计算机辅助诊断在肺癌CT筛查Lung-RADS分类中的应用:对读者间一致性的影响
该研究从国家肺癌筛查试验中随机选取200例覆盖所有Lung-RADS类别的基线CT,由5名放射科医师分别在不使用和使用CAD的情况下独立分类。CAD使读者间一致性从中等(Fleiss κ=0.60)轻微提升至显著(κ=0.65),并减少了结节大小测量的差异和癌症阳性病例中的重大管理差异。
要点
- CAD对Lung-RADS分类的读者间一致性仅有轻微提升(κ从0.60到0.65)。
- CAD可减少结节大小测量的不一致比例(从5.1%降至3.1%)。
- 癌症阳性病例中,CAD使读者对之间的重大管理差异减半。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 不使用CAD时,5名读者对Lung-RADS分类的读者间一致性为中等(Fleiss κ=0.60,95%CI 0.57-0.63)。
- 使用CAD时,读者间一致性提升至显著(Fleiss κ=0.65,95%CI 0.63-0.68)。
- 使用CAD后,读者倾向于上调而非下调Lung-RADS类别(平均上调12.3%,平均下调4.4%)。
- 不一致的主要原因是两次阅片中选择的主要风险结节不同(不使用CAD时54.2%[201/371],使用CAD时63.6%[232/365])。
- 结节大小测量的不一致比例从5.1%(102/2000)降至3.1%(62/2000),p<0.001。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 在日常阅片中,CAD可辅助减少结节大小测量的变异性,但需注意其可能轻微提升读者间一致性。
- CAD使用后读者更倾向于上调Lung-RADS类别,报告时应注意避免过度分期。
- 在癌症阳性病例中,CAD有助于减少读者间重大管理差异(如随访间隔至少9个月的差异)。
局限性
- 本研究为回顾性设计,样本来自单一临床试验队列。
- 仅纳入200例基线CT,样本量有限。
- CAD系统仅呈现最多5个风险主导结节,可能遗漏其他结节。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVES: To evaluate the effects of computer-aided diagnosis (CAD) on inter-reader agreement in Lung Imaging Reporting and Data System (Lung-RADS) categorization.
METHODS: Two hundred baseline CT scans covering all Lung-RADS categories were randomly selected from the National Lung Cancer Screening Trial. Five radiologists independently reviewed the CT scans and assigned Lung-RADS categories without CAD and with CAD. The CAD system presented up to five of the most risk-dominant nodules with measurements and predicted Lung-RADS category. Inter-reader agreement was analyzed using multirater Fleiss κ statistics.
RESULTS: The five readers reported 139-151 negative screening results without CAD and 126-142 with CAD. With CAD, readers tended to upstage (average, 12.3%) rather than downstage Lung-RADS category (average, 4.4%). Inter-reader agreement of five readers for Lung-RADS categorization was moderate (Fleiss kappa, 0.60 [95% confidence interval, 0.57, 0.63]) without CAD, and slightly improved to substantial (Fleiss kappa, 0.65 [95% CI, 0.63, 0.68]) with CAD. The major cause for disagreement was assignment of different risk-dominant nodules in the reading sessions without and with CAD (54.2% [201/371] vs. 63.6% [232/365]). The proportion of disagreement in nodule size measurement was reduced from 5.1% (102/2000) to 3.1% (62/2000) with the use of CAD (p < 0.001). In 31 cancer-positive cases, substantial management discrepancies (category 1/2 vs. 4A/B) between reader pairs decreased with application of CAD (pooled sensitivity, 85.2% vs. 91.6%; p = 0.004).
CONCLUSIONS: Application of CAD demonstrated a minor improvement in inter-reader agreement of Lung-RADS category, while showing the potential to reduce measurement variability and substantial management change in cancer-positive cases.
KEY POINTS: • Inter-reader agreement of five readers for Lung-RADS categorization was minimally improved by application of CAD, with a Fleiss kappa value of 0.60 to 0.65. • The major cause for disagreement was assignment of different risk-dominant nodules in the reading sessions without and with CAD (54.2% vs. 63.6%). • In 31 cancer-positive cases, substantial management discrepancies between reader pairs, referring to a difference in follow-up interval of at least 9 months (category 1/2 vs. 4A/B), were reduced in half by application of CAD (32/310 to 16/310) (pooled sensitivity, 85.2% vs. 91.6%; p = 0.004).
引用
- Park S, Park H, Lee SM, et al. Application of computer-aided diagnosis for Lung-RADS categorization in CT screening for lung cancer: effect on inter-reader agreement. Eur Radiol. 2021. PMID: 34331112. doi:10.1007/s00330-021-08202-3
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。