双能CT影像组学特征在三种不同扫描仪间的稳健性
在65keV虚拟单能图和虚拟平扫图上提取774个特征,以CCC≥0.9为稳健标准,患者来源的稳健特征比例很低(约2.5%–16.1%),且体模实验未能印证患者中少数稳健特征。结论提示双能CT影像组学特征跨平台泛化性有限。
要点
- 跨双能CT平台的影像组学特征稳健性普遍偏低,模型迁移需谨慎。
- 患者中稳健特征比例在VMI65keV下约2.5%–16.1%,VUE下约2.7%–11.1%。
- 体模实验未复现患者中少数稳健特征,体模不能替代患者验证。
核心结论
- 三种双能CT扫描仪之间,患者来源的影像组学特征稳健性低,少数稳健特征未在体模中得到印证,跨平台模型泛化性可能受限。
研究设计与样本
- 在标准化图像处理后,于体模组织及患者表现正常的肝、脾、肌肉组织放置ROI,基于65keV虚拟单能图和虚拟平扫图提取774个影像组学特征(86个原始特征及其8种小波变换)。
- 以一致性相关系数(CCC)≥0.9判定特征稳健,并用方差分析评估扫描仪间差异。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 以CCC≥0.9作为特征稳健的阈值,评估三种双能CT平台两两之间的影像组学特征稳健性。
- 患者VMI65keV稳健特征比例:双源vs快速kV切换16.1%(125/774),双层探测器vs快速kV切换2.5%(19/774),双源vs双层探测器2.6%(20/774)。
- 患者VUE稳健特征比例:双源vs快速kV切换11.1%(86/774),双层探测器vs快速kV切换2.8%(22/774),双源vs双层探测器2.7%(21/774)。
- 方差分析无显著差异的特征比例在患者中为51.4%–71.1%,在体模中为60.6%–73.4%。
- 体模来源特征在任何扫描仪间比较中均未达到高稳健性阈值。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 基于单一双能CT平台特征构建的影像组学模型在换用其他平台时需重新验证,阅片报告引用组学结果时应注明设备平台。
- 采用CCC≥0.9等稳健性筛选并优先选择跨平台稳定的特征,可减少设备差异带来的偏差。
局限性
- 体模实验结果与患者结果不一致,体模无法完全反映临床条件下的跨平台稳健性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVES: To investigate the robustness of radiomic features between three dual-energy CT (DECT) systems.
METHODS: An anthropomorphic body phantom was scanned on three different DECT scanners, a dual-source (dsDECT), a rapid kV-switching (rsDECT), and a dual-layer detector DECT (dlDECT). Twenty-four patients who underwent abdominal DECT examinations on each of the scanner types during clinical follow-up were retrospectively included (n = 72 examinations). Radiomic features were extracted after standardized image processing, following ROI placement in phantom tissues and healthy appearing hepatic, splenic and muscular tissue of patients using virtual monoenergetic images at 65 keV (VMI65keV) and virtual unenhanced images (VUE). In total, 774 radiomic features were extracted including 86 original features and 8 wavelet transformations hereof. Concordance correlation coefficients (CCC) and analysis of variances (ANOVA) were calculated to determine inter-scanner robustness of radiomic features with a CCC of ≥ 0.9 deeming a feature robust.
RESULTS: None of the phantom-derived features attained the threshold for high feature robustness for any inter-scanner comparison. The proportion of robust features obtained from patients scanned on all three scanners was low both in VMI65keV (dsDECT vs. rsDECT:16.1% (125/774), dlDECT vs. rsDECT:2.5% (19/774), dsDECT vs. dlDECT:2.6% (20/774)) and VUE (dsDECT vs. rsDECT:11.1% (86/774), dlDECT vs. rsDECT:2.8% (22/774), dsDECT vs. dlDECT:2.7% (21/774)). The proportion of features without significant differences as per ANOVA was higher both in patients (51.4-71.1%) and in the phantom (60.6-73.4%).
CONCLUSIONS: The robustness of radiomic features across different DECT scanners in patients was low and the few robust patient-derived features were not reflected in the phantom experiment. Future efforts should aim to improve the cross-platform generalizability of DECT-derived radiomics.
KEY POINTS: • Inter-scanner robustness of dual-energy CT-derived radiomic features was on a low level in patients who underwent clinical examinations on three DECT platforms. • The few robust patient-derived features were not confirmed in our phantom experiment. • Limited inter-scanner robustness of dual-energy CT derived radiomic features may impact the generalizability of models built with features from one particular dual-energy CT scanner type.
引用
- Lennartz S, O'Shea A, Parakh A, et al. Robustness of dual-energy CT-derived radiomic features across three different scanner types. Eur Radiol. 2021. PMID: 34542695. doi:10.1007/s00330-021-08249-2
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。