儿童脑动静脉畸形分级一致性与不一致指数
本研究为单中心回顾性研究,纳入45例连续儿童脑动静脉畸形,由3名评分者在治疗前影像上进行Spetzler–Martin(SM)与Spetzler–Ponce(SP)分级,并开发病例级不一致指数(DI)。结果显示SM分级一致性较差,SP分级一致性改善但仍有38%病例跨至少一个SP边界,功能区和畸形团形态一致性最低。
要点
- 儿童AVM的SM分级和SP分级存在明显观察者间差异,报告时需警惕分级漂移。
- 功能区和畸形团形态最不稳定,是造成分级跨层和DI升高的主要来源。
- DI可用于教学反馈、数据质量控制和筛选需要多学科讨论的病例。
核心结论
- 儿童AVM分级一致性波动主要集中在主观描述项和具有临床意义的分层边界上,同一病变可被分入不同风险层级。
- SP分级较SM分级一致性提高,但仍有38%(17/45)病例在评分者间跨越至少一个SP边界。
- 功能区判定和畸形团形态一致性最低,是导致分级不稳定的关键因素。
研究设计与样本
- 单中心回顾性研究,纳入45例连续儿童脑动静脉畸形,在治疗前影像上由3名评分者进行独立分级。
- 记录SM各组成项与总分、SP分类、致密型与弥漫型畸形团形态,一致性采用ICC和κ统计评价。
- 病例级不一致指数(DI,0–1)综合了SP分类的评分者间离散度、SM分数离散度和SM组成项不匹配情况。
关键影像表现/征象
- 功能区和畸形团形态可重复性最低,畸形团大小和深静脉引流一致性相对较高。
- 功能区判定κ=0.29,畸形团形态κ=−0.15,畸形团大小κ=0.41,深静脉引流κ=0.58。
- 高DI病例主要由功能区判定不一致和SM II/III、SP A/B之间的分层边界跨越所驱动。
诊断标准与关键数值
- SM评分一致性ICC=0.72,SM分级分类一致性Fleiss κ=0.04。
- SP分类一致性κ=0.49,17/45例(38%)在评分者间跨越至少一个SP边界。
- 功能区κ=0.29,畸形团形态κ=−0.15,畸形团大小κ=0.41,深静脉引流κ=0.58。
- 不一致指数DI范围为0.15至1.00,中位数为0.46。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 在日常阅片和报告中报告儿童AVM分级时,应特别注意功能区和致密/弥漫型畸形团形态判定。
- 对位于SM II/III或SP A/B边界附近的AVM,应考虑进行多学科讨论或双人复核。
- DI可作为评分质量监控工具,用于培训反馈和识别分级不稳定病例。
局限性
- 单中心回顾性研究设计。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
PURPOSE: To quantify interobserver variability in Spetzler–Martin (SM) and Spetzler–Ponce (SP) grading of pediatric arteriovenous malformations (AVMs) and to develop a Disagreement Index (DI) capturing case-level grading instability and rater-dependent reclassification. METHODS: In this single-centre retrospective study, 45 consecutive pediatric AVMs were graded on pretreatment imaging by three raters. SM components/grade, SP class, and compact versus diffuse nidus morphology were recorded. Agreement was assessed using intraclass correlation coefficients (ICC) and κ statistics. A case-level DI (0–1) aggregated between-rater spread in SP class, dispersion of SM scores, and mismatches in SM components. RESULTS: SM score agreement was moderate (ICC = 0.72), whereas categorical agreement on SM grades was poor (Fleiss’ κ = 0.04). Collapsing into SP classes improved agreement (κ = 0.49), yet 17/45 AVMs (38%) crossed at least one SP boundary across raters. Eloquence (κ = 0.29) and nidus morphology (κ=−0.15) were least reproducible; nidus size and deep venous drainage showed higher agreement (κ = 0.41 and 0.58). DI ranged from 0.15 to 1.00 (median 0.46); high-DI cases were driven mainly by discordant eloquence and threshold crossings (SM II/III; SP A/B). CONCLUSIONS: In pediatric AVMs, grading variability clusters around subjective descriptors and clinically meaningful thresholds, allowing the same lesion to be assigned to different risk strata. DI may support trainee feedback, data-quality checks, and prioritisation of cases for multidisciplinary review.
引用
- Lioi, De Benedictis, Ferlito, et al. Interobserver variability of pediatric AVM grading: a disagreement index for training and calibration. Neuroradiology. 2026. PMID: 41571823. doi:10.1007/s00234-025-03902-9
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。