美国ACGME神经放射学专科培训项目现状调查
对美国91个ACGME认证的诊断性神经放射学专科培训项目主任进行21问在线调查,共60个(66%)项目有可评估回复。结果显示大型项目在填满培训名额和扩增名额方面均优于小型项目,但两者均面临来自大型项目和地理位置的招募竞争。
要点
- 大型神经放射学培训项目比小型项目更容易填满全部名额。
- 地理位置是影响所有项目招募的普遍挑战之一。
- 大型与小型项目的扩招及招募策略应有所不同。
核心结论
- 大型神经放射学项目比小型项目更容易填满全部ACGME批准的名额,且近5年更常增加名额。
- 大型项目竞争和地理位置是影响神经放射学项目招募的共同挑战,与项目规模无关。
- 扩大和填补美国神经放射学项目的策略应根据项目规模而有所不同。
研究设计与样本
- 为横断面在线问卷调查,研究对象为91个美国ACGME认证的诊断性神经放射学培训项目的项目主任。
- 问卷包含21个问题,共60个项目(66%)返回可评估回复。
- 按批准名额的中位数将项目分为大型(大于中位数)和小型(小于或等于中位数)两类比较。
- 以P<0.05为统计学显著标准。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 2024-2025学年,37/60(62%)的项目填满全部培训名额。
- 大型项目填满全部名额的比例为20/25(80%),高于小型项目的17/35(49%),P=0.017。
- 自2019-2020学年以来,大型项目增加名额的比例为14/25(56%),高于小型项目的5/35(14.3%),P=0.002。
- 通过国家住院医师匹配项目填补全部名额时,小型项目19/34(54%)比大型项目5/25(20%)更困难,P<0.001。
- 项目主任任期长短与能否填满培训项目无统计学相关,P=0.75。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 在评估培训项目招募难度时,应同时考虑项目规模与地理位置因素。
- 大型项目的独特挑战为名额数量多,小型项目的独特挑战为来自邻近项目的竞争。
局限性
- 为自我报告的问卷调查,可能存在选择偏倚和报告偏倚。
- 仅66%的项目返回可评估回复,未回复项目情况不明确。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
PURPOSE: U.S. ACGME-approved neuroradiology fellowship positions continue to increase in the setting of a national radiologist shortage, and the challenges faced by expanding fellowship programs could vary with program size. The aim of our project was to survey neuroradiology fellowship Program Directors (PDs) at US ACGME-approved diagnostic neuroradiology fellowship programs to better understand the challenges and practices in fellow recruitment, growth of fellowship class size, and other factors.
MATERIALS AND METHODS: An online 21-question survey was distributed to PDs of US ACGME-approved diagnostic neuroradiology fellowships (n=91). All variables were appropriately summarized and correlations assessed. Programs were dichotomized as large (greater than median number of approved spots) or small (less than or equal to median). Differences between large and small programs were evaluated with appropriate statistical tests. Effects associated with P<0.05 were considered statistically significant.
RESULTS: PDs from 60/91(66%) institutions had evaluable responses. For the 2024-2025 academic year, 37/60(62%) programs filled all their fellowship positions. The proportion of large programs (20/25,80%) filling all their positions was higher (P=0.017) than small programs (17/35,49%). Large programs (14/25,56%) increased the number of fellowship positions more than small programs (5/35,14.3%) since 2019-2020 (P=0.002). Small programs had more difficulty filling all fellowship positions (19/34,54%) than large programs (5/25,20%) through national residency match program (P<0.001). Both large and small programs were challenged by other large programs and geographical location. Unique challenges for large and small programs were the high number of fellowship positions and competition from nearby programs, respectively. Length of PD tenure was not statistically correlated with the ability to fill the fellowship program (P=0.75). Small programs had a larger median of ABR-alternative pathway candidates [29%(0-66.7%)] than large programs [9.5%(0-16.7%)], the distribution did not differ significantly (P=0.19).
CONCLUSIONS: Large neuroradiology fellowship programs filled all ACGME-approved positions with less difficulty and often increased their available fellowship positions in the last 5 years, compared to small programs. Competition from large programs and geographical location challenge recruitment for neuroradiology fellowship programs irrespective of size. Strategies for expanding and filling U.S. neuroradiology fellowships should vary based on fellowship size with a goal to help alleviate the on-going radiologist shortage.
引用
- Nayate, Vedantham, Hadi, et al. A Snapshot of US ACGME-Approved Neuroradiology Fellowship Programs- How are We Training and Growing? AJNR Am J Neuroradiol. 2026. PMID: 42618338. doi:10.3174/ajnr.A9599
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。