机会性应用无体模校准方法通过QCT/FEA预测骨折风险
研究提出基于受试者自身组织的无体模校准方法,用于QCT/FEA估计椎体骨折属性,并与DXA的aBMD值进行相关性分析。无体模方程与体模估计的BMD高度相关(99%),QCT/FEA预测的骨折载荷与体模法结果高度相关(0.94-0.99),与DXA-aBMD中度相关(0.64-0.68)。结论认为无体模校准方法在临床中有应用潜力。
要点
- 无体模校准方程与基于体模的BMD估计高度相关(99%)。
- 无体模QCT/FEA预测的骨折载荷与体模法结果高度相关(0.94-0.99)。
- 无体模QCT/FEA预测与DXA-aBMD中度相关(0.64-0.68)。
核心结论
- 提出的基于受试者组织的无体模校准方法在QCT/FEA中显示出应用于临床前瞻性和回顾性应用的潜力。
研究设计与样本
- 研究使用111例临床QCT扫描中的80例,通过体模校准方法获取受试者特异性参数并开发无体模校准方程,方程基于不同软组织和区域的HU值及多元线性回归分析;另用31例QCT扫描对基于体模和无体模方程的QCT/FEA估计的L3椎体骨折载荷进行交叉验证,并将QCT/FEA预测的骨折载荷与DXA获得的aBMD进行相关性分析。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 无体模方程与基于体模的BMD估计相关系数为99%。
- 无体模方程与体模特异性结果在QCT/FEA预测的骨折载荷交叉验证中相关系数为0.94-0.99。
- 无体模方程的QCT/FEA预测结果与DXA-aBMD的相关系数为0.64-0.68。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVES: Quantitative computed tomography (QCT)-based finite element analysis (FEA) implements a calibration phantom to estimate bone mineral density (BMD) and assign material properties to the models. The objectives of this study were to (1) propose robust phantom-less calibration methods, using subject-specific tissues, to obtain vertebral fracture properties estimations using QCT/FEA; and (2) correlate QCT/FEA predictions to DXA values of areal BMD.
METHODS: Eighty of a cohort of 111 clinical QCT scans were used to obtain subject-specific parameters using a phantom calibration approach and for the development of the phantom-less calibration equations. Equations were developed based on the HU measured from various soft tissues and regions, and using multiple linear regression analyses. Thirty-one additional QCT scans were used for cross-validation of QCT/FEA estimated fracture loads from the L3 vertebrae based on the phantom and phantom-less equations. Finally, QCT/FEA-predicted fracture loads were correlated with aBMD obtained from DXA.
RESULTS: Overall, 217 QCT/FEA models from 31 subjects (20 females, 11 men) with mean ages of 69.6 (13.1) and 67.3 (14) were used to cross-validate the phantom-less equations and assess bone strength. The proposed phantom-less equations showed high correlations with phantom-based estimates of BMD (99%). Cross-validation of QCT/FEA-predicted fracture loads from phantom-less equations and phantom-specific outcomes resulted in high correlations for all proposed methods (0.94-0.99). QCT/FEA correlation outcomes from the phantom-less equations and DXA-aBMD were moderately high (0.64-0.68).
CONCLUSIONS: The proposed QCT/FEA subject-specific phantom-less calibration methods demonstrated the potential to be applied to both prospective and retrospective applications in the clinical setting.
KEY POINTS: • QCT/FEA overcomes the disadvantages of DXA and improves fracture properties predictions of vertebrae. • QCT/FEA fracture estimates using the phantom-less approach highly correlated to values obtained using a calibration phantom. • QCT/FEA prediction using a phantom-less approach is an accurate alternative over phantom-based methods.
引用
- Prado M, Khosla S, Chaput C, et al. Opportunistic application of phantom-less calibration methods for fracture risk prediction using QCT/FEA. Eur Radiol. 2021. PMID: 34047849. doi:10.1007/s00330-021-08071-w
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。