表现/征象
- CASSEAL算法按心下、心内、心上区域顺序采集9个轴位切面
- 胎儿脊柱前位时轴位切面显示不全风险明显升高,校正OR为3.95
- 母体BMI每增加1 kg/m²,显示不全风险校正OR为1.06
诊断标准与关键数值
- 以至少1个轴位切面显示异常作为筛查标准,特异度和阴性预测值较高
临床应用与阅片要点
- 按心下、心内、心上顺序采集9个轴位切面有助于避免遗漏扩展心血管结构
- 胎儿脊柱前位和母体高BMI时需预判显示不全风险并延长扫查或调整手法
- 任一轴位切面形态异常均应触发进一步胎儿超声心动图检查
- 完成约30例培训后检查效率可显著提高,适合多中心推广
局限性
- 敏感性估计需谨慎解读,因未对全部病例行产后系统超声心动图
- 筛查性能为探索性分析,基于可获得产前和产后随访数据
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVES: To evaluate the feasibility, transferability, and implementation performance of the cardiovascular system sonographic evaluation algorithm (CASSEAL), a structured 3 × 3 sequential framework for second-trimester ultrasound assessment of the extended fetal cardiovascular system, in a multicenter screening setting.
METHODS: This prospective multicenter observational study included unselected singleton and twin pregnancies examined between 18 and 22+6 weeks' gestation. After standardized training, operators completed an initial implementation phase (first 30 examinations) followed by a validation phase (≥50 additional examinations). The CASSEAL algorithm consists of sequential acquisition of 9 axial planes organized into infracardiac, cardiac, and supracardiac territories within a structured 3 × 3 framework. The primary outcome was complete visualization of all 9 views. Secondary outcomes included examination time, factors associated with incomplete visualization, and exploratory screening performance using absence of normality in ≥1 axial view as the screening criterion.
RESULTS: A total of 1494 fetal examinations performed by 15 operators across 7 centers were analyzed. Complete visualization of all 9 views increased from 78% in the implementation phase to 84% in the validation phase (p = .01). Mean examination time decreased significantly after completion of the learning phase (8.0 ± 6.4 versus 5.8 ± 3.9 minutes; p < .001). In multivariable analysis, the validation phase independently reduced the likelihood of incomplete visualization (adjusted OR, 0.65; p < .01), whereas higher maternal body mass index (adjusted OR, 1.06 per kg/m2; p < .001) and anterior fetal spine position (adjusted OR, 3.95; p < .001) increased this risk. Thirty-six fetuses (2.4%) had confirmed cardiovascular anomalies, vascular variants, or relevant ultrasound markers. Exploratory screening performance estimates based on available prenatal and postnatal follow-up suggested high specificity and negative predictive value, although sensitivity estimates should be interpreted cautiously because systematic postnatal echocardiography was not available.
CONCLUSIONS: The CASSEAL algorithm demonstrates high feasibility, a short learning curve, and robust multicenter reproducibility for structured second-trimester evaluation of the extended fetal cardiovascular system. The integrated 3 × 3 sequential framework may facilitate standardized assessment of supracardiac, cardiac, and infracardiac territories in routine multicenter screening practice.
引用
- Arribas, Payo, Martín, et al. Multicenter Implementation and Validation of the Structured 3 × 3 CASSEAL Framework for Second-Trimester Assessment of the Extended Fetal Cardiovascular System. J Ultrasound Med. 2026. PMID: 42671062. doi:10.1002/jum.70422
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。