对比增强乳腺X线与乳腺MRI的患者偏好:系统综述与Meta分析
本系统综述与Meta分析纳入5项研究共395例受试者,评估患者对对比增强乳腺X线(CEM)与乳腺MRI的偏好。结果显示284例偏好CEM,75例偏好MRI,36例无偏好。汇总后偏好CEM的比例为71.8%(95%CI 67.2%-75.9%),剔除中性应答后升至约81.5%;证据确定性为低。
要点
- 在诊断效能假定相当时,多数患者更偏好CEM而非乳腺MRI。
- 偏好CEM的原因主要与减少幽闭恐惧、检查时间更短和焦虑更低有关。
- 该偏好证据不应被解读为两种检查诊断效能等同。
核心结论
- 现有证据提示,在诊断效能假定可比的临床情境下,患者更常偏好CEM而非乳腺MRI。
- 患者偏好CEM主要与减少幽闭恐惧、检查时间更短和焦虑更低有关。
- 该结果支持在两种检查均临床适宜时,将患者体验纳入共同决策,但不应解读为诊断等效证据。
研究设计与样本
- 纳入5项研究共395例受试者。
- 采用单比例随机效应Meta分析,logit转换与限制性最大似然估计。
- 分析分别在不剔除与剔除中性应答两种条件下进行,并做留一法敏感性分析。
- 证据确定性采用分级评估,总体评级为低。
关键影像表现/征象
- 284例受试者偏好CEM,75例偏好乳腺MRI,36例报告无偏好。
- 患者偏好CEM的原因主要与减少幽闭恐惧、检查时间更短和焦虑更低相关。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 汇总后偏好CEM的比例为71.8%(95%CI 67.2%-75.9%),异质性I²=0%。
- 剔除中性应答后,在有明确偏好的受试者中偏好CEM的比例约为81.5%。
- 留一法分析结果一致。
- 证据确定性被评为低,原因为研究数量有限、临床适应证异质及方法学局限。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 在CEM与乳腺MRI均临床适宜时,可将患者对幽闭恐惧、检查时长和焦虑的偏好纳入共同决策。
- 报告或咨询时不宜将患者偏好数据作为两种检查诊断效能等同的依据。
局限性
- 证据确定性为低,因纳入研究数量有限、临床适应证异质及方法学局限。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
RATIONALE AND OBJECTIVES: Contrast-enhanced mammography (CEM) is increasingly used as an alternative to breast magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) in selected clinical settings. While diagnostic performance has been widely studied, patient preference remains less well characterized. This systematic review and meta-analysis evaluated patient preference for CEM compared to breast MRI.
MATERIALS AND METHODS: MEDLINE and Embase were searched through October 2025 for studies comparing patient preference between CEM and breast MRI. Prospective and survey-based studies reporting extractable preference data were included. A random-effects meta-analysis of single proportions was performed using logit transformation and restricted maximum likelihood estimation. Analyses were conducted with and without neutral responses.
RESULTS: Five studies comprising 395 participants were included. Overall, 284 participants preferred CEM, 75 preferred MRI, and 36 reported no preference. The pooled proportion preferring CEM was 71.8% (95% CI, 67.2%-75.9%) with no significant heterogeneity (I² = 0%). Excluding neutral responses increased preference for CEM to approximately 81.5% among participants expressing a definite preference. Leave-one-out analyses showed consistent results. Certainty of evidence was rated as low because of the limited number of studies, heterogeneous clinical indications, and methodological limitations.
CONCLUSION: Available evidence suggests that patients more frequently prefer CEM than breast MRI when diagnostic performance is assumed to be comparable. Preference appears largely related to reduced claustrophobia, shorter examination time, and lower anxiety. These findings support incorporating patient experience into shared decision-making when both modalities are clinically appropriate, but they should not be interpreted as evidence of diagnostic equivalence.
引用
- Ferre, Benefield, Kuzmiak, et al. Patient Preference for Contrast-Enhanced Mammography Compared to Breast MRI. Acad Radiol. 2026. PMID: 42557201. doi:10.1016/j.acra.2026.07.025
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。