指南与共识介入技术与安全胸部US

急诊医学超声引导神经阻滞能力定义的德尔菲共识

Defining Ultrasound-Guided Nerve Block Competency for Emergency Medicine: A Delphi-Method Consensus Statement.
指南 / 共识 · AEM Educ Train · 2026-06-05

通过改良德尔菲方法,27名急诊医学与麻醉学专家对急诊医师超声引导神经阻滞能力定义达成共识。123项问卷条目中61项达成共识,涵盖能力定义、教学方法、评估方法和持续专业实践评价。该共识为住院医师培训、临床授权和质量保证提供结构化框架。

要点

  • 共识明确了急诊医师超声引导神经阻滞能力定义的多个维度,可用于指导培训与授权。
  • 关于确定能力所需的最少操作例数存在显著争议,未形成统一共识。
  • 超声引导神经阻滞是否应纳入核心超声权限仍存在不同意见,需机构自行决策。

核心结论

  • 该多学科改良德尔菲研究首次形成定义急诊医师超声引导神经阻滞能力的全国性共识。
  • 61项共识条目为住院医师课程、师资发展、临床授权和质量保证提供了结构化框架。

研究设计与样本

  • 研究类型为改良德尔菲共识研究,文献综述辅助形成123项问卷条目。
  • 27名专家(23名急诊医学、4名麻醉学)来自24家机构,完成两轮电子投票与讨论。
  • 共识预先定义为80%一致同意率。
  • 问卷覆盖四个领域:能力定义、教学方法、评估方法和持续专业实践评价。

诊断标准与关键数值

  • 123项条目中61项达成共识(80%一致同意率)。
  • 达成共识的条目分布:能力定义33项、教学方法14项、评估方法8项、持续专业实践评价6项。
  • 关于确定能力所需的最少操作例数未达成共识。
  • 关于超声引导神经阻滞是否应纳入核心超声权限未达成共识。

临床应用与阅片要点

  • 共识条目可作为制定超声引导神经阻滞住院医师培训课程和师资发展计划的参考框架。
  • 机构在建立UGNB临床授权标准和持续质量保证时可采用本共识的结构化条目。
  • 由于最少操作例数和核心权限归属未达成共识,各机构需根据自身情况制定具体要求。

局限性

  • 德尔菲法基于专家意见而非客观临床结局数据,共识条目可能受参与者专业背景影响。
  • 麻醉学专家仅4名,占比较低,可能影响跨学科视角的均衡性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开

BACKGROUND: Ultrasound-guided nerve blocks (UGNBs) are increasingly incorporated into multi-modal analgesia in the Emergency Department (ED). Despite their growing adoption, there is no consensus defining when an Emergency Medicine (EM) clinician is competent to perform UGNBs. Training methods, assessment approaches, and credentialing standards remain highly variable across institutions. The objective of this study was to define competency in UGNBs for EM physicians through a modified Delphi method that included national experts in EM and Anesthesia.

METHODS: A comprehensive librarian-assisted literature review informed the development of a 123-item questionnaire covering four domains: defining competency, teaching methods, assessment methods, and ongoing professional practice evaluation. Twenty-seven experts (23 EM, 4 anesthesiology) representing 24 institutions participated in two rounds of electronic voting and discussion. Consensus was defined a priori as 80% agreement.

RESULTS: All 27 panelists (100%) completed both rounds. Of 123 items, 61 achieved consensus: 33 items related to defining competency, 14 to teaching methods, 8 to assessment methods, and 6 to ongoing professional practice evaluation related to UGNBs. There was significant debate regarding the minimum number of UGNBs to determine competency and whether UGNBs should be included as a core ultrasound privilege.

CONCLUSION: This multidisciplinary modified Delphi provides the first national consensus defining competency in UGNBs for both practicing and EM physicians in training. The 61 consensus items offer a structured framework for residency curricula, faculty development, clinical privileging, and quality assurance. These recommendations may help guide forthcoming ACGME requirements and support safe, effective integration of UGNBs into emergency medicine training.

来源:AEM Educ Train,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Brown, Le, De Schutter, et al. Defining Ultrasound-Guided Nerve Block Competency for Emergency Medicine: A Delphi-Method Consensus Statement. AEM Educ Train. 2026. PMID: 42256842. doi:10.1002/aet2.70207

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。