指南与共识腹部技术与安全MR

成人克罗恩病MR小肠造影关键表型的SAR-AGA共识报告阅片者间一致性:放射科医生经验的影响

Inter-reader agreement of the Society of Abdominal Radiology-American Gastroenterological Association (SAR-AGA) consensus reporting for key phenotypes at MR enterography in adults with Crohn disease: impact of radiologist experience.
指南 / 共识 · Abdom Radiol (NY) · 2021-07-29

回顾性评估99例成人克罗恩病MR小肠造影,比较2名经验丰富与2名经验较少放射科医生对SAR-AGA共识关键表型(活动性肠道炎症、狭窄、穿透性疾病、肛周疾病等)的阅片者间一致性。全体阅片者对穿透性疾病、脓肿、肛周脓肿一致性几乎完美(κ>0.90),对回肠炎症、近端小肠炎症、狭窄一致性强(κ 0.80-0.90),经验较少者在初诊与随访间回肠炎症及狭窄一致性有显著差异,经验丰富者随访肛周瘘一致性显著降低。

要点

  • 全体阅片者对穿透性疾病、脓肿、肛周脓肿一致性几乎完美(κ>0.90)。
  • 全体阅片者对活动性回肠炎、近端小肠炎及狭窄一致性强(κ 0.80-0.90)。
  • 经验较少者初诊回肠炎一致性κ 0.68低于随访κ 0.96(p=0.018)。

核心结论

  • SAR-AGA共识推荐的关键克罗恩病表型(活动性回肠炎、近端小肠炎、狭窄、穿透性疾病、脓肿、肛周脓肿)阅片者间一致性为强至几乎完美;一致性较低的部分可作为未来教育目标以进一步标准化克罗恩病MRE报告;随访MRE应包含专用肛周序列。

研究设计与样本

  • 回顾性研究,纳入99例克罗恩病患者的MR小肠造影(50例初诊、49例随访),检查时间为2019年1月1日至2020年3月20日;由2名经验丰富和2名经验较少的放射科医生评估活动性肠道炎症(胃、近端小肠、回肠、结肠)、狭窄、可能狭窄、穿透性疾病及肛周疾病;MRE方案未包含专用肛周序列;采用患病率调整偏倚调整kappa评估阅片者间一致性并按经验水平比较。

关键影像表现/征象

  • 全体阅片者对穿透性疾病、脓肿及肛周脓肿在所有99例克罗恩病患者中一致性几乎完美(κ>0.90)。
  • 全体阅片者对活动性回肠炎、近端小肠炎及狭窄在所有99例克罗恩病患者中一致性强(κ 0.80-0.90)。
  • 经验较少者初诊MRE活动性回肠炎一致性κ 0.68 vs 随访κ 0.96(随访较初诊升高,p=0.018)。
  • 经验较少者随访MRE狭窄一致性κ 0.76 vs 初诊κ 1.0(随访较初诊降低,p=0.027)。
  • 经验丰富者随访MRE肛周瘘一致性κ 0.55 vs 初诊κ 0.92(随访较初诊降低,p=0.008)。

诊断标准与关键数值

  • 活动性肠道炎症评估部位包括胃、近端小肠、回肠、结肠。
  • 穿透性疾病、脓肿及肛周脓肿的阅片者间一致性κ>0.90。
  • 活动性回肠炎、近端小肠炎及狭窄的阅片者间一致性κ 0.80-0.90。

临床应用与阅片要点

  • 原文结论指出一致性较低的部分可作为未来教育目标以进一步标准化克罗恩病MRE报告,并建议随访MRE应包含专用肛周序列。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开

PURPOSE: To assess inter-reader agreement of key features from the SAR-AGA recommendations for the interpretation and reporting of MRE in adult patients with CD, focusing on the impact of radiologist experience on inter-reader agreement of CD phenotypes.

METHODS: Two experienced and two less-experienced radiologists retrospectively evaluated 99 MRE in CD patients (50 initial MRE, 49 follow-up MRE) performed from 1/1/2019 to 3/20/2020 for the presence of active bowel inflammation (stomach, proximal small bowel, ileum, colon), stricture, probable stricture, penetrating disease, and perianal disease. The MRE protocol did not include dedicated perianal sequences. Inter-rater agreement was determined for each imaging feature using prevalence-adjusted bias-adjusted kappa and compared by experience level.

RESULTS: All readers had almost-perfect inter-reader agreement (κ > 0.90) for penetrating disease, abscess, and perianal abscess in all 99 CD patients. All readers had strong inter-reader agreement (κ: 0.80-0.90) in 99 CD patients for active ileum inflammation, proximal small bowel inflammation, and stricture. Less-experienced readers had significantly lower inter-reader agreement for active ileum inflammation on initial than follow-up MRE (κ 0.68 versus 0.96, p = 0.018) and for strictures on follow-up than initial MRE (κ 0.76 versus 1.0, p = 0.027). Experienced readers had significantly lower agreement for perianal fistula on follow-up than initial MRE (κ: 0.55 versus 0.92, p = 0.008).

CONCLUSION: There was strong to almost-perfect inter-reader agreement for key CD phenotypes described in the SAR-AGA consensus recommendations including active ileum and proximal small bowel inflammation, stricture, penetrating disease, abscess, and perianal abscess. Areas of lower inter-reader agreement could be targeted for future education efforts to further standardize CD MRE reporting. Dedicated perianal sequences should be included on follow-up MRE.

来源:Abdom Radiol (NY),查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Dane B, Qian K, Gauvin S, et al. Inter-reader agreement of the Society of Abdominal Radiology-American Gastroenterological Association (SAR-AGA) consensus reporting for key phenotypes at MR enterography in adults with Crohn disease: impact of radiologist experience. Abdom Radiol (NY). 2021. PMID: 34324038. doi:10.1007/s00261-021-03229-y

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。