虚拟平扫图像衰减测量的纵向可重复性:多厂商双能CT评估
回顾性纳入137例重复腹部双能CT患者,比较快速kV切换、双层探测器和双源三种扫描仪虚拟平扫衰减测量的纵向可重复性。总可重复率分别为94.9%、93.8%和90.6%,脂肪变异最低,主动脉、门静脉和肾脏最高。增强图像衰减的纵向差异显著影响虚拟平扫衰减的纵向差异。
要点
- 虚拟平扫衰减测量的纵向可重复率:快速kV切换94.9%、双层探测器93.8%、双源90.6%。
- 脂肪的纵向变异最低为4.0%,主动脉13.3%、门静脉10.8%、肾脏10.7%最高。
- 增强图像衰减的纵向差异显著影响虚拟平扫衰减的纵向差异(p<0.001,t值4.34)。
核心结论
- 三种双能CT扫描仪的虚拟平扫衰减纵向可重复性均较高,但纵向变异受增强影响,在血管和肾脏中幅度最大且扫描仪间差异显著。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性研究纳入137例重复腹部双能CT患者,快速kV切换组46例、双层探测器组43例、双源组48例,在虚拟平扫及对应增强图像上测量肝、脾、肾、主动脉、门静脉和脂肪的衰减。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 测量差异≤10 HU视为可重复;快速kV切换可重复率94.9%,双层探测器93.8%,双源90.6%。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVES: The accuracy of virtual unenhanced (VUE) images has been extensively investigated, yet data on their longitudinal reproducibility is limited. The study purpose was to evaluate the longitudinal reproducibility of VUE attenuation measurements on three different dual-energy CT (DECT) scanner types.
METHODS: A total of 137 patients with repeated abdominal DECT either on a rapid kV switching (rsDECT; n = 46), a dual-layer detector (dlDECT; n = 43), or a dual-source scanner (dsDECT; n = 48) were retrospectively included. Attenuation was measured on VUE and corresponding contrast-enhanced images in the liver, spleen, kidneys, aorta, portal vein, and fat. Longitudinal reproducibility was evaluated by calculating the absolute inter-scan differences (HU) and the inter-scan variation (%). Measurement pairs with differences ≤ 10 HU were considered reproducible. Influence of contrast-enhanced attenuation on VUE reproducibility was analyzed using linear regression.
RESULTS: The scanner-specific cohorts showed similar age (p-range: 0.35-0.99), sex (p-range: 0.68-1), body weight (p-range: 0.26-0.87), body diameter (p-range: 0.34-0.76), and inter-scan time (p-range: 0.52-0.83). In total, 94.9% of VUE measurements were reproducible for rsDECT, 93.8% for dlDECT, and 90.6% for dsDECT. Overall inter-scan variation was lowest in fat (4.0 (1.7-8.2)%) and highest in tissues with high contrast enhancement: the aorta (13.3 (4.6-21.3)%), portal vein (10.8 (5.7-19.8)%), and kidneys (10.7 (3.9-18.0)%). Significant differences in inter-scan variation were found between the scanner types for the aorta, portal vein, kidneys, and spleen. Inter-scan differences in contrast-enhanced attenuation significantly influenced inter-scan differences in VUE attenuation (p < 0.001; t-ratio: 4.34).
CONCLUSIONS: Longitudinal reproducibility of VUE attenuation was high for all scanners, yet inter-scan variation of VUE attenuation was influenced by contrast enhancement, showing greatest magnitude and discrepancy between scanner types in vessels and the kidneys.
KEY POINTS: • We found that 94.9% of attenuation measurements on virtual unenhanced images were reproducible for rapid kV switching DECT, 93.8% for dual-layer detector DECT, and 90.6% for dual-source DECT. • Inter-scan variation of attenuation in virtual unenhanced images was comparable between the three scanner types in the liver and fat, whereas inter-scan variation in the spleen, kidneys, portal vein, and aorta showed significant differences between scanner types (p < 0.05). • Inter-scan attenuation differences in contrast-enhanced images significantly influenced inter-scan differences in virtual unenhanced attenuation (p < 0.001, t-ratio: 4.34), suggesting a residual impact of contrast enhancement differences between examinations.
引用
- Lennartz S, Parakh A, Cao J, et al. Longitudinal reproducibility of attenuation measurements on virtual unenhanced images: multivendor dual-energy CT evaluation. Eur Radiol. 2021. PMID: 34110426. doi:10.1007/s00330-021-08083-6
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。