疑似SLAP损伤的影像学检查:成本效果研究
本研究从美国医疗系统角度构建决策分析模型,模拟25岁既往诊断SLAP损伤患者,比较1.5-T和3-T MRI及MR关节造影等策略的增量成本效果。结果显示,非增强3-T MRI策略最具成本效果且占优;若无3-T,则1.5-T MRA优于1.5-T MRI。主要驱动因素是3-T MRI和1.5-T MRA分别具有最高特异性,减少假阳性与不必要手术。
要点
- 疑似SLAP损伤时,非增强3-T MRI是最具成本效果的影像策略。
- 无3-T设备时,1.5-T MRA比1.5-T MRI更具成本效果。
- 策略优势主要源于更高特异性,减少假阳性及不必要手术。
核心结论
- 非增强3-T MRI策略是疑似SLAP损伤患者最具成本效果的影像选择,且优于3-T MRA和1.5-T MRI/MRA。
- 当3-T成像不可用时,1.5-T MRA比1.5-T MRI更具成本效果。
研究设计与样本
- 研究为成本效果分析,基于决策分析模型,从美国医疗系统角度、2年时间跨度模拟25岁既往诊断SLAP损伤患者。
- 模型比较1.5-T和3-T MR关节造影(MRA)与非增强MRI协议组合及相应治疗策略。
- 成本、概率和效用估计来自全面文献检索,成本以2017年美元计,主要效果指标为质量调整生命年。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 主要效果结局为质量调整生命年,成本以2017年美元估算。
- 概率敏感性分析确认非增强3-T MRI为优势策略;无3-T时1.5-T MRA为优选。
- 3-T MRI和1.5-T MRA在各自场景中特异性最高,减少假阳性、避免不必要手术并降低成本。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 对疑似SLAP损伤患者,优先选用非增强3-T MRI以平衡成本与效果。
- 若机构无3-T设备,1.5-T MRA较1.5-T MRI更具成本效果,可减少假阳性。
- 报告时应关注特异性相关征象,避免假阳性导致的不必要手术。
局限性
- 研究为基于文献参数的决策模型,非直接患者队列验证。
- 视角为美国医疗系统,结果外推至其他医疗体系需谨慎。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
BACKGROUND. Superior labrum anterior and posterior (SLAP) tears are a common shoulder pathology. Although MRI is the imaging reference standard for diagnosis of this pathology, the cost-effectiveness of common MRI strategies is unclear. OBJECTIVE. The primary objective of our study was to determine the cost-effectiveness of the common MRI-based strategies used for the diagnosis of SLAP tears. METHODS. We created decision analytic models from the perspective of the U.S. health care system over a 2-year time horizon for a hypothetical population of 25-year-old patients with a previous diagnosis of SLAP tear. We used the decision models to compare the differences in incremental cost-effectiveness of the common MRI strategies, which included combinations of 1.5-T and 3-T MR arthrography (MRA) and unenhanced MRI protocols, and the resulting treatment applied for these patients. Input data on cost, probability, and utility estimates were obtained through a comprehensive literature search. The primary effectiveness outcome was quality-adjusted life years. Costs were estimated in 2017 U.S. dollars. RESULTS. When all imaging strategies were considered, the unenhanced 3-T MRI-based imaging strategy was the preferred and dominant option over 3-T MRA and 1.5-T imaging (MRI and MRA). When the model was run without 3-T imaging as an option, 1.5-T MRA was the favored option. Probabilistic sensitivity analyses confirmed the same preferred imaging strategy results. CONCLUSION. An unenhanced 3-T MRI-based strategy is the most cost-effective imaging option for patients with suspected SLAP tear. When 3-T imaging is not available, 1.5-T MRA is more cost-effective than 1.5-T MRI. The main driver of these results is the fact that 3-T MRI and 1.5-T MRA are the most specific tests in these respective scenarios, which results in fewer false-positives, prevents unnecessary surgeries, and leads to decreased costs. CLINICAL IMPACT. Our cost-effectiveness model findings complement prior diagnostic accuracy work, helping produce a more comprehensive approach to define imaging utility for radiologists, clinicians, and patients with SLAP tears who have access to various types of MRI options.
引用
- Gyftopoulos S, Conroy J, Koo J, et al. Imaging of Patients Suspected of SLAP Tear: A Cost-Effectiveness Study. AJR Am J Roentgenol. 2021. PMID: 34406055. doi:10.2214/AJR.21.26420
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。