Bosniak 2019版分类在CT与MRI评估囊性肾脏肿块中的比较
结果显示CT与MRI的类别一致性中等(原始版70.8%,2019版72.3%),MRI可识别更多分隔和突起;2019版在CT和MRI上均较原始版提高特异度并保持敏感度。
要点
- Bosniak 2019版在CT和MRI上均较原始版提高特异度,敏感度保持。
- MRI较CT可显示更多分隔(p<0.001)和更多突起(p=0.034)。
- CT与MRI的Bosniak分类一致性中等(kappa 0.60-0.63),阅片时需注意模态差异。
核心结论
- Bosniak 2019版分类在CT和MRI上均较原始版提高特异度并保持敏感度,总体准确度更高。
- 同一囊性肿块在CT与MRI上获得的Bosniak类别存在差异,一致性中等。
研究设计与样本
- 3名放射科医生(R2、R3、R4)独立先评估CT、后评估MRI,间隔至少1个月分别采用Bosniak原始版和2019版分类,评估分隔数量、分隔/壁厚度和突起,分歧由R1共识解决。
关键影像表现/征象
- MRI较CT识别更多分隔(p<0.001)和更多突起(p=0.034)。
- 分隔/壁厚度(p=0.067,0.855)和突起大小(p=0.467)在CT与MRI间无差异。
诊断标准与关键数值
- CT与MRI的Bosniak原始版分类一致率为70.8%(kappa=0.60,p=0.0146),2019版一致率为72.3%(kappa=0.63,p=0.006)。
- Bosniak 2019版特异度:CT 79.0%(95%CI 71.0-87.0%),MRI 70%(95%CI 62.0-77.0%);原始版特异度:CT 63.0%(95%CI 56.0-69.0%),MRI 66.0%(95%CI 58.0-74.0%)。
- 观察者间一致性:Bosniak 2019版K=0.44(CT)、0.39(MRI);原始版K=0.35(CT)、0.37(MRI)。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 在报告囊性肾脏肿块时,采用Bosniak 2019版分类可提高特异度,减少良性病变的过度诊断。
- 需注意MRI可能显示比CT更多的分隔和突起,可能导致类别上调,阅片时应结合多模态评估。
局限性
- 观察者间一致性仅为中等(K=0.35-0.44),分类可重复性有限。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVE: To compare imaging features in cystic masses imaged with both CT and MRI using Bosniak Classification version 2019 (Bosniak.v2019) and original Bosniak Classification (Bosniak.original).
MATERIALS AND METHODS: This IRB-approved, retrospective, cross-sectional study evaluated sixty-five consecutively identified cystic (≤ 25% enhancing) masses imaged by CT and MRI between 2009 and 2019: 35 with histologic diagnosis and 30 Bosniak.v2019 Class 2 and Class 2F cystic masses verified by an expert radiologist (R1) with minimum 5-year stability. Three radiologists (R2, R3, R4) independently evaluated CT, followed by MRI and assigned Bosniak.original and Bosniak.v2019 class in two sessions separated by ≥ 1 month and assessed the following: septa number, septa/wall thickness, and protrusions. Discrepancies were resolved by consensus with R1.
RESULTS: There was 70.8% agreement (kappa = 0.60, p = 0.0146) in class assigned by CT versus MRI for Bosniak.original and 72.3% agreement (kappa = 0.63, p = 0.006) for Bosniak.v2019. Increased septa number (p < 0.001) and more protrusions (p = 0.034) were identified on MRI, with no differences in septal/wall thickness (p = 0.067, 0.855) or protrusion size (p = 0.467). For both CT and MRI, Bosniak.v2019 improved specificity (79.0% [95% confidence interval 71.0-87.0%] CT, 70% [62.0-77.0%] MRI) compared to Bosniak.original (63.0% [56.0-69.0%] CT, 66.0% [58.0-74.0%] MRI) with maintained sensitivity and higher overall accuracy. Inter-observer agreement was similar-to-slightly higher for Bosniak.v2019 (K = 0.44 CT, 0.39 MRI) versus Bosniak.original (K = 0.35 CT, 0.37 MRI).
CONCLUSION: Class assignment differs in cystic masses evaluated by CT versus MRI for original and v2019 Bosniak Classification with similar-to-slightly higher agreement and improved specificity and higher overall accuracy on both CT and MRI with Bosniak version 2019.
引用
- Chan J, Yan JH, Munir J, et al. Comparison of Bosniak Classification of cystic renal masses version 2019 assessed by CT and MRI. Abdom Radiol (NY). 2021. PMID: 34390368. doi:10.1007/s00261-021-03236-z
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。