两个深度学习模型对偶发肺结节恶性概率评估的多中心表现与一致性
回顾性多中心病例对照研究纳入231例患者269个偶发肺结节,按大小分层采样,比较两个深度学习模型与Brock模型。结果显示DL1和DL2的AUC分别为0.74和0.72,均优于Brock的0.63,且跨中心表现一致。
要点
- 深度学习模型对偶发肺结节恶性概率判断优于Brock模型,可辅助风险分层。
- 两个DL模型在不同中心间鉴别效能较一致,提示跨机构应用潜力。
- 固定敏感度77.5%时,DL模型特异度60%,高于Brock的44%。
核心结论
- 在多中心、肿瘤富集且按大小分层的偶发肺结节数据集中,两个深度学习模型均优于Brock模型,且跨中心表现一致。
- 额外使用临床数据训练的DL2与仅用筛查数据训练的DL1表现相当。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性多中心病例对照研究,按5-10 mm、10-15 mm、15-30 mm大小层采样。
- 每个中心和大小层目标纳入10个恶性、20个良性结节,最终纳入269个结节来自231例患者。
- 比较两个深度学习模型与Brock模型,使用AUC及固定敏感度下特异度,DeLong法比较AUC。
诊断标准与关键数值
- DL1与DL2的总体AUC分别为0.74和0.72,Brock为0.63,两个DL模型均显著优于Brock,p均小于0.01。
- 以Brock模型10%阈值为参照,其敏感度为77.5%,此时DL1和DL2的特异度均为60%,Brock为44%。
- 分中心AUC:DL1、DL2、Brock在中心1分别为0.76、0.75、0.74;中心2为0.72、0.71、0.55;中心3为0.73、0.71、0.59。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 深度学习模型可作为偶发肺结节恶性风险评估的辅助工具,可能减少不必要随访或有创检查。
- 模型在不同CT特征和患者人群的中心间表现稳定,支持跨机构应用的潜在可行性。
- Brock模型在部分中心AUC下降较明显,而DL模型保持相对稳定。
局限性
- 研究为回顾性病例对照设计,结节样本经过大小分层和肿瘤富集,不能反映真实世界患病率。
- 原文指出仍需在代表性队列和真实世界患病率下进行前瞻性验证。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVES: A screening-trained deep learning (DL) model (DL1) for pulmonary nodule malignancy probability estimation on CT previously demonstrated good discrimination on a single-centre dataset of incidental nodules. An updated DL model (DL2) was trained on both screening and clinical data. We aimed to test the performance of both models in a multicentre dataset of incidental nodules.
MATERIALS AND METHODS: A retrospective, multicentre, case-control dataset of incidental nodules was collected, sampled across size buckets (5-10 mm, 10-15 mm, 15-30 mm), aiming for 10 malignant and 20 benign nodules per bucket and centre, resulting in 270 nodules. Performance was assessed using AUCs and specificity at a fixed sensitivity. AUCs were compared using the DeLong method. Both DL models were compared with the Brock model. Consistent discrimination was investigated by centre-stratified analyses.
RESULTS: The multicentre dataset contained 269 nodules (89 malignant) from 231 patients. DL1 and DL2 achieved AUCs of 0.74 and 0.72, respectively, versus 0.63 for Brock (both p < 0.01). Using a 10% threshold for the Brock model (sensitivity 77.5%), specificity was 60% for both DL models compared with 44% for the Brock model. Centre-specific AUCs for DL1, DL2, and Brock were 0.76, 0.75, and 0.74 (centre 1), 0.72, 0.71, and 0.55 (centre 2), and 0.73, 0.71, and 0.59 (centre 3), respectively.
CONCLUSION: The DL models outperformed the Brock model on a multicentre, cancer-enriched size-stratified dataset and performed consistently across centres, though prospective validation in representative cohorts with real-world prevalences is needed. The DL model trained with additional clinical data performed equal to the screening-trained model.
KEY POINTS: Question How consistent is the performance of a screening-trained deep learning model across multicentre incidental pulmonary nodules, and does an additionally clinically trained model improve performance? Findings The two deep learning models showed similar discrimination, outperforming the clinically used Brock model in the pooled cancer-enriched dataset, and consistent performance across multiple centres. Clinical relevance The current study provides evidence of consistent model performance across centres with varying CT characteristics and patient populations within one country, supporting the potential of DL models to classify pulmonary nodules across different clinical settings.
引用
- Dinnessen, Antonissen, Peeters, et al. Multicentre performance and consistency of two deep learning models for malignancy probability estimation of incidental pulmonary nodules. Eur Radiol. 2026. PMID: 42570025. doi:10.1007/s00330-026-12787-y
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。