指南与共识外周血管技术与安全US

颈内静脉床旁超声能力评估工具的国际共识

Development of Validity Evidence of a Standardized Competency Tool for Internal Jugular Vein Point of Care Ultrasound: Consensus Recommendations from International Experts.
指南 / 共识 · J Gen Intern Med · 2026-01-08

研究采用改良Delphi法,由5名有颈内静脉超声经验的内科医师制定两套超声能力核查表,再由9名POCUS专家进行三轮共识。核查表1针对30–45°卧位超声JVP评估,核查表2针对直立位JVP评估。最终分别纳入18项与15项条目,并设定通过分数及关键条目。

要点

  • 核查表1用于30–45°卧位u-JVP评估,共18项条目,通过分数69.6%,关键条目4项。
  • 核查表2用于直立或90°位JVP评估,共15项条目,通过分数70.2%,关键条目3项。
  • 该工具可用于标准化评估学员颈内静脉POCUS操作熟练度,关键条目应重点关注。

核心结论

  • 改良Delphi法达成两套颈内静脉POCUS能力评估工具共识,可标准化评估学员操作熟练度。
  • 核查表1最终纳入18项条目,其中4项为关键条目;核查表2纳入15项条目,其中3项为关键条目。

研究设计与样本

  • 采用改良Delphi法的共识研究,由5名有颈内静脉超声经验的内科医师初步制定两套核查表。
  • 9名POCUS专家参与三轮改良Delphi评审,设定的共识标准为同意率不低于80%。
  • 共识形成后采用改良Angoff法设定通过分数并识别关键条目。

诊断标准与关键数值

  • 共识定义为条目同意率达到80%或以上,三轮后未达标条目被排除。
  • 核查表1原23项条目中18项达成共识,纳入比例为77%;通过分数为69.6%,4/18项判定为关键条目。
  • 核查表2原18项条目中15项达成共识,纳入比例为83%;通过分数为70.2%,3/15项判定为关键条目。

临床应用与阅片要点

  • 评估颈内静脉POCUS技能时可分别使用卧位u-JVP核查表与直立位JVP核查表。
  • 关键条目在能力考核中应作为重点观察内容,未通过关键条目可能影响整体判定。
  • 核查表通过明确条目和通过分数,可用于培训考核与学员操作反馈。

局限性

  • 原文未报告样本量统计效能和核查表在真实临床考核中的效度验证。
  • 共识专家仅9名,均来自POCUS领域,可能存在专业视角偏倚。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开

BACKGROUND: Central venous pressure (CVP) is traditionally evaluated by visually estimating the jugular venous pressure (JVP), but this examination can vary with patient anatomy and operator skill. Point-of-care ultrasound (POCUS) of the internal jugular vein (IJV) presents a promising alternative for evaluating the JVP but a standardized competency-based assessment tool is lacking.

OBJECTIVE: This study aimed to develop educational tools for assessing competency in IJV POCUS using a modified Delphi method.

DESIGN: Two ultrasound competency checklists were developed by five Internal Medicine physicians experienced in IJV ultrasound. Checklist 1 focused on ultrasound JVP (u-JVP) evaluation with patients positioned at 30-45°, while Checklist 2 focused on upright-JVP with patients in an upright or 90° position based on previously published techniques. Nine expert physicians in POCUS participated in three rounds of a modified Delphi process to determine consensus on checklist items. Consensus was defined as agreement of 80% or more; items that did not reach consensus after three rounds were excluded. A subsequent modified Angoff method was used to establish passing scores and identify critical items.

KEY RESULTS: After three rounds of the Delphi process, 18 of 23 items (77%) in Checklist 1 and 15 of 18 items (83%) in Checklist 2 reached consensus for inclusion. Passing scores were established at 69.6% for Checklist 1 and 70.2% for Checklist 2. Additionally, 4/18 items (22%) in Checklist 1 and 3/15 items (20%) in checklist 2 were identified as critical.

CONCLUSION: Using a modified Delphi method to appraise two competency assessment tools for POCUS evaluation of the IJV, we reached consensus on an 18-item checklist for u-JVP and a 15-item checklist for upright JVP, of which 4 and 3 items were deemed critical, respectively. By defining critical items and setting passing scores, these tools may help standardize the assessment of trainee proficiency in IJV POCUS.

来源:J Gen Intern Med,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Aguilar Franco, Rosenberg, Mohanty, et al. Development of Validity Evidence of a Standardized Competency Tool for Internal Jugular Vein Point of Care Ultrasound: Consensus Recommendations from International Experts. J Gen Intern Med. 2026. PMID: 41507643. doi:10.1007/s11606-025-10098-4

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。