急性主动脉综合征的急诊CT误诊
该横断面研究回顾性分析2013年1月至2016年12月一家大型健康委员会三家收治成人患者的急性医院内连续88例确诊急性主动脉综合征(AAS)病例,评估急诊CT报告与最终诊断的差异。31%(27例)存在至少一处差异,包括未识别或误判AAS 15%(13例)、出血13%(11例)、分支受累9%(8例)、分类错误3%(3例),所有差异均发生于无心血管专科兴趣的放射科医生报告的80%(70例)病例中;26%(23/88)转诊时临床未怀疑AAS,仅51%的疑似病例CT技术充分。结论认为急诊CT评估中显著差异常见,无心血管专科兴趣的放射科医生报告者差异突出,提示疑似和确诊AAS病例均需紧急专科复核。
要点
- 无心血管专科兴趣的放射科医生报告的AAS病例中31%存在诊断差异,专科兴趣医生报告的病例未见差异。
- 主要差异包括未识别或误判AAS(15%)、出血(13%)、分支受累(9%)和分类错误(3%)。
- 26%的AAS病例转诊时临床未怀疑,仅51%的疑似病例CT扫描技术充分,运动伪影导致3例假阳性。
核心结论
- 急诊CT对AAS阳性病例的评估中显著差异常见,技术及判读存在重要陷阱;无心血管专科兴趣的放射科医生报告的全部病例均出现差异,提示疑似和确诊病例均需紧急专科复核。
研究设计与样本
- 横断面研究,回顾性识别2013年1月至2016年12月一家大型健康委员会三家收治成人患者的急性医院内连续88例确诊AAS病例,由两位心血管放射科医生复核初次CT及报告,评估差异、报告者专科兴趣、转诊时临床怀疑及扫描技术充分性,并单独评估假阳性诊断。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 在88例连续确诊AAS病例中,31%(27例)至少存在一处差异,包括未识别或误判AAS 15%(13例)、出血13%(11例)、分支受累9%(8例)、分类错误3%(3例)。
- 所有差异均发生于无心血管专科兴趣的放射科医生报告的80%(70例)病例中。
- 26%(23/88)的AAS病例转诊时临床未怀疑,仅51%的疑似病例CT扫描技术充分。
- 识别7例假阳性诊断,其中3例与运动伪影相关。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 作者认为,疑似和确诊AAS病例均需紧急心血管专科影像复核。
- 作者指出,CT技术和判读均存在重要陷阱,支持在AAS急诊评估中常规引入心血管专科影像意见。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVES: This cross-sectional study assessed the accuracy of emergency CT reports at presentation in acute aortic syndrome (AAS).
METHODS: Retrospective identification of cases of AAS presenting within a large health board with three acute hospitals receiving adult patients between January 2013 and December 2016. CT studies and reports at presentation were reviewed for discrepancies related to diagnosis, complications and classification by two cardiovascular radiologists. The specialist interest of the original reporters, clinically suspected diagnosis at referral for CT and technical adequacy of the scans were also assessed. False-positive diagnoses were identified and evaluated separately.
RESULTS: Among 88 consecutive confirmed cases of AAS at least one discrepancy was identified in 31% (n = 27), including failure to identify or misinterpretation of the AAS itself in 15% (n = 13), haemorrhage in 13% (n = 11), branch involvement in 9% (n = 8), and misclassification in 3% (n = 3). All discrepancies occurred among the 80% (n = 70) of cases reported by radiologists without specialist cardiovascular interest. 26% (n = 23/88) of AAS cases were not clinically suspected at referral for CT and although this was associated with suboptimal protocols, only 51% of CT scans among suspected cases were technically adequate. Seven false-positive diagnoses were identified, three of which related to motion artefact.
CONCLUSION: Significant discrepancies are common in the emergency CT assessment of positive cases AAS and this study highlights important pitfalls in CT technique and interpretation. The absence of discrepancies among radiologists with specialist cardiovascular interest suggests both suspected and confirmed cases warrant urgent specialist review.
ADVANCES IN KNOWLEDGE: CT angiography is central to the diagnosis of AAS; however, significant radiology discrepancies are common among non-specialists. This study highlights important pitfalls in both CT technique as well as interpretation and supports routine specialist cardiovascular imaging input in the emergency assessment of AAS.
引用
- Dreisbach JG, Rodrigues JC, Roditi G, et al. Emergency CT misdiagnosis in acute aortic syndrome. Br J Radiol. 2021. PMID: 34491770. doi:10.1259/bjr.20201294
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。