诊断放射学中的肿瘤相关错误:基于医疗事故索赔的10年分析
该研究回顾性分析了2008至2017年间美国医疗事故数据库中的放射学索赔案例,发现肿瘤相关案例占放射学诊断性索赔的44.0%,且肿瘤相关案例中高严重性伤害占79%,远高于非肿瘤案例的42%;影像误判是肿瘤相关案例的主要贡献因素(80.7%),最常涉及乳腺X线和CT。
要点
- 肿瘤是放射学诊断性索赔的最大来源,占44.0%,高于其他任何疾病类别。
- 肿瘤相关放射学案例中97.4%为诊断性指控,非肿瘤案例仅55.0%为诊断性指控。
- 影像误判是肿瘤相关诊断性案例的主要贡献因素,占80.7%。
核心结论
- 肿瘤是放射学诊断性索赔的最大来源;肿瘤相关案例更可能归因于诊断错误,且与非肿瘤案例相比更常伴随高严重性伤害;需要努力减少肿瘤影像的误判。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性分析,使用美国Controlled Risk Insurance Company的Comparative Benchmarking System数据库(涵盖美国约30%的医疗事故索赔),检索2008至2017年期间以放射学为主要服务的索赔案例,按肿瘤与非肿瘤状态、指控类型(诊断性与非诊断性)和成像方式分层比较。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 在10年期间,放射学占所有医疗事故索赔的3.9%(2,582/66,061),占诊断性指控索赔的12.8%(1,756/13,695)。
- 肿瘤(新生物)占放射学诊断性指控案例的44.0%,份额大于其他任何疾病类别。
- 在放射学诊断性指控案例中,高严重性伤害在肿瘤案例中占79%,在非肿瘤案例中仅占42%。
- 在所有肿瘤相关放射学案例中,97.4%为诊断性指控,而非肿瘤案例中仅55.0%为诊断性指控。
- 影像误判是肿瘤相关放射学诊断性案例的主要贡献因素,占80.7%(623/772);涉及误判的肿瘤相关诊断性案例最常用的检查方式为乳腺X线和CT。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 作者认为,需要努力减少肿瘤影像的误判。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
PURPOSE: To retrospectively analyze the nature and extent of oncology-related errors accounting for malpractice allegations in diagnostic radiology.
METHODS: The Comparative Benchmarking System of the Controlled Risk Insurance Company, a database containing roughly 30% of medical malpractice claims in the United States, was searched retrospectively for the period 2008 to 2017. Claims naming radiology as a primary service were identified and were stratified and compared by oncologic versus nononcologic status, allegation type (diagnostic versus nondiagnostic), and imaging modality.
RESULTS: Over the 10-year period, radiology was the primary responsible service for 3.9% of all malpractice claims (2,582 of 66,061) and 12.8% of claims with diagnostic allegations (1,756 of 13,695). Oncology (neoplasms) accounted for 44.0% of radiology cases with diagnostic allegations, a larger share than any other category of medical condition. Among radiology cases with diagnostic allegations, high-severity harm occurred in 79% of oncologic but just 42% of nononcologic cases. Of all oncologic radiology cases, 97.4% had diagnostic allegations, and just 55.0% of nononcologic radiology cases had diagnostic allegations. Imaging misinterpretation was a contributing factor for a large majority (80.7% [623 of 772]) of oncologic radiology cases with diagnostic allegations. The modalities most commonly used in oncologic radiology cases with diagnostic allegations involving misinterpretation were mammography and CT.
CONCLUSION: Oncology represents the largest source of radiology malpractice cases with diagnostic allegations. Oncologic radiology malpractice cases are more likely than nononcologic radiology cases to be due to diagnostic errors. Furthermore, compared with those that are nononcologic, oncologic radiology cases with diagnostic allegations are more likely to be associated with high-severity harm. Efforts are warranted to reduce misinterpretations of oncologic imaging.
引用
- Rosenkrantz AB, Siegal D, Skillings JA, et al. Oncologic Errors in Diagnostic Radiology: A 10-Year Analysis Based on Medical Malpractice Claims. J Am Coll Radiol. 2021. PMID: 34058137. doi:10.1016/j.jacr.2021.05.001
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。