三维谐波与次谐波成像用于乳腺病灶表征:多中心临床试验
这项前瞻性多中心研究纳入可疑乳腺病灶拟活检女性,评估三维超声造影(谐波HI与次谐波SHI)结合临床评分与定量参数对病灶的鉴别能力。219例数据中良性164例、恶性55例,超声准确率82%–85%优于标准影像72%,SHI结合临床读片的最佳回归模型准确率达97%,但读者间一致性中等至偏低(κ<0.52)。
要点
- 三维次谐波成像(SHI)可显示比谐波成像(HI)更多的血管吻合与血供。
- 超声造影联合临床评估可将可疑乳腺病灶诊断准确率提升至97%。
- SHI可提高诊断信心3%–6%,但读者间一致性仅中等至偏低。
核心结论
- 联合三维次谐波成像定量参数与临床评估可改善可疑乳腺病灶的表征。
- 超声(含造影模式)诊断准确率82%–85%,显著优于标准影像的72%。
研究设计与样本
- 前瞻性多中心临床研究,纳入拟活检的可疑乳腺病灶女性,最终219例数据可用。
- 采用改良Logiq 9扫描仪(GE Healthcare),行二维灰阶超声与能量多普勒后注射对比剂Definity(Lantheus)。
- 三维谐波成像发射/接收频率5.0/10.0 MHz,三维次谐波成像发射/接收频率5.8/2.9 MHz。
- 5名放射科医师独立对包括标准影像在内的各模式行7点BIRADS评分、病灶血管性及诊断信心评分。
- 以病理为参考标准,采用ROC与反向逐步逻辑回归分析诊断准确性,并计算κ统计量评估读者间一致性。
关键影像表现/征象
- 次谐波成像显示的血管吻合与血供多于谐波成像(P < .021),但按病理分组比较无差异(P > .27)。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 超声诊断准确率82%–85%,标准影像准确率72%(P < .03)。
- 最佳回归模型结合临床读片与次谐波成像定量参数,准确率达97%。
- 次谐波成像使诊断信心提高3%–6%(P < .05)。
- 读者间一致性κ < 0.52,为中等至偏低。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 阅片时可结合三维次谐波成像的血管吻合与血供信息辅助BIRADS分类。
- 定量参数(血管异质性、灌注、曲线下面积)可与临床评估联合用于提高诊断准确率。
- 注意读者间一致性中等至偏低,结果解读需结合多医师意见。
局限性
- 读者间一致性中等至偏低(κ < 0.52),可能影响重复性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVE: Breast cancer is the most frequent type of cancer among women. This multi-center study assessed the ability of 3D contrast-enhanced ultrasound to characterize suspicious breast lesions using clinical assessments and quantitative parameters.
METHODS: Women with suspicious breast lesions scheduled for biopsy were enrolled in this prospective, study. Following 2D grayscale ultrasound and power Doppler imaging (PDI), a contrast agent (Definity; Lantheus) was administrated. Contrast-enhanced 3D harmonic imaging (HI; transmitting/receiving at 5.0/10.0 MHz), as well as 3D subharmonic imaging (SHI; transmitting/receiving at 5.8/2.9 MHz), were performed using a modified Logiq 9 scanner (GE Healthcare). Five radiologists independently scored the imaging modes (including standard-of-care imaging) using a 7-point BIRADS scale as well as lesion vascularity and diagnostic confidence. Parametric volumes were constructed from time-intensity curves for vascular heterogeneity, perfusion, and area under the curve. Diagnostic accuracy was determined relative to pathology using receiver operating characteristic (ROC) and reverse, step-wise logistical regression analyses. The κ-statistic was calculated for inter-reader agreement.
RESULTS: Data were successfully acquired in 219 cases and biopsies indicated 164 (75%) benign and 55 (25%) malignant lesions. SHI depicted more anastomoses and vascularity than HI (P < .021), but there were no differences by pathology (P > .27). Ultrasound achieved accuracies of 82 to 85%, which was significantly better than standard-of-care imaging (72%; P < .03). SHI increased diagnostic confidence by 3 to 6% (P < .05), but inter-reader agreements were medium to low (κ < 0.52). The best regression model achieved 97% accuracy by combining clinical reads and parametric SHI.
CONCLUSIONS: Combining quantitative 3D SHI parameters and clinical assessments improves the characterization of suspicious breast lesions.
引用
- Forsberg F, Piccoli CW, Sridharan A, et al. 3D Harmonic and Subharmonic Imaging for Characterizing Breast Lesions: A Multi-Center Clinical Trial. J Ultrasound Med. 2021. PMID: 34694019. doi:10.1002/jum.15848
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。