下肢复杂骨折外固定架患者CT:迭代金属伪影减少技术对金属伪影负荷与主观质量的影响
回顾性纳入56例下肢外固定架患者共72次CT检查,比较无iMAR与三种iMAR预设(iMARspine、iMARhip、iMARextremity)对金属伪影负荷和主观图像质量的影响。结果显示iMARhip和iMARextremity金属伪影负荷最低、主观质量最高,但所有iMAR预设均引入新的重建伪影。
要点
- 对规则、混合和单管外固定架,iMARhip与iMARextremity的金属伪影负荷低于noMAR和iMARspine,主观质量更高。
- iMARhip与iMARextremity之间伪影负荷和主观质量无显著差异。
- 所有iMAR预设均引入新的重建伪影,阅片时需注意识别。
核心结论
- 对三种外固定架类型,iMARhip和iMARextremity实现最大金属伪影负荷降低和最高主观图像质量,但两者均引入新的重建伪影。
- 使用这两种iMAR预设的CT可能有助于外固定架的围手术期管理。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性研究,纳入56例患者(20女,36男;平均年龄56±18岁)共72次CT检查,外固定架类型包括规则、混合和单管。
- 检查分别重建为无iMAR(noMAR)和三种iMAR预设(iMARspine、iMARhip、iMARextremity)。
- 由一名放射科住院医师用软件定量金属伪影负荷;两名放射科住院医师独立用4分制评估整体图像质量和诊断信心。
- 采用Bonferroni校正事后检验比较技术间差异;用组内相关系数(ICC)评估读者间一致性;用事后多项回归模型预测整体图像质量。
关键影像表现/征象
- 定量金属伪影负荷均值:noMAR为100,816±45,558,iMARspine为88,889±44,028,iMARhip为82,295±41,983,iMARextremity为81,956±41,890。
- 整体图像质量ICC≥0.94;合并读者数据的中位整体图像质量评分:规则固定架noMAR为2、iMARspine和iMARhip为3、iMARextremity为4;混合固定架noMAR为1、iMARspine为2、iMARhip和iMARextremity为3;单管固定架noMAR为2、iMARspine和iMARhip为3、iMARextremity为4。
- 所有固定架类型下,iMARhip和iMARextremity的金属伪影负荷低于noMAR和iMARspine、整体图像质量高于noMAR和iMARspine(p<.05),但规则固定架的iMARhip和iMARextremity与iMARspine的图像质量比较除外;iMARhip与iMARextremity间无差异(均p>.05)。
- 所有固定架和重建下诊断信心中位数均为4;所有iMAR预设对所有检查均引入新的重建伪影(两名读者均如此)。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 主观整体图像质量和诊断信心采用4分制(4=优秀,即最高质量或最高信心)。
- 相对于noMAR,整体质量的独立预测因素:iMARspine(OR=1.92-5.51)、iMARhip(OR=5.56-31.10)、iMARextremity(OR=7.07-38.21)。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 对下肢外固定架患者CT,可优先选用iMARhip或iMARextremity预设以降低金属伪影负荷并提高主观图像质量。
- 所有iMAR预设均会引入新的重建伪影,阅片和报告时需注意与真实病变鉴别。
- 诊断信心在各重建间均为中位4分,提示iMAR预设未降低诊断信心。
局限性
- 回顾性研究,样本量72次检查来自单中心56例患者。
- 所有iMAR预设均引入新的重建伪影,可能影响图像判读。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
BACKGROUND. Lower extremity external fixators have complex geometries that induce pronounced metal artifact on CT. Iterative metal artifact reduction (iMAR) algorithms help reduce such artifact, although no dedicated iMAR preset exists for external fixators. OBJECTIVE. The purpose of our study was to compare iMAR presets for CT examinations in terms of quantitative metal artifact burden and subjective image quality in patients with external fixators for complex lower extremity fractures. METHODS. This retrospective study included 72 CT examinations in 56 patients (20 women, 36 men; mean age, 56 ± 18 [SD] years) with lower extremity external fixators (regular, hybrid, or monotube). Examinations were reconstructed without iMAR (hereafter referred to as "noMAR") and with three iMAR presets (iMARspine, iMARhip, iMARextremity). A radiology resident quantified metal artifact burden using software. Two radiology residents independently assessed overall image quality and diagnostic confidence using 4-point scales (4 = excellent [highest quality or highest confidence]). Techniques were compared using Bonferroni-corrected post hoc tests. Interreader agreement was assessed by intraclass correlation coefficients (ICCs). A post hoc multinomial regression model was used for predicting overall image quality. RESULTS. Mean quantitative metal artifact burden was 100,816 ± 45,558 for noMAR, 88,889 ± 44,028 for iMARspine, 82,295 ± 41,983 for iMARhip, and 81,956 ± 41,890 for iMARextremity. Overall image quality yielded an ICC of 0.94 or greater. Using pooled reader data, median overall image quality score for the regular fixator was 2 (noMAR), 3 (iMARspine and iMARhip), and 4 (iMARextremity); for the hybrid fixator, 1 (noMAR), 2 (iMARspine), and 3 (iMARhip and iMARextremity); and for the monotube fixator, 2 (noMAR), 3 (iMARspine and iMARhip), and 4 (iMARextremity). Metal artifact burden was lower and overall image quality was higher (p < .05) for iMARhip and iMARextremity than noMAR and iMARspine for all fixators (aside from image quality of iMARhip and iMARextremity vs iMARspine for regular fixators) but were not different (all, p > .05) between iMARhip and iMARextremity. Median diagnostic confidence was 4 for all fixators and reconstructions. Independent predictors of overall quality relative to noMAR were iMARspine (odds ratio [OR] = 1.92-5.51), iMARhip (OR = 5.56-31.10), and iMARextremity (OR = 7.07-38.21). All iMAR presets introduced new reconstruction artifacts for all examinations for both readers. CONCLUSION. For the three fixator types, iMARhip and iMARextremity achieved greatest metal artifact burden reduction and highest subjective image quality, although both introduced new reconstruction artifacts. CLINICAL IMPACT. CT using the two identified iMAR presets may facilitate perioperative management of external fixators.
引用
- Brendlin AS, Reinert CP, Baumgartner H, et al. CT in Patients With External Fixation for Complex Lower Extremity Fractures: Impact of Iterative Metal Artifact Reduction Techniques on Metal Artifact Burden and Subjective Quality. AJR Am J Roentgenol. 2021. PMID: 34523951. doi:10.2214/AJR.21.26442
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。