公众号 / 文章儿科影像技术与安全

儿童虐待诊断中的伦理挑战:误诊的危害是什么

Ethical challenges in child abuse: what is the harm of a misdiagnosis?
PubMed 文献 · Pediatr Radiol · 2021-05-17

本文探讨儿童虐待诊断中假阴性(漏诊)与假阳性(误诊)危害权衡的伦理张力及其在法庭程序中的表现。作者指出儿童虐待医师(包括儿科放射科医师)在知晓虐待总体上漏诊远多于过度诊断的前提下做出日常决策,而辩护方强调临床决策与不公正现象相关。作者认为儿童虐待医师可通过采取措施减轻偏见感知并更明确承认误诊危害来与刑事辩护律师建立信任,专业学会可帮助准备专家证言。

要点

  • 儿童虐待医师(含儿科放射科医师)需权衡漏诊与误诊儿童虐待的潜在后果。
  • 医师在知晓虐待总体上漏诊远多于过度诊断的前提下做出日常实践决策。
  • 辩护方专家证人资质违反专业标准,证言基于同行评议不足的文献。

核心结论

  • 儿童虐待医师可能通过采取措施减轻偏见感知并更明确承认误诊的潜在危害,来与刑事辩护律师建立信任。
  • 代表这些医师的专业学会(如儿科放射学会)可同时采取措施帮助其成员医师更好地准备专家证言并使其更易出庭作证。

临床应用与阅片要点

  • 儿童虐待医师(包括儿科放射科医师)承担权衡漏诊与误诊儿童虐待潜在后果的重大责任。
  • 医师在知晓虐待总体上漏诊远多于过度诊断的前提下做出日常实践决策。
  • 辩护方专家证人资质违反专业标准,提供基于同行评议不足文献的一贯有缺陷的证言。
  • 作者认为儿童虐待医师可能通过采取措施减轻偏见感知并更明确承认误诊的潜在危害来与刑事辩护律师建立信任。
  • 作者认为代表这些医师的专业学会(如儿科放射学会)可同时采取措施帮助其成员医师更好地准备专家证言并使其更易出庭作证。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开

In this article the author examines ethical tensions inherent to balancing harms of false-negative and false-positive child abuse diagnoses, and he describes how such tensions manifest in courtroom proceedings. Child abuse physicians, including pediatric radiologists, shoulder heavy responsibilities weighing the potential consequences of not diagnosing child abuse when it could have been diagnosed (false negatives) against the consequences of making the diagnosis when it has not occurred (false positives). These physicians, who practice under ethical obligations to serve children's best interests and protect them from harm, make daily practice decisions knowing that, on balance, abuse is substantially more underdiagnosed than over diagnosed. Legal justice advocates, however, emphasize that clinical decision-making around abuse is not disassociated from endemic injustices that unduly incriminate individuals from socioeconomically underprivileged populations. Some defense advocates charge that child abuse physicians are insufficiently sensitive to harms of erroneous diagnoses, and they have characterized these clinicians as frankly biased. To support their claims in court, defense advocates have enlisted likeminded physician witnesses whose credentials as experts flout professional standards and who provide consistently flawed testimony based upon deficiently peer-reviewed literature. This article concludes that, to help mitigate these unhealthy circumstances, child abuse physicians might build trust with criminal defense advocates by instituting measures to alleviate perceptions of biases and by more explicitly acknowledging the potential harms of erroneous diagnoses. Professional societies representing these physicians, such as the Society for Pediatric Radiology, could take concurrent measures to help better prepare their constituent clinicians for expert testimony and make them more available to testify.

来源:Pediatr Radiol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Brown SD. Ethical challenges in child abuse: what is the harm of a misdiagnosis? Pediatr Radiol. 2021. PMID: 33999247. doi:10.1007/s00247-020-04845-4

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。