文献速递胸部技术与安全DR

放射科AI工具退役:人员视角与退出框架

Responsible Artificial Intelligence Off-Boarding in Radiology: Staff Perspectives on Decommissioning and a Proposed Withdrawal Framework.
PubMed 文献 · J Am Coll Radiol · 2026-06-06

该研究调查了一家多中心NHS信托机构撤除胸部X线AI分诊工具后2个月的工作人员体验,共40人应答(21.4%)。结果显示撤除后感知患者获益保持稳定(70%同意),但感知工作负担(35%)高于后期实施阶段。研究提出三阶段AI退出协议:撤除前评估、渐进过渡与撤除后支持。

要点

  • AI工具撤除后工作人员对患者获益的感知仍稳定在70%,略低于实施前71.1%。
  • 撤除后感知工作负担(35%)高于后期实施阶段(26.4%),但低于早期实施阶段(51.7%)。
  • 报告人员应答率低(5/40),其中2人表示失望,1人称已依赖该AI工具。

核心结论

  • AI工具撤除同时产生操作上的解脱感和临床价值的损失感,且效应因工作人员角色而异。
  • 应将AI退出管理作为AI全生命周期负责任治理的核心组成部分。
  • 提出三阶段AI退出协议:撤除前评估、渐进过渡和撤除后支持。

研究设计与样本

  • 研究类型为匿名工作人员调查,于一家多中心NHS信托撤除胸部X线AI分诊工具后2个月进行。
  • 应答率为21.4%(40/187),与早期实施阶段调查应答率相当。
  • 调查重复了此前三个实施阶段调查中的部分条目,并新增撤除相关问题。
  • 自由文本采用演绎法分析,并以「工作需求-资源模型」进行解读。
  • 研究为单中心(多中心NHS信托)撤除后调查,非对照研究。

关键影像表现/征象

  • 原文涉及的是胸部X线AI分诊工具撤除后的工作人员体验,未报告具体影像征象。

诊断标准与关键数值

  • 撤除后感知患者获益:70%(28/40)同意,对比实施前71.1%(32/45)、早期实施65.5%(19/29)、后期实施67.9%(36/53)。
  • 撤除后感知工作负担:35%(14/40),高于后期实施阶段26.4%(14/53),低于早期实施阶段51.7%(15/29)。
  • 自由文本共22条,常见主题包括临床价值或流程效率的损失、撤除后的操作解脱感、AI启用升级期间的患者情绪劳动。

临床应用与阅片要点

  • AI工具撤除前应评估对临床流程的影响,识别可能依赖该工具的工作人员角色。
  • 撤除应采用渐进过渡方式,避免突然中断对报告人员工作流的冲击。
  • 撤除后需提供支持,关注报告人员对AI依赖产生的心理负担和适应问题。
  • 日常阅片报告中应记录AI工具使用状态,便于后续撤除时评估影响。

局限性

  • 应答率仅21.4%,且报告人员应答极低(5/40),可能低估报告人员对撤除的反应。
  • 单中心调查,结果的外推性有限。
  • 调查为撤除后2个月的横断面数据,无法反映长期适应情况。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开

PURPOSE: Artificial intelligence (AI) governance commonly emphasizes procurement, validation, deployment, and performance monitoring but lack guidance on how embedded AI tools should be withdrawn when funding, contracts, or strategy change abruptly. We examined staff experience after withdrawal of a chest radiograph AI triage tool and developed a practical framework for responsible AI off-boarding.

METHODS: An anonymous staff survey was circulated 2 months after decommissioning of a chest radiograph AI triage tool at a multisite National Health Service trust. The survey repeated selected items from three earlier implementation-phase surveys, with added decommissioning-specific questions on workflow, perceived patient benefit, emotional burden, and future AI engagement. Quantitative responses were summarized descriptively. Free text responses were analyzed deductively and interpreted using the Job Demands-Resources model.

RESULTS: The response rate was 21.4% (40 of 187), comparable to earlier survey rounds. Perceived patient benefit from AI remained stable, with 70% (28 of 40) agreement postdecommissioning versus 71.1% (32 of 45) pre-implementation, 65.5% (19 of 29) early implementation, and 67.9% (36 of 53) late implementation. Perceived logistical burden postdecommissioning (35%, 14 of 40) was higher than at late implementation (26.4%, 14 of 53) but lower than at early implementation (51.7%, 15 of 29). Response rate from reporting staff was low (5 of 40), with two voicing disappointment in AI tool withdrawal, and one stating they had grown reliant on the tool. Across 22 free text entries, frequent themes included loss of clinical value or pathway efficiency, operational relief after withdrawal, and patient-facing emotional labor during AI-enabled escalation.

CONCLUSIONS: Decommissioning produces both operational relief and perceived clinical loss, with effects differing by staff role. We propose a three-phase AI Off-Boarding Protocol: prewithdrawal assessment, graduated transition and postwithdrawal support. Decommissioning management should be treated as a central part of responsible governance across the AI life cycle.

来源:J Am Coll Radiol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Packer, Dean, Storey, et al. Responsible Artificial Intelligence Off-Boarding in Radiology: Staff Perspectives on Decommissioning and a Proposed Withdrawal Framework. J Am Coll Radiol. 2026. PMID: 42251951. doi:10.1016/j.jacr.2026.06.004

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。