Ahlbäck评分能否识别中重度膝骨关节炎软骨厚度丢失的不同亚组?
本研究基于骨关节炎倡议(OAI)108例KLG 3/4患者,用基线X线评估Ahlbäck评分,并分析基线至1年3D FLASH MRI的软骨厚度变化。结果显示Ahlbäck各亚组间股胫关节、内侧和外侧间室及OV1的软骨厚度变化无显著差异,仅Ahlbäck 4组OV16变化显著高于Ahlbäck 1-3组(p=0.03)。结论认为Ahlbäck评分在预测1年软骨厚度丢失方面不优于KLG,支持继续使用更简便的KLG。
要点
- Ahlbäck评分未能将中重度膝OA患者按软骨厚度丢失速度有效分层。
- 仅Ahlbäck 4组OV16(软骨增厚区)变化显著高于Ahlbäck 1-3组。
- 日常评估中继续使用KLG分级即可,无需用Ahlbäck评分替代。
核心结论
- Ahlbäck评分对中重度膝OA患者1年软骨厚度丢失的预测不优于KLG分级。
研究设计与样本
- 基于OAI队列的108例KLG 3/4膝OA患者,基线KLG来自OAI数据库,Ahlbäck评分用同一X线片评估。
- 软骨厚度变化采用基线及1年3D FLASH MRI分析整个股胫关节、内侧间室、外侧间室及有序值OV1和OV16。
关键影像表现/征象
- Ahlbäck各亚组间股胫关节、内侧间室、外侧间室及OV1的软骨厚度变化无统计学显著差异。
- Ahlbäck 4组OV16变化显著高于Ahlbäck 1-3组(p=0.03)。
诊断标准与关键数值
- KLG 3对应Ahlbäck 1,KLG 4细分为Ahlbäck 2-5。
- 108例中KLG 3/4分别为30/78例,Ahlbäck 1-5分别为30/33/36/9/10例。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 在中重度膝OA的影像评估和临床试验患者筛选中,可继续使用简便的KLG分级。
- Ahlbäck评分对软骨厚度丢失的预测价值有限,不宜作为分层依据。
局限性
- 样本量有限(108例),仅分析1年随访数据。
- Ahlbäck评分基于同一X线片回顾性评估,可能存在读片变异性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVE: Kellgren-Lawrence grades (KLG) are frequently used for patient selection in clinical trials. The Ahlbäck radiographic grading system has been developed for moderate and severe knee OA. KLG 3 is comparable to Ahlbäck 1 and KLG 4 is subdivided into Ahlbäck 2-5. The objective of this study was to investigate if the Ahlbäck scoring system is able to subdivide patients with moderate to severe knee OA (KLG 3/4) into groups with different sensitivity to change in cartilage thickness.
MATERIALS AND METHODS: This study was based on 108 Osteoarthritis Initiative (OAI) participants with KLG 3/4. Baseline KLG scores were available from the OAI database; Ahlbäck scores were performed using the same x-rays. Cartilage thickness change in the weight-bearing femorotibial cartilage was analysed from baseline and year 1 3D FLASH MRI for the entire femorotibial joint (FTJ), the medial (MFTC) and the lateral compartment (LFTC) and for the location-independent ordered values 1 and 16 (OV 1/OV 16) representing the subregions with largest loss (OV 1) and gain (OV 16) within each knee.
RESULTS: Of the 108 patients, n = 30/78 had KLG 3/4. The corresponding Ahlbäck scores (1-5) were n = 30/33/36/9/10. Cartilage thickness changes between Ahlbäck groups showed no statistically significant difference for FTJ, MFTC, LFTC and OV 1, but change in OV 16 was significantly higher in Ahlbäck 4 knees (p = 0.03) compared to Ahlbäck 1-3 knees.
CONCLUSION: Radiographic knee OA grading with Ahlbäck scores was not superior to KLG for prediction of cartilage thickness loss over 1 year, in patients with moderate and severe knee OA supporting the continuous use of the easier and more widely used KLG.
引用
- Hangaard S, Boesen M, Bliddal H, et al. Do Ahlbäck scores identify subgroups with different magnitudes of cartilage thickness loss in patients with moderate to severe radiographic osteoarthritis? One-year follow-up data from the Osteoarthritis Initiative. Skeletal Radiol. 2021. PMID: 34347112. doi:10.1007/s00256-021-03871-z
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。