基于深度神经网络模型评估青春期肘关节X线片上快速进展的骨龄
本研究从两家机构获取4437对青春期个体的肘关节正侧位X线片,构建并验证深度神经网络模型,以Sauvegrain法(基于肱骨小头、滑车、尺骨鹰嘴突和桡骨近端骨骺形态的评分系统)由五名训练有素的研究者建立参考标准骨龄。外部机构测试集(n=141)中,模型与五名专家的平均绝对差异为0.19至0.30年,与参考标准的平均绝对差异为0.22年;模型与阅片者间ICC为0.98。结论认为模型评估青春期快速进展骨龄的表现与专家相似。
要点
- 模型与专家评估青春期快速进展骨龄的平均绝对差异为0.19至0.30年(外部测试集)。
- 尺骨鹰嘴突准确率最高(74.5%),桡骨骨骺最低(63.1%)。
- 模型与阅片者间一致性ICC为0.98,阅片者间ICC为0.99。
核心结论
- 基于肘关节X线片的深度神经网络模型评估青春期快速进展骨龄的表现与专家相似,平均绝对差异为0.22年(与参考标准比)。
研究设计与样本
- 研究从两家机构获取4437对青春期个体肘关节正侧位X线片,用于构建和验证深度神经网络模型;参考标准骨龄由五名训练有素的研究者采用Sauvegrain法(基于肱骨小头、滑车、尺骨鹰嘴突和桡骨近端骨骺形态的评分系统)建立;测试集(n=141)来自外部机构。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 内部验证中,模型与阅片者骨龄评估的平均绝对差异为0.15年。
- 外部测试集中,模型与五名专家的平均绝对差异为0.19至0.30年,与参考标准的平均绝对差异为0.22年。
- 模型与阅片者间一致性ICC为0.98,阅片者间一致性ICC为0.99。
- 亚部分分析中,尺骨鹰嘴突准确率最高(74.5%),其次为滑车(73.7%)、肱骨小头(73.7%),桡骨骨骺最低(63.1%)。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 原文指出,青春期骨龄对脊柱侧弯或肢体长度差异患者确定疾病阶段尤为重要,影响手术时机和方法的选择。
- 原文指出,常用基于手部X线片的方法在评估青春期骨龄时存在局限性,因该时期手和腕部骨骼形态变化不甚明显。
- 原文结论认为,基于肘关节X线片训练的深度神经网络模型在评估青春期快速进展骨龄方面表现出与人类专家相似的表现。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVES: Bone age is considered an indicator for the diagnosis of precocious or delayed puberty and a predictor of adult height. We aimed to evaluate the performance of a deep neural network model in assessing rapidly advancing bone age during puberty using elbow radiographs.
METHODS: In all, 4437 anteroposterior and lateral pairs of elbow radiographs were obtained from pubertal individuals from two institutions to implement and validate a deep neural network model. The reference standard bone age was established by five trained researchers using the Sauvegrain method, a scoring system based on the shapes of the lateral condyle, trochlea, olecranon apophysis, and proximal radial epiphysis. A test set (n = 141) was obtained from an external institution. The differences between the assessment of the model and that of reviewers were compared.
RESULTS: The mean absolute difference (MAD) in bone age estimation between the model and reviewers was 0.15 years on internal validation. In the test set, the MAD between the model and the five experts ranged from 0.19 to 0.30 years. Compared with the reference standard, the MAD was 0.22 years. Interobserver agreement was excellent among reviewers (ICC: 0.99) and between the model and the reviewers (ICC: 0.98). In the subpart analysis, the olecranon apophysis exhibited the highest accuracy (74.5%), followed by the trochlea (73.7%), lateral condyle (73.7%), and radial epiphysis (63.1%).
CONCLUSIONS: Assessment of rapidly advancing bone age during puberty on elbow radiographs using our deep neural network model was similar to that of experts.
KEY POINTS: • Bone age during puberty is particularly important for patients with scoliosis or limb-length discrepancy to determine the phase of the disease, which influences the timing and method of surgery. • The commonly used hand radiographs-based methods have limitations in assessing bone age during puberty due to the less prominent morphological changes of the hand and wrist bones in this period. • A deep neural network model trained with elbow radiographs exhibited similar performance to human experts on estimating rapidly advancing bone age during puberty.
引用
- Ahn KS, Bae B, Jang WY, et al. Assessment of rapidly advancing bone age during puberty on elbow radiographs using a deep neural network model. Eur Radiol. 2021. PMID: 34115194. doi:10.1007/s00330-021-08096-1
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。