超声骨化面积比预测儿童骨龄:无辐射列线图的开发与内部验证
本研究为单中心前瞻性设计,纳入 1053 例 3–15 岁儿童,以左桡骨远端、尺骨及股骨的超声面积骨化比(ORs)为预测变量,以放射学 RUS-CHN 骨龄为参考标准。通过 LASSO 回归构建列线图,在验证集中骨龄预测 MAE 为 2.94 个月,并显著校正发育不一致儿童的年龄锚定偏倚。该工具仅针对 RUS-CHN 标准校准,需外部验证后方可临床使用。
要点
- 多部位超声面积骨化比 ICC>0.88,重复性优良。
- 列线图对发育提前或延迟儿童较基线模型骨龄 MAE 降低超过 60%。
- 该列线图仅校准于 RUS-CHN 标准,不能直接推广到其他骨龄标准。
核心结论
- 多部位超声面积骨化比是高重复性的无辐射骨成熟度指标。
- 内部验证的列线图可估计 RUS-CHN 放射骨龄,并校正发育不一致儿童的年龄锚定偏倚。
- 数值校准仅针对 RUS-CHN 标准,临床使用前需外部多中心和纵向验证。
研究设计与样本
- 纳入 1053 例 3–15 岁儿童,按 7:3 随机分为训练集和验证集。
- 计算左侧桡骨远端、尺骨和股骨的超声面积骨化比(ORs)。
- 以放射学 RUS-CHN 骨龄作为参考标准,经 LASSO 回归筛选变量构建列线图。
关键影像表现/征象
- 超声面积骨化比取左侧桡骨远端、尺骨和股骨三个部位,二维超声观察骨化区域面积。
- 研究评价了模型在不同发育不一致亚组(成熟提前或延迟)中的表现。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 验证集中列线图预测 RUS-CHN 骨龄的 MAE 为 2.94 个月,RMSE 为 3.67 个月,R² 为 0.989。
- 在成熟提前或延迟儿童中,列线图骨龄预测 MAE 较基线临床特征模型降低超过 60%。
- 预测成年身高(PAH)的次级模型 MAE 为 0.63 cm。
- 超声面积骨化比测量的重复性 ICC>0.88。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 超声骨化面积比可作为随访中减少电离辐射暴露的骨成熟度评估方向,但仅限 RUS-CHN 标准。
- 阅片或报告时需理解该列线图不能替代其他骨龄标准如 GP 图谱的判读。
- 对发育提前或延迟的儿童,该模型可减少仅按实际年龄判断带来的骨龄预测误差。
局限性
- 仅进行内部验证,缺乏外部多中心验证与纵向验证。
- 数值校准仅针对 RUS-CHN 标准,外推至其他骨龄标准受限。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
PURPOSE: Radiographic bone age (BA) assessment involves ionizing radiation, limiting its utility in frequent longitudinal follow-up. This study developed and internally validated a radiation-free nomogram based on multi-site two-dimensional ultrasound area ossification ratios (ORs) to assess Zhonghua-05 (RUS-CHN) radiographic bone age and predicted adult height (PAH), evaluating its incremental value over chronological age.
METHODS: In this single-center prospective study (August 2024 ∼ December 2025), 1,053 children aged 3-15 years were randomized into training and validation sets (7:3). Ultrasound area ORs of the left distal radius, ulna, and femur were calculated. Using radiographic RUS-CHN BA as the reference standard, predictor variables were selected via LASSO regression to construct the nomogram. Model performance was evaluated across the cohort and within developmental discordance subgroups (advanced/delayed maturation).
RESULTS: Ultrasound OR measurements showed excellent reproducibility (ICC > 0.88). In the validation set, the nomogram predicted RUS-CHN BA with a mean absolute error (MAE) of 2.94 months (RMSE = 3.67 months, R2 = 0.989). Crucially, in children with advanced or delayed maturation, the nomogram reduced BA prediction MAE by over 60 % compared to a baseline clinical feature model. The secondary model for PAH achieved an MAE of 0.63 cm.
CONCLUSIONS: Multi-site ultrasound area ORs provide a highly reproducible, radiation-free index of skeletal maturity. As an internally validated, standard-specific research tool, the nomogram estimated RUS-CHN radiographic BA and corrected age-anchoring bias in children with discordant maturation. Because its numeric calibration is specific to the RUS-CHN standard, external multicenter and longitudinal validation is required before clinical use.
ABBREVIATIONS: BA, Bone age; BMI, Body mass index; CI, Confidence interval; GP, Greulich Pyle; ICC, Intraclass correlation coefficient; LASSO, Least absolute shrinkage and selection operator; LoA, Limits of agreement; MAE, Mean absolute error; MPH, Mid‑parental height; OR, Area ossification ratio; PAH, Predicted adult height; QC, Quality control; RMSE, Root mean square error; RUS‑CHN, Radius, ulna, and short bones RUS skeletal‑maturity score, Chinese standard; SOP, Standard operating procedure; TRIPOD, Transparent Reporting of a multivariable prediction model for Individual Prognosis Or Diagnosis.
引用
- Deng, Qiang, Wang, et al. Ultrasound-based area ossification ratios for pediatric radiographic bone age: Development and internal validation of a radiation-free nomogram. Eur J Radiol. 2026. PMID: 42570575. doi:10.1016/j.ejrad.2026.113135
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。