疑似虐待儿童肋骨骨折:CT与X线诊断准确性多中心研究
该研究纳入64例小于2岁因疑似身体虐待接受胸片和胸部CT的患儿,由19位顾问放射科医师独立阅片,以初次及随访胸片为参考标准评估CT诊断肋骨骨折的准确性。结果显示CT在患者层面敏感度为90.6%、特异度为74.2%,提示CT可替代六次胸片方案用于疑似虐待的初始与随访影像评估。
要点
- 胸部CT对疑似虐待患儿肋骨骨折患者层面敏感度达90.6%,可用于替代初次及随访胸片方案
- 后部肋骨骨折CT敏感度为79.7%,阅片时需重点观察后肋区域避免漏诊
- CT在肋骨及部位层面特异度分别为94.16%和97.09%,阳性发现可信度较高
核心结论
- 胸部CT对疑似身体虐待患儿肋骨骨折具有较高诊断准确性,有潜力替代当前初始及随访六次胸片的标准方案
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性多中心诊断准确性观察研究,时间跨度为2011年9月至2021年9月共10年
- 纳入64例小于2岁因疑似身体虐待同时接受胸片和胸部CT的患儿,中位年龄2个月,其中男孩36例
- 由19位顾问放射科医师独立阅片,分三轮进行:第一轮仅初始胸片、第二轮仅CT、第三轮初始及随访胸片
- 影像判读内容包括肋骨骨折有无、骨折分期、骨折位置及诊断置信度
关键影像表现/征象
- CT在患者层面检出肋骨骨折的敏感度为90.6%(95% CI 88.2-92.6),特异度为74.2%(95% CI 70.2-78.0)
- CT在单根肋骨层面敏感度为85.6%(95% CI 84.1-87.0),特异度为94.16%(95% CI 93.8-94.4)
- CT在肋骨弓具体部位层面敏感度为75.7%(95% CI 74.0-77.4),特异度为97.09%(95% CI 96.9-97.2)
- CT对后部肋骨骨折的敏感度为79.7%
诊断标准与关键数值
- 参考标准为初次胸片联合随访胸片,以患者、单根肋骨、肋骨弓具体部位三个层面分别计算CT诊断准确性
- 患者层面CT诊断敏感度90.6%(95% CI 88.2-92.6),特异度74.2%(95% CI 70.2-78.0)
- 肋骨层面CT诊断敏感度85.6%(95% CI 84.1-87.0),特异度94.16%(95% CI 93.8-94.4)
- 部位层面CT诊断敏感度75.7%(95% CI 74.0-77.4),特异度97.09%(95% CI 96.9-97.2)
临床应用与阅片要点
- 对于疑似身体虐待的小于2岁患儿,胸部CT可作为替代六次胸片方案的影像选择,有助于缩短评估时间
- 阅片时后部肋骨区域CT敏感度相对较低,报告时应系统观察后肋弓,避免漏诊后部骨折
- CT在部位层面特异度高,阳性骨折发现可作为虐待评估的重要依据,但患者层面特异度仅74.2%需结合临床综合判断
局限性
- 回顾性研究设计本身可能存在选择偏倚和信息偏倚
- 以胸片作为参考标准,胸片本身对肋骨骨折存在漏诊可能,可能影响CT诊断准确性的评估
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVES: To assess the diagnostic accuracy of chest CT for rib fractures in live children investigated for suspected physical abuse (SPA), using initial and follow-up chest radiographs (CXRs) as the reference standard.
MATERIALS AND METHODS: A retrospective 10-year (September 2011-2021) multicentre search was performed for children less than two years of age who received CXRs and chest CT for SPA. Nineteen consultant radiologists independently read the images: Round 1 (initial CXRs only), Round 2 (CTs only) and Round 3 (initial and follow-up CXRs). No reporter performed Round 3 before Round 1 or 2. Radiologists reported the presence of rib fractures, fracture age, fracture location and confidence level. CT diagnostic accuracy (sensitivity, specificity, and accuracy) was calculated per patient, per rib and per specific location along the rib arc.
RESULTS: A total of 64 patients (36 boys) with a median age of 2 months were included and assessed by 19 independent consultant radiologists. Patient level analysis: CT sensitivity = 90.6% (95% confidence interval [CI]: 88.2-92.6), specificity = 74.2% (95% CI: 70.2-78.0). Rib level analysis: CT sensitivity = 85.6% (95% CI: 84.1-87.0), specificity = 94.16% (95% CI: 93.8-94.4). Location level analysis: CT sensitivity = 75.7% (95% CI: 74.0-77.4), specificity = 97.09% (95% CI: 96.9-97.2).
CONCLUSION: Chest CT confers accurate rib fracture detection in live children with SPA, with the potential to replace the current standard of performing six CXRs as part of initial and follow-up imaging for SPA.
KEY POINTS: Question What is the diagnostic performance of chest CT in detecting rib fractures in live children with SPA, using CXR as a reference standard? Findings Chest CT showed 90.6% sensitivity and 74.2% specificity for detecting rib fractures on patient-based analysis, with 79.7% sensitivity for posterior rib fractures. Clinical relevance Chest CT accurately detects rib fractures in children investigated for SPA and may serve as an alternative to initial and follow-up CXR, supporting timely clinical assessment and management.
引用
- Alzahrani, Paddock, Jeanes, et al. Rib fracture diagnosis in suspected abuse: Computed tomography or radiographs (RECEPTOR)? A multicentre diagnostic accuracy observational study. Eur Radiol. 2026. PMID: 41619005. doi:10.1007/s00330-026-12330-z
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。