基础重症超声心动图培训的能力标准、流程与判定:LUCC 倡议的德尔菲共识声明
该共识由 21 名基础重症超声心动图(BCCE)专家参与改良德尔菲流程,2020 年 4 月至 2021 年 5 月共四轮,条目纳入阈值为≥80% 同意、排除阈值为≤30%。共识确定了纵向 BCCE 培训须包含入门培训、导师指导的形成性培训、能力终结性评估和最终认知评估,并统一了图像采集与判读的通过标准及形成性与终结性评估标准。作者指出这些推荐需前瞻性验证。
要点
- 纵向 BCCE 培训须包含入门培训、导师指导的形成性培训、能力终结性评估和最终认知评估。
- 图像采集与判读质量采用形成性与终结性评估相同的客观标准,并将 BCCE 发现分为主要与次要。
- 共识统一了错误标准化处理、终结性评估准备标准及监督方式;推荐需前瞻性验证。
核心结论
- 该专家共识就纵向 BCCE 培训提出综合的循证推荐,但这些推荐需前瞻性验证。
研究设计与样本
- 改良德尔菲流程,采用经验证的 AGREE-II 工具原则,基于系统综述选择领域;2020 年 4 月至 2021 年 5 月共 21 名 BCCE 专家参与四轮,第 1、2 轮为五份网络问卷(含分支逻辑软件定向提问),第 3 轮为视频会议投票定稿,第 4 轮在期刊同行评议期间以网络问卷进行。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 每轮后条目纳入的同意阈值为≥80%,排除阈值为≤30%;第 1、2 轮后 114 个条目中 62 个达成一致,第 3 轮对 49 个未解决条目新增 12 个条目,其中 56 个达成一致、5 个未解决。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 共识推荐纵向 BCCE 培训须包括入门培训、导师指导的形成性培训、能力终结性评估和最终认知评估;图像采集与判读质量的形成性与终结性评估采用相同标准,将 BCCE 发现分为主要与次要,并标准化错误处理、终结性评估准备标准及监督方式。
局限性
- 原文指出这些推荐需前瞻性验证(require prospective validation)。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
BACKGROUND: With the paucity of high-quality studies on longitudinal basic critical care echocardiography (BCCE) training, expert opinion guidelines have guided BCCE competence educational standards and processes. However, existing guidelines lack precise detail due to methodological flaws during guideline development.
RESEARCH QUESTIONS: To formulate methodologically robust guidelines on BCCE training using evidence and expert opinion, detailing specific criteria for every step, we conducted a modified Delphi process using the principles of the validated AGREE-II tool. Based on systematic reviews, the following domains were chosen: components of a longitudinal BCCE curriculum; pass-grade criteria for image-acquisition and image-interpretation; and formative/summative assessment and final competence processes.
STUDY DESIGN AND METHODS: Between April 2020 and May 2021, a total of 21 BCCE experts participated in four rounds. Rounds 1 and 2 used five web-based questionnaires, including branching-logic software for directed questions to individual panelists. In round 3 (videoconference), the panel finalized the recommendations by vote. During the journal peer-review process, Round 4 was conducted as Web-based questionnaires. Following each round, the agreement threshold for each item was determined as ≥ 80% for item inclusion and ≤ 30% for item exclusion.
RESULTS: Following rounds 1 and 2, agreement was reached on 62 of 114 items. To the 49 unresolved items, 12 additional items were added in round 3, with 56 reaching agreement and five items remaining unresolved. There was agreement that longitudinal BCCE training must include introductory training, mentored formative training, summative assessment for competence, and final cognitive assessment. Items requiring multiple rounds included two-dimensional views, Doppler, cardiac output, M-mode measurement, minimum scan numbers, and pass-grade criteria. Regarding objective criteria for image-acquisition and image-interpretation quality, the panel agreed on maintaining the same criteria for formative and summative assessment, to categorize BCCE findings as major vs minor and a standardized approach to errors, criteria for readiness for summative assessment, and supervisory options.
INTERPRETATION: In conclusion, this expert consensus statement presents comprehensive evidence-based recommendations on longitudinal BCCE training. However, these recommendations require prospective validation.
引用
- Rajamani A, Galarza L, Sanfilippo F, et al. Criteria, Processes, and Determination of Competence in Basic Critical Care Echocardiography Training: A Delphi Process Consensus Statement by the Learning Ultrasound in Critical Care (LUCC) Initiative. Chest. 2021. PMID: 34508739. doi:10.1016/j.chest.2021.08.077
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。