验证人工智能方案用于非增强头部CT的急性分诊与正常排除
研究纳入英国、美国、印度3家机构的390例非增强头部CT,由3名FRCR顾问放射科医师确定参考标准,验证AI对颅内出血、急性梗死和正常的分类效能。AI对颅内出血、急性梗死和正常的AUC分别为0.988、0.933和0.939,颅内出血敏感度/特异度为0.988/0.925,急性梗死为0.833/0.927。AI排除正常扫描的阴性预测值为0.93%,可去除54.3%的正常病例。
要点
- AI对颅内出血的AUC为0.988(0.978-0.994),敏感度0.988、特异度0.925。
- AI对急性梗死的AUC为0.933(0.901-0.961),敏感度0.833、特异度0.927。
- AI排除正常扫描的阴性预测值为0.93%,去除54.3%的正常病例。
核心结论
- AI算法可有效分诊颅内出血和急性梗死以优先处理急重症患者,并识别91.3%的放射科医师颅内出血假阴性和69.1%的急性梗死假阴性;排除正常扫描可去除27.4%的全部扫描且未遗漏急性病变。
研究设计与样本
- 研究收集来自英国、美国、印度3家机构的390例头部CT扫描,由3名FRCR顾问放射科医师分配参考标准标签,并将AI性能与3名独立放射科医师对比。
诊断标准与关键数值
- AI对颅内出血的AUC为0.988(0.978-0.994),敏感度0.988、特异度0.925。
- AI对急性梗死的AUC为0.933(0.901-0.961),敏感度0.833、特异度0.927。
- AI对正常扫描的AUC为0.939(0.919-0.958)。
- 放射科医师对颅内出血的敏感度/特异度为0.907/0.991,对急性梗死为0.618/0.977。
- AI排除正常扫描的阴性预测值为0.93%,去除54.3%的正常病例;放射科医师的阴性预测值为86.8%。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
PURPOSE: Non-contrast CT head scans provide rapid and accurate diagnosis of acute head injury; however, increased utilisation of CT head scans makes it difficult to prioritise acutely unwell patients and places pressure on busy emergency departments (EDs). This study validates an AI algorithm to triage patients presenting with Intracranial Haemorrhage (ICH) or Acute Infarct whilst also identifying a subset of patients as Normal, with the potential to function as a rule-out test.
METHODS: In total, 390 CT head scans were collected from 3 institutions in the UK, US and India. Ground-truth labels were assigned by 3 FRCR consultant radiologists. AI performance, as well as the performance of 3 independent radiologists, was measured against ground-truth labels.
RESULTS: The algorithm showed AUC values of 0.988 (0.978-0.994), 0.933 (0.901-0.961) and 0.939 (0.919-0.958) for ICH, Acute Infarct and Normal, respectively. Sensitivity/specificity for ICH and Acute Infarct were 0.988/0.925 and 0.833/0.927, respectively, compared to 0.907/0.991 and 0.618/0.977 for radiologists. AI rule-out of Normal scans achieved 0.93% negative predictive value (NPV) for the removal of 54.3% of Normal cases, compared to 86.8% NPV for radiologists.
CONCLUSION: We show our algorithm can provide effective triage of ICH and Acute Infarct to prioritise acutely unwell patients. AI can also benefit clinical accuracy, with the algorithm identifying 91.3% of radiologist false negatives for ICH and 69.1% for Acute Infarct. Rule-out of Normal scans has huge potential for workload management in busy EDs, in this case removing 27.4% of all scans with no acute findings missed.
引用
- Dyer T, Chawda S, Alkilani R, et al. Validation of an artificial intelligence solution for acute triage and rule-out normal of non-contrast CT head scans. Neuroradiology. 2021. PMID: 34623478. doi:10.1007/s00234-021-02826-4
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。