使用AGREE II工具对介入放射学辐射防护指南质量的批判性评价:一项EuroAIM倡议
该研究于2021年4月15日系统检索MEDLINE、EMBASE、美国国家指南交换中心及美国国家卫生与临床优化研究所数据库中介入放射学辐射防护指南,最终纳入2009至2018年发表的11部指南,用AGREE II六域工具由三名作者独立评价。纳入指南总体质量中位72%(四分位距64-83%),仅1部(9%)总体低质量、4部(36%)总体高质量;「适用范围与目的」「表述清晰性」「编辑独立性」得分最高(分别为87%、76%、75%),「适用性」「制定严谨性」「利益相关方参与」得分最低(分别为46%、49%、52%)。
要点
- 纳入11部指南总体质量中位72%(四分位距64-83%),属可接受水平
- 仅1部(9%)总体低质量,4部(36%)总体高质量,其余为可接受质量
- 「适用性」域中位得分最低(46%),提示实际实施存在差距
核心结论
- 全部指南总体方法学质量可接受,其中三分之一达到最高质量等级;「适用性」域中位得分最低,提示未来指南需解决实际实施差距。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述与指南质量评价:2021年4月15日检索MEDLINE、EMBASE、美国国家指南交换中心及美国国家卫生与临床优化研究所数据库,最终纳入2009至2018年发表的11部介入放射学辐射防护指南;由三名作者独立使用AGREE II六域工具评价,总体质量分为低(<60%)、可接受(60-80%)、好(>80%)三类。
诊断标准与关键数值
- AGREE II六域工具评价;总体质量分级:低(<60%)、可接受(60-80%)、好(>80%);纳入指南总体质量中位72%(四分位距64-83%);各域中位得分:「适用范围与目的」87%、「表述清晰性」76%、「编辑独立性」75%、「利益相关方参与」52%、「制定严谨性」49%、「适用性」46%。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 作者认为「适用性」域中位得分最低,提示未来指南需解决实际实施差距。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
PURPOSE: To systematically review and assess the methodological quality of guidelines for radiation protection in interventional radiology.
MATERIALS AND METHODS: On April 15th, 2021, a systematic search for guidelines on radiation protection in interventional radiology was performed using MEDLINE, EMBASE, National Guideline Clearinghouse, and National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence databases. Among retrieved guidelines, we then excluded those not primarily focused on radiation protection or on interventional radiology. Authors' professional role and year of publication were recorded for each included guideline. Guideline quality evaluation was performed independently by three authors using the six-domain tool "AGREE II", with an overall guideline quality score divided into three classes: low (<60%), acceptable (60-80%), and good quality (>80%).
RESULTS: Our literature search identified 106 citations: after applying exclusion criteria, 11 guidelines published between 2009 and 2018 were included, most of their authors being interventional radiologists (168/224, 75%). Overall quality of included guidelines was acceptable (median 72%, interquartile range 64-83%), with only one guideline (9%) with overall low quality and four guidelines (36%) with overall good quality. Among AGREE II domains, "Scope and Purpose", "Clarity of Presentations", and "Editorial Independence" had the best results (87%, 76%, and 75% respectively), while "Applicability", "Rigor of Development", and "Stakeholder Involvement" the worst (46%, 49%, and 52% respectively).
CONCLUSION: Considering all guidelines, the overall methodological quality was acceptable with one third of them reaching the highest score class. The "Applicability" domain had the lowest median score, highlighting a practical implementation gap to be addressed by future guidelines.
引用
- Zanardo M, Gerasia R, Giovannelli L, et al. A critical appraisal of the quality of guidelines for radiation protection in interventional radiology using the AGREE II tool: A EuroAIM initiative. Eur J Radiol. 2021. PMID: 34479125. doi:10.1016/j.ejrad.2021.109906
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。